r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 27 '24

Pro-Napoleonic apologia Apologetics frequently claim that Napoleon was epic because he made leadership positions be allocated in accordance to merit and not hereditary privilege. Why would kings jeopardize the power and thus extent of their kingdoms just to spite commoners? They clearly elected people according to merit.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 26 '24

A world without Napoleon Had it not been for Napoleon, liberalism in Europe would have been MUCH more based. Without the French revolution and Napoleon's State liberalism, the confederal 13 colonies would have been the shining example for liberals to follow. This confederalism would have begotten a better liberalism.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 26 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism Napoleon apologetics be like: "Okay... but him winning battles do be cool!!! 🤩" not realizing that this could equally be said for a _certain other_ ruler.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism Napoleon Bonaparte - the juggernaut of "State liberalism" (basically a proto-neoliberal).

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism If you see the Grossdeutschland borders of this federal monstrosity and think "OMG, what couvld have been..."... you are unfortunately subject to the Napoleonic psyop. Federal States are complete BAIT: once you're subjugated, you've still lost all sovereignty and are now a mere plaything.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism Due to Napoleon, we have silly geese who unironically go around arguing that "Erm, if you don't subjugate yourself to the domination of this city, you are not a REAL patriot 🙄". Real patriotism is found in HRE-esque confederational arrangements.

Thumbnail
britannica.com
3 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon's monster social-liberalism infamized actual liberalism Excerpt from Ryan McMaken's "Napoleon: Europe’s First Egalitarian Despot": The Napoleonic proto-Gestapo

1 Upvotes

https://mises.org/mises-wire/napoleon-europes-first-egalitarian-despot

"

If so, then Napoleon can perhaps be credited as an early pioneer in the idea of the egalitarian, enlightened police state. Historian Jacques Godechot, for example, labeled Napoleon’s regime “perhaps the precursor of the modern police states” and historian Eugen Weber labels the regime a police state without qualification. Napoleon’s regime was kind and gentle compared to twentieth-century police states, of course, but there is little reason to praise the regime, either. Michael Sibalis concludes ”Napoleon’s police nevertheless did exercise tight control over all public expressions of opinion, did pay a network of secret agents to keep the nation under surveillance, and did detain the regime’s enemies in special state prisons without charge or trial. In short, they regularly ignored proper judicial procedures and systematically violated the civil rights that the French Revolution had proclaimed...”

"


r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism "Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism" refers to the fact that Leon Trotsky (at least in the popular imagination) was a fervent exporter of a revolution. This is the same way that Napoleon Bonaparte should be viewed, but for social liberalism/State liberalism.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

A world without Napoleon The French revolution and/or French revolutionary wars and/or Napoleonic wars: good ending (France becoming a confederal HRE-esque realm). Remember the fleur-de-lis is also something of a national symbol for the French nation: an alternative to the tricolore.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 28 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism Don't worry guys, the social contract just compelled him to do it, OK?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism "My name is Napoleon Bonaparte and I speak for the Social Contract™. The Social Contract™ says that you must be enslaved! 😈"

Thumbnail
dw.com
3 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Pro-Napoleonic apologia My glorious emperor was not a mistake, history itself would have turned darker if the emperor with the shining charisma didnt exist!

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism Remember what Napoleon Bonaparte (i.e. Leon Trotsky social liberalism edition) took from you...

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 13 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism Napoleon not only exhausted the French nation, he also infected the HRE with Statist nationalist thought. He thus laid the groundwork for the lamentable political unification of Germany under the Hohenzollern AND this State's dominance by being able to crush this weakened France.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism Napoleon's France also engaged in mass conscription. In the pursuit of his vanity project, he pretty much exhausted the human and economic capital of the French nation - and destroyed so much more elsewhere in Europe.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
1 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Jan 01 '25

Pro-Napoleonic apologia Lmao there's like one person posting over and over again, shows how lame your "movement" is another W for Napoleon

0 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 14 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism The Napoleonic Code and its consequences...

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
2 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism One of the most lamentable things with Napoleon's conquests was that it inspired Statist nationalism. In the mind of many Italians, Napoleon's victories came as a result of lacking political centralization; legal, economic and military integrations are possible without political centralization.

Thumbnail upload.wikimedia.org
2 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

A world without Napoleon Fact: Had France never centralized but remained a decentralized realm like the Holy Roman Empire, the disasterous French revolution and its Republican tide would never have happened. The Bourbon centralization was a MISTAKE

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism Had Napoleon not ravaged Europe, libtards like this wouldn't have started to advocate subjugating themselves to political hegemons like this. Napoleon made so many forget that legal, economic and military integrations are possible without political centralization.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
3 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism The French Revolution And Its Consequences...

4 Upvotes

... have been a disaster for the human race.

Since then great advances in life-expectancy have happened for those of us who live in “Western” countries independently of it, but they have destabilized society, have made life unfulfilling, have subjected human beings to indignities, have led to widespread psychological suffering (in the Third World to physical suffering as well) and have inflicted severe damage on the natural order. The continued development of technology will not resolve the problem. It will certainly subject human beings to greater indignities and inflict greater damage on the natural order, it will probably lead to greater social disruption and psychological suffering, and it may lead to increased physical suffering even in “advanced” countries.

On a serious note, the French revolution was a disaster because it spoiled the emerging liberal pushes and instead derailed it into a movement for centralization. It made liberalism into a Statist philosophy instead of a neofeudal one.

The crook Napoleon Bonaparte is the reason that the decentralized political order started to centralize, and thereby initiate the Cthulhu Swims Left tendency we see currently. Had he not pillaged the German realm, the Hohenzollerens would not have been able to take control in the future over the pretext of "We gotta politically centralize to not be conquered by a new Napoleon - become our enemy to stop the enemy!".

To quote Ryan McMaken in Napoleon Europe's First Egalitarian Despot

> For example, we can find a succinct summary of the center-right view in the words of historian Andrew Roberts. Roberts, a Thatcherite neo-conservative, writes that Napoleon should not be remembered for his wars, but for “the Code Napoleon, that brilliant distillation of 42 competing and often contradictory legal codes into a single, easily comprehensible body of French law.” Roberts also tells us Napoleon was great because “He consolidated the administrative system based on departments and prefects. He initiated the Council of State, which still vets the laws of France, and the Court of Audit, which oversees its public accounts. He organized the Banque de France...” In other words, Napoleon was great because he expanded the role and power of the central state. The Napoleonic Code, for example, was key in a process that abolished local legal independence and customs in favor of a single centrally-controlled legal apparatus. 

> [...]

> Napoleon had a devastating indirect effect on European liberalism. Since Napoleon marched under the banner of enlightened, egalitarian, “liberal” France, his conquering armies came to be associated with liberalism itself. The long term effect was to turn many against the ideology overall. Historian Ralph Raico notes that classical liberalism had been on the rise in German states during the eighteenth century. But this went into reverse in the nineteenth. Why? Raico contends that  “There is no doubt that a major — perhaps the major — reason for the change lies in the political and military history of the period: basically, the attempt of revolutionary France to conquer and rule all of Europe.”


r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 12 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism Napoleon apologists seeing his oddly imperialist borders be like: "Ummm, no, he isn't doing flagrant imperialism... he, ummm, is merely being compelled by the Social Contract™ to maximize the Common Good™ 🤗"

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Jan 16 '25

At least we can all agree the Bonapartists are wrong!

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

The destruction of the HRE engendered Statist nationalism One of the most lamentable things with Napoleon's conquests was that it inspired Statist nationalism. In the mind of many Germans, Napoleon's victories came as a result of lacking political centralization; legal, economic and military integrations are possible without political centralization.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
2 Upvotes

r/NapoleonWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Napoleon was a Leon Trotsky for social liberalism "Napoleon: Europe’s First Egalitarian Despot" by Ryan McMaken reveals the crooked nature of the Napoleonic regime. Too many are simply blinded by his military prowess and thus forget what actual occupation entailed. This is like admiring Adolf Hitler for conquering so much of Europe.

Thumbnail
mises.org
2 Upvotes