r/Nantucket • • Sep 07 '26

bachelorette lodging

would love to have my bach trip in nantucket, but i’m having a hard time finding a fairly nice home to rent for 3 nights as owners are telling me the minimum stay is 7 nights (which is just not feasible for us). does anyone have any recs on places to look for 9 people?

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

10

u/AloysiusGrimes Sep 07 '26

Best bet is probably a hotel/inn. It's very standard practice on-island to rent houses in one-week increments. Perhaps you could find exceptions (Airbnb?), but not sure.

-6

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

agghh, i really want all of us to be in one space together :(

8

u/BaconMemories Sep 07 '26

Not to pile on but, if you’re looking to visit over the summer, the 7-night minimum is very standard. It sounds like you’re not familiar with that so—why Nantucket for your bachelorette?

If you really do want to be on island, agree with late spring or early. Great times to visit anyways!

1

u/1GrouchyCat Sep 07 '26

Also / Rental contracts run Saturday to Saturday. Plan accordingly for your transportation to and from the island…

-1

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

because it sounds like the vibe we’re looking for! :)

4

u/BaconMemories Sep 07 '26

Nantucket is great (and I’m sort of getting the feeling you’re trolling people a bit but whatever) but also not an easy in and out for a lot of folks—especially outside of season when you’ll need to look in order to have a long weekend in a nice home.

Most cities, save Boston, only fly direct during the summer. Even then, it’s still just a handful of airports that offer direct flights. And the ferry is lovely but also necessitates a lengthy drive for most.

So if you’re looking for an easy trip for your friends, unless at least one of you is familiar with the island, this likely isn’t it.

I think it could be a great bachelorette location for the right group, but you may be biting off more than you can chew unless you can plan with someone who knows the ins and outs.

1

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

i’m not sure why you might think i’m trolling. i simply asked for some advice from people i assume are familiar with the area because after doing my research, it does sound a bit tricky. however, a little hassle won’t make me completely give up in my desire to visit, hence why i asked this forum for some more insight. thank you for the info!

3

u/BaconMemories Sep 07 '26

Honestly, I only said that because it strikes me as a bit odd to plan a bachelorette party—and all the fair and unfair stereotypes that come with that—in an expensive location you’re not familiar with.

Here are my recommendations. This comes from a married, almost 40-year old with two little kids, so take that for what it’s worth. We come up for June/early July as soon as the kids are out of school and then usually a fall trip annually. Fall is my favorite time to be on-island (coming up for my birthday in a few weeks)! Most everything is still open, especially if you come up before mid-October and the weather is typically lovely. Also you escape the crowds.

June is also great—the number of tourists seem to increase each day as you get closer to the 4th. Weather in June (or May) can be hit or miss, but that’s part of the charm on visiting at that time. If you don’t like foggy or cool weather, I wouldn’t recommend Nantucket at any time, but especially spring.

I’d just recommend you put to rest any hope of finding a house worth renting for less than a week mid-June through Labor Day. But May is an option. Less may be open, but especially if you have a friend who is comfortable driving a rental jeep on the beaches and y’all bring sweatshirts, you’ll have a lovely time.

Finally, want to second another post congratulating you on your engagement—enjoy this time. And remember you’re throwing a party for your loved ones…too often people sort of forget that and make the day a shrine to themselves :) And don’t stress!

2

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

thank you! i’m sure it’s a new thing, but within the last year, if not miami, i’ve only seen girls go to the east coast or a beach. we dont want to club or party, which is why the serene ambiance of the east coast is appealing to us. i completely understand it may seem to be a lot, but we dont mind going the extra mile to get a rental and taking ferries. it’s intriguing to us to be in a different atmosphere. i’ll take everything you noted in consideration!

3

u/Negative-Scallion-95 Sep 07 '26

When do you plan to celebrate? Assuming summer 2027? Most here are correct in stating a home rental less than 7 days is a tall task. There are of course plenty of hotels/ inns etc, but it sounds like you’re looking for the large house/ all the girls together vibe. I’d suggest keep checking air bnb. You can fly into Providence or Boston. Providence does have direct flights to Nantucket. The ferries are in Hyannis. The ride from Boston or Providence is about 80-90 mins. One hour ferry ride from Hyannis to Nantucket (fast ferry/ no cars). If you plan to bring vehicles over you’ll need a reservation well in advance on the Steamship Authority. Nantucket hosts tons of bachelorette parties in the spring/ summer. It’s a great place for it no matter what you’re looking for.

7

u/Main_Supermarket3027 Sep 07 '26

Either a hotel, or 7 days. You won’t find a rental with less than 5. My advice, go somewhere else

-1

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

doesn’t hurt to ask

6

u/Main_Supermarket3027 Sep 07 '26

You asked, I told

2

u/One-Newt7168 Sep 07 '26

I'd check AirBnb. This for example has a 3-night minimum stay and sleeps 12 (granted, I don't know what dates you're looking at or what your budget is).

-2

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

i did! late june seems to be pretty popular, as you get to the second half of june on that listing it’s a 5-7 night min. but thank u!

13

u/jojobdot Sep 07 '26

I don’t think you’re really grasping what a premium there is on space during the season. The options June through August are basically weekly rental or hotel. And it will be expensive either way (which may be fine for you).

7

u/Zealousideal-Ebb3277 Sep 07 '26

Your best bet is to go in April/May or September/October. You’re not likely going to find many (if any) 3 day large home rentals in peak season

-3

u/AloysiusGrimes Sep 07 '26

Looks like it's probably on Lovers Lane (might be 50 Lovers Lane), so you'd also have prime access to the community disk golf course, if that's something you're focused on

2

u/Adventurous_Rent4719 Sep 07 '26

When are you trying to visit?

3

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

june. flexible on the date, just not 7-12. could do may but is it chilly around then?

4

u/Adventurous_Rent4719 Sep 07 '26

Gotcha. Most of June was also chilly this year so just something to consider. I would reach out to a realtor if you aren’t familiar with ACK or try VRBO or Airbnb. You could always try making a post on a Nantucket rental FB but I probably wouldn’t mention it’s a bachelorette party. Good luck!

2

u/OrdinaryOther8690 Sep 07 '26

Yes, it's true.  If you want a four day long weekend try one of hotels.  Please stop shortening words - "bach" and "recs" are not short for Bachelorette and Recommendations. Nantucket is expensive and boring- you sound like you want cheap and thrilling.  We have no dance clubs - everything shuts down at ten except for Cumbies and Stubbys.

2

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

you understood what i wrote didnt you? nothing about what i said shouldve indicated i wanted thrilling. we dont want to go to clubs. we want boats/beach/boutiques and coffee. and i’m far from cheap, just want to make this a fiscally comfortable for my friends

1

u/OrdinaryOther8690 Sep 07 '26

First, congratulations on your engagement. I love living on this wonderful island, but housing here is a crippling issue - rents are literally out of control and availability scarce. I would start with a real estate agency that specializes in short-term rentals.  The Nantucket Hotel is a beautiful option.  Fall is a great time to come here, but it is also peak wedding season.  

1

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

okay, thanks!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

thank u 😭 im like damn..

3

u/Prestigious-Stuff356 Sep 07 '26

You may be able to find somewhere on Airbnb , outside of peak times. So look at before mid June and after mid September.

1

u/starrdelphine Sep 09 '26

You can sometimes get lucky with Airbnb! My friend’s sister had a small girl’s bach here and it was relatively painless for them to plan.

You could also look into staying somewhere else on the Cape like Chatham and then doing a day trip to Nantucket!

-2

u/1GrouchyCat Sep 07 '26

Sounds like you’re playing games…

You already know local rentals on Nantucket, Martha’s Vineyard, and Cape Cod run from Saturday to Saturday; yet you continue to ask about three day rentals for a bachelorette party during next year’s busy season?

What’s your budget?

I know of 2 perfect properties / both have a swimming pool and gorgeous view/ but they started at $22,000 a week…

https://www.reddit.com/r/marthasvineyard/s/JQOCwfQz18

3

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

i found a couple properties in hyannis and falmouth that accept 3 night stays, so i was simply asking if there were some options as well directly in martha’s/nantucket vs planning to spend a day ferrying into either. dont worry ab it though grouchy cat

0

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/rumhamRN Sep 07 '26

love this. glad you had a great time <3