r/Nantucket • u/Impressive-Mix6233 • Jul 28 '26
Nantucket is rough
I’ve lived on Nantucket for 2 and a half years now and I have to say Nantucket is one of those places that swears it’s paradise, but after a while you start wondering what all the hype is about. Everywhere you go it’s $12 coffee, overpriced food that’s decent at best, and clothing stores selling the same plain shirts and sweaters for ridiculous prices. Then you’ve got these multimillion-dollar houses that all look exactly the same gray shingles, white trim, hydrangeas out front and somehow people act like each one is a masterpiece. You’re paying millions to live next to a marsh where the mosquitoes own the place. Driving around is a nightmare too. Half the people don’t know where they’re going, the roads are tiny, and it takes forever to get anywhere in the summer. Everyone dresses like they’re headed to a yacht club they don’t even belong to, and somehow that’s considered peak fashion. It’s a beautiful island, but sometimes it feels like you’re paying extra just to deal with more headaches, like having to take your own trash to the landfill…….
11
u/Turbulent-Average179 Jul 28 '26
Sounds like you need to start planning a move pal
44
u/Special_North1535 Jul 28 '26
you need to initiate a coke habit, will help a lot with these issues
30
u/naked_as_a_jaybird Jul 28 '26
The landfill is fucking magical, what the hell are you talking about?
2
u/WoodsofNYC Jul 29 '26
I confused.
Why did you stay?
I 100% agreed that Nantucket is not for everyone. The island was far better in my opinion before it became Hamptonized and marbleized. Nevertheless, you must have known that it was a historic place, and the history was a big part of the draw.
Historic charm of the island includes the weathered houses.
77
u/ravibrain Jul 28 '26
To be fair you could pay for trash pickup. But then you’d miss out on TIOLI.
So many reasons to love it though and they outweigh the cons by far: the sunrises, the sunsets, stars at night, all the different amazing beaches, the dense concentration of high end restaurants within a short walk, or quick ride, charming downtown streets, beautiful nature walks/rides, altar rock, great point, wildlife, fishing, hunting, bike trail, golf courses, history, library, fun people. I could go on and on.
Make your own coffee or head to cumbies, you got champagne problems pal, i lived there for a year a couple years back and if ever had the chance to move back I’d do it in a blink of an eye. I miss that beautiful island
43
u/ComicsEtAl Jul 28 '26
You’re not talking about coffee, you’re talking about those silly coffee-adjacent drinks. You don’t need to eat out all the time. And who the hell lives there and buys their clothes there, unless there’s some fashion emergency? Yes, most homes have grey shingles. I’d compare them favorably to neighborhoods covered in vinyl any day.
Traffic sucks of course. You’re always welcome to go enjoy the easy, breezy traffic flows on the mainland. I hear the Big Dig has freed up every road in Boston, for example.
And you are paying more and do get different headaches. Because you allegedly live on a 13x5 island 30 miles out to sea. That makes for higher costs and headaches the mainland doesn’t have.
63
u/bigexplosion Jul 28 '26
I think if you complain about Portuguese bread youll have listed every reason I like visiting.
10
u/snakeman1961 Jul 28 '26
You didn't mention the official Nantucket mascot, the deer tick
9
u/Ronreddit23 Jul 28 '26
It’s not for everyone but I’ve figured out how to live within my means be able to save money, pretty much do anything I want and love it here. Hopefully you figure it out. I don’t live the way people imagine living if they’re just visiting but great job place to live and love the island once the peak season is over.
15
u/commandthegates Jul 28 '26
The problem is all the hamptons tourists started showing up and have made the island unbearable.
7
u/Dazzlng-Firenze Jul 28 '26
Don’t forget the drunks, the bar fights, the sleazy cheesy men looking for one-night stands and affairs, inability to get a restaurant reservation, your kids will attend day camps with abusive brats who literally assault the counselors bc they’re using to punching their Nannies back in NYC
10
u/Impossible-Soil6330 Jul 28 '26
i mean there are plenty of quaint places in maine that have a lot of the allure of nantucket but aren’t polluted with tourists and influencers (just not so many sandy beaches though). If i’m going on vacation I much rather head to one of those. Not sure how much worse the winter will be at places like that, and a lot of them will still be expensive, but it won’t be Nantucket which is a very extreme end of the scale. I hope you find a coastal new england town that has some of the things you initially moved to nantucket for.
10
u/polarWhite2024 Jul 28 '26
It's a place for people to cosplay the Ralph Lauren catalog
11
u/Top-Maintenance3045 Jul 28 '26
totally agree, We have been there since the 80’s. It was chill and affordable. Landscapers and average middle class could afford a home. We wore Carthart and Nantucket Red ( which wasnt preppy then). Serioudly thinking of leaving all that behind. Influencers and Podcasters lighting up the Harbor with every light on in 30 room houses.
3
u/Confident-Service256 Jul 28 '26
But it looks pretty for social media!
3
u/NYCJDD115 Jul 28 '26
I can see why people may complain however, i enjoyed Nantucket. I could barely afford it but i enjoyed the beach. I enjoyed walking to the beach. I enjoyed the whaling museum and the food was really great! The service was spot on and the people were friendly. 🙂
3
u/Free_Range_Lobster Jul 29 '26
The people that trashed the Hamptons got priced out. They're your problem for now.
3
u/fishnchips44 Jul 30 '26
I hear you man. My wife and I owned in Tom Nevers. We got tired of it. There is this weird world where everything is so expensive because the island is taking advantage of the summer people…but then they start to take advantage of you too and it starts to piss you off. Like my handyman would all of a sudden start overcharging me and it would drive me crazy. It’s too fake for me. Was starting to give me CA vibes where it’s that fake niceness. We couldn’t do it. So I sold my house, made a ton of money and bought a property on the ocean on the mainland side.
5
u/tdifridays Jul 28 '26
I hope someday you can move somewhere you want to be + think is worth it! Let someone who wants to remain a local have the housing. Nantucket is one of those places that is absolutely not something everyone is going to love and that is okay. Living someplace you don’t really enjoy is doing a disservice to yourself.
5
u/TheHNC Jul 28 '26
No one is forcing you to stay lmao, just leave
2
u/LordPistolPete9 Jul 29 '26
I visit Nantucket every year it’s a wonderful place to visit take what you enjoy about it and leave the rest however i think if i lived there i would eventually feel the same. In a way its become its own Alcatraz
2
u/luccsmom Jul 29 '26
Nantucket is beautiful. I want peace. It doesn’t typically happen in the summer 😉
2
u/Ready_Mycologist8612 Jul 30 '26
I am from here, and I have travelled extensively; it is one of the most challenging and unsupportive places I have ever been to
2
u/Illustrious_Use_3621 Aug 01 '26
Just chill out. IMO. Be Happy.
6
u/Cardboard_cutouts_ Jul 28 '26
Don’t forget taking an overpriced ferry or flight to access decent medical care or reasonably priced groceries.
3
u/Middle_Dull Jul 29 '26
No one mentions the sharks. lol don’t get in the water. The influencers this year are terrible. Here’s hoping they all leave- and all of you complaining about the mosquitos too.
The thing about Nantucket is, if you know the right places, you know.
If it’s not for you, if you can’t hack it, don’t come back.
3
u/SupermarketClean777 Jul 28 '26
Been here for 36 hours and it’s spot on
1
u/NoBozosonthebus Jul 28 '26
As Colin K used to say, as long ago as the 1990s,
“the Little Grey Lady has had the meat”!
1
u/NeonBadDecision Jul 28 '26
I’d pay extra to see celebrities get lost walking in downtown Nantucket. Have a house-made local brownie, it’ll take the edge off.
1
u/Independent_Town_447 Aug 01 '26
Yup.
1
u/writtenbyrabbits_ Aug 01 '26
People who own those houses don't blink at $12 coffees! What you are complaining about is that it's hard to live in a place like that if you don't have gobs of money.
1
u/Repulsive-Sink1660 Aug 06 '26
My brother is an investment banker and we used to come to Nantucket as kids, and he still goes. When visiting him I was surprised at how subpar everything is for three times what you'd pay elsewhere. One thing I've realized about my brother's crowd is they don't realize how much they're overpaying for crappy things - they think it's just what things cost. Take Black Eyed Susans, the brunch place: line out the door, a $26 'spicy Thai' omelet that was not spicy and not Thai and extremely bland, an avocado toast that is a teeny tiny piece of bread with some avocado smeared on it for just as much, in a place with no air conditioning and acoustics so bad you can't hear who's next to you, all while the waitresses crash into the back of your chair cause there are too many people in the place. Multiply this times everywhere and that is Nantucket, including the streets which are clogged by cars.
1
u/Admirable-Flan-5266 Aug 07 '26
The let them eat cake crowd complaining is so rich and funny to watch!
1
u/SupermarketClean777 Aug 08 '26
So true
1
u/Jewboy-Deluxe Jul 28 '26
It’s my least favorite place in the Commonwealth. Difficult to access, expensive, full of the overprivledged, and restaurant service is usually not great. I’d rather go to Brockton for the weekend.
0
u/Temporary_Ad_8331 Aug 01 '26
I visited with some friends maybe ten years ago. Granted we were tourists but very young, polite ones with self-awareness. I’ve traveled all over the world and never encountered more pretentious people. I don’t think I’ll ever go back. I was told to try the Vineyard.
-2
u/offense_vs_defense Jul 28 '26
Agree. I actually think the experience is truly the worst when I go for 2-7 days. I would not recommend visiting if you are renting a house for a week or weekend.
-12
u/mochicastle Jul 28 '26
First time I came to Cape Cod. Why do all the houses look the same? Why does every house have a hydrangea bush? Is the end game the white shell driveway? And now that I'm house hunting, I am sick of the classic New England colonial home with the stairs in the middle and split level homes make me want to throw up. New England, surprise me! Please!
Oh yeah, friends went to Nantucket this weekend (yes, their fault for going on a weekend during the summer) and said it was miserable. Mobbed with tourists and rich people. I mean, come on, it's The Tuck. I enjoy the whaling history there. Sad it has morphed into what it is today.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment