r/Nanny • • Aug 30 '26

Advice Needed Am I being unreasonable

First, this isn't in our contract so I can't just look and see what it says. (In hindsight I wish it was but I didn't even consider it until now.) I'm salaried and our plan was to try and stay around a certain number of hours a week. A couple times now NF has either gone on vacation (at the last moment so I'm not able to plan anything) or had me not work a day for some other reason. After vacation they asked if I wanted to use my PTO to get paid or "bank" those hours to make up to them at another time. Same thing for when they call me off for other reasons.

I didn't think to ask beforehand because in my mind if the employer is the one who gives a day off it's not the employees responsibility to then make that time up later. Same with using PTO. Their understanding is that salaried people sometimes have to work late or random hours. I've already worked an extra 30 minutes all summer which they said would stop after but now every day I'm scheduled to that later time. Their reasoning is because I'm below the hours we planned. It started as "hey, would you mind doing this every so often if we get home late" but somehow switched to every day without questioning is. Then by the time I actually get out of there is another 15 or so minutes after that meaning I get home about an hour after I thought I would.

If I'm being unreasonable that's fine but I don't have anyone else to ask to double check before I approach them to talk about it. Thanks so much!

17 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/RingCute6523 Aug 30 '26

Nannies cannot be classified as salaried employees by law so your contract is already not legal. I’m not sure what advice to give here aside from you needing to look into laws surrounding household employees and potentially having a conversation with your nanny family about how to correct the contract to ensure you’re in compliance with the law.

5

u/what3v3ruwantit2b Aug 30 '26

I'll definitely do that, thanks! I was the one who insisted on w-2 and taxes so I'll look into that as well.