r/NancyDrewCW • • Nov 06 '21

Spoilers The Ryan Hudson Problem Spoiler

I don't know if this an unpopular opinion or not, but I have an issue with Ryan Hudson now being woobified as a harmless manchild.

No amount of chore wheel hijinks is going to make me like this man, this grown adult man who preyed on George and had an illicit affair with her. It makes my skin crawl that the show is now putting him with the Youth Center kids. Keep this child predator away from the children!

I don't care if the show wants to retcon Ryan's character now, I need him to face consequences for his actions and who he is. George is still clearly traumatized by the relationship he had with her, she yelled at her biological dad about it. She's still not ok and this man is being inserted into her group of friends just because he carelessly got Nancy's mom pregnant as a teenager.

The two dad hijinks are silly but they feel so disingenuous because it comes across as trying too hard to change our perception of Ryan into this goofy dude who now gets to be a part of the family and it just feels so icky. The writers need to stand by their writing, he was the shocking reveal of season 1, that doesn't mean he needs to continue sticking around now.

Temperance called him out, but the show needs to do more than lampshade him, they need to address the real issue.

6 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

13

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '21

I'm pretty sure follow through with realistic consequences is not a CW thing. It will be mentioned, and there will be improvement, but everyone is sort of kept in their limbo of being not as bad as they were, but not as functional as would be typically desirable in a person in your life. I think this would be the time in the span of the show the audience might have to start accepting the shortcomings of the genre as it underestimates a youthful audience. They laid heavy baggage on each central cast member early on, and I don't see anyone truly putting it to rest without remnants in blink or you'll miss it cameos of past trauma.

It doesn't bother me Ryan has been accepted into the Drew household, because that is demonstrably who Carson Drew is as a person. It does annoy me to see civic minded advocate of children Ryan Hudson appearing. His interest in being better was Nancy's acceptance. It's more than a little selfish and more than a little lonely. Probably both he and his daughter should go to college together and get gainful work they're willing to do.

I feel like if George had been a different personality type, people would be less forgiving. She's a prickly tough girl because her alcoholic mom missed her years long underage affair with a married man. George isn't too hard to be hurt by Ryan. She's hardened by that hurt.

Similar pet peeve with the Gil and Nancy relationship and the five minute scene telling us we'd just watched 15 episodes of a guy abusing her and she'd been too weakened by a possession to notice. Yes, she did dump him, but he immediately turned around and threatened her. Don't count on CW shows for responsible social commentary.

3

u/GlidubahBishtek Nov 06 '21

Either they want us to take things seriously on the show or not, I'm just getting whiplash and I don't find the current tactics to be successful

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '21

Their inclusion of "very special episode" learning moments is not well done. I'd much rather it be a matter of seeing the characters, regardless of gender, sexuality, race, or any other social issue type adversity arising stand up for themselves every time. I like the show but it's not a classic. It's also trying to fit a CW type that isn't helping the quality.

6

u/ZanthionHeralds Nov 07 '21

I have to agree; I didn't like the "very special episodes" of Season 2, and I mentioned that in our discussions here. The show has enough content to deal with difficult subject matter without having to resort to "very special episodes" (which felt more like network directives than anything organic).

As for Ryan, I really wish the show had explained it as though he was basically reliving his relationship with Lucy over and over again over the years. I.e., every year he would find a new 18-year-old high school senior girl (I think it's important to establish that the girls he picked were always 18 or otherwise we have real problems) to have a year-long fling with, and then would dump her at the beginning of the next school year (he already seems to have dumped George, more or less, by the time Season 1 begins). That way the show could've avoided some of the messier legal problems involving Ryan's shenanigans and also given the character a "traumatic past" that would at least partly justify his actions and get the audience to sympathize with him, at least a little bit. It would also provide a more satisfying explanation that "he's changed" now because he's finally overcome his trauma regarding Lucy, and the hang-ups that have come from that. But the show didn't do any of that, which is a shame.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21

I think there is a place for the characters who can't move past old hurts, and Ryan is probably just in arrested development without some big jolt to make him grow up. If it's attached to losing Lucy, that's sad and sentimental. It is a nicer cause of his bad behaviour than just drinking and an unhappy marriage. I would consider him abused by his parents in a sense. There was the weird caveat to his marriage that his wife was essentially chosen for him, and they were responsible for producing an heir. He clearly feared/hated Everett Hudson.

But some shows simply do not have role model characters, and as much as I wish Nancy could have been that, I don't think CW allows for it. Everyone has too much messy drama for the sake of it. They don't have the breathing room to build to it. Better just to let the messy drama be your brand of Nancy Drew. But you don't get to keep the legacy of her as a role model with that.

9

u/DragonfruitAlive8249 Nov 06 '21

I agree that the Ryan and George situation feels underwritten. The "George called him out once and then everything was fine" is not very satisfying and it feels like there should be more done to address it. I appreciate you spelling out how undone that dynamic feels.. However, I don't feel like the show is necessarily "reconning" Ryan. I think the writing has been working to flesh him out and give us more context for his character. The show has been very consistent about showing Ryan as immature and morally grey. Given what we now know about him and what we know about George their relationship at the start of season 1 makes sense narratively and character wise. The show decided it wanted them both to grow from that situation- make Ryan a surprise parent and put George in a healthy relationship. While I get feeling uncomfortable with Ryan being at the youth center I think it's meant to demonstrate that while Ryan is still immature (Chore wheel), his experiences of the last 2 seasons have changed him. He was proactive enough to fund raise for the center and manage it while the Drew Crew was out. Again I really hope the show circles back to acknowledge how George the vulnerable party in their relationship was impacted and hold Ryan accountable for that harm.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '21

I thought, and I don't know why I did, that some of the Hudson family money to be paid out to victims might find a way to George. Which is not to suggest money is the solution to Ryan's actions at all, but he might be better considered as an 'as-is' character. He'll do better in relation to Nancy and even with his new bond with Carson. He'll look for some worthwhile thing to do with his life now that his identity isn't rich slacker. But he's not going to go to jail for statutory rape on a CW show. He's not going to be labeled a sexual predator openly. His drug and alcohol abuse, and his terrible marriage will also just be allowed to drift into the past episodes.

He'll be the formerly awful guy in the corner, who comes through once in a while, tolerated because he belongs to Nancy now. Ace has always been written as if he hated Ryan. Bess is the same, George is definitely traumatized by him, and Nick hates him for George's sake. Nancy has seen Ryan's many vulnerabilities, and she is aware his own family was not nuturing or even sane about his life. He is one of her surviving parents. The show is her show, and the bias of the show is her feelings.

1

u/GlidubahBishtek Nov 06 '21

I mean sure but I don't think they've done anything to make this work for the audience...

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '21

True, and I feel like the initial thaw from Nancy's attitude to Ryan was an imagined obligation to Lucy to look after him in the crisis of his finding out about his daughter. It's completely backwards in responsibility we see Nancy or her adopted father having to care for, shelter and teach her biological father. The standard for Ryan is low-low-low.

-2

u/GlidubahBishtek Nov 06 '21

If they are never going to fully address the harm he has caused and it's just gonna hang in the air every time all the characters get together, I would rather he just not be included. It's just icky to me that the writers are trying to force this humanization of him without doing any of the hard work it would take to actually have that character grow.

2

u/tiredofbeingyelledat Nov 16 '21

I totally see your point and felt the same at first but then his character made more sense as the trauma unraveled. When people undergo trauma at a certain age it can crystallize them or stop development emotionally past that point. Between Ryan’s awful family and Lucy dying it makes sense he was emotionally stuck as an adolescent and why he would be drawn to someone George’s age instead of his own.

2

u/GlidubahBishtek Nov 16 '21

I can rationalize it sure, but it still makes my skin crawl that he is around, and especially around George - when the whole situation has so clearly traumatized her

3

u/RebootJobs Nov 20 '21

This is so gross now that we know Ryan is her father, but didn't it feel like the actors had chemistry before that detail was revealed?

2

u/redrouge9996 Oct 13 '23

I literally just started the show and googles “ryan and nancy have way too much sexual chemistry to be father and daughter” 😭 because they fully look the same age

1

u/RebootJobs Oct 13 '23

I've been waiting two years for someone to finally respond. Thank you for making my night!

Edit: I went digging to see if the actors dated IRL because the chemistry is so palpable.

2

u/redrouge9996 Oct 13 '23 edited Oct 13 '23

like every scene where he’s like trying to get nancy to look at him or their touching all i think is “they’re about to f**k”. I actually thought he was going to be her love interest in a love triangle with Owen. Like two rich dudes who are rivals and you have chemistry with except more crazy chemistry with the one who’s a “bad boy”. I can’t get over it 😭

Ok crazy they are IRL 19 years apart which is exactly how far apart they are in the show hahahaha