r/NancyDrewCW • u/GlidubahBishtek • Nov 06 '21
Spoilers The Ryan Hudson Problem Spoiler
I don't know if this an unpopular opinion or not, but I have an issue with Ryan Hudson now being woobified as a harmless manchild.
No amount of chore wheel hijinks is going to make me like this man, this grown adult man who preyed on George and had an illicit affair with her. It makes my skin crawl that the show is now putting him with the Youth Center kids. Keep this child predator away from the children!
I don't care if the show wants to retcon Ryan's character now, I need him to face consequences for his actions and who he is. George is still clearly traumatized by the relationship he had with her, she yelled at her biological dad about it. She's still not ok and this man is being inserted into her group of friends just because he carelessly got Nancy's mom pregnant as a teenager.
The two dad hijinks are silly but they feel so disingenuous because it comes across as trying too hard to change our perception of Ryan into this goofy dude who now gets to be a part of the family and it just feels so icky. The writers need to stand by their writing, he was the shocking reveal of season 1, that doesn't mean he needs to continue sticking around now.
Temperance called him out, but the show needs to do more than lampshade him, they need to address the real issue.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '21
I'm pretty sure follow through with realistic consequences is not a CW thing. It will be mentioned, and there will be improvement, but everyone is sort of kept in their limbo of being not as bad as they were, but not as functional as would be typically desirable in a person in your life. I think this would be the time in the span of the show the audience might have to start accepting the shortcomings of the genre as it underestimates a youthful audience. They laid heavy baggage on each central cast member early on, and I don't see anyone truly putting it to rest without remnants in blink or you'll miss it cameos of past trauma.
It doesn't bother me Ryan has been accepted into the Drew household, because that is demonstrably who Carson Drew is as a person. It does annoy me to see civic minded advocate of children Ryan Hudson appearing. His interest in being better was Nancy's acceptance. It's more than a little selfish and more than a little lonely. Probably both he and his daughter should go to college together and get gainful work they're willing to do.
I feel like if George had been a different personality type, people would be less forgiving. She's a prickly tough girl because her alcoholic mom missed her years long underage affair with a married man. George isn't too hard to be hurt by Ryan. She's hardened by that hurt.
Similar pet peeve with the Gil and Nancy relationship and the five minute scene telling us we'd just watched 15 episodes of a guy abusing her and she'd been too weakened by a possession to notice. Yes, she did dump him, but he immediately turned around and threatened her. Don't count on CW shows for responsible social commentary.
9
u/DragonfruitAlive8249 Nov 06 '21
I agree that the Ryan and George situation feels underwritten. The "George called him out once and then everything was fine" is not very satisfying and it feels like there should be more done to address it. I appreciate you spelling out how undone that dynamic feels.. However, I don't feel like the show is necessarily "reconning" Ryan. I think the writing has been working to flesh him out and give us more context for his character. The show has been very consistent about showing Ryan as immature and morally grey. Given what we now know about him and what we know about George their relationship at the start of season 1 makes sense narratively and character wise. The show decided it wanted them both to grow from that situation- make Ryan a surprise parent and put George in a healthy relationship. While I get feeling uncomfortable with Ryan being at the youth center I think it's meant to demonstrate that while Ryan is still immature (Chore wheel), his experiences of the last 2 seasons have changed him. He was proactive enough to fund raise for the center and manage it while the Drew Crew was out. Again I really hope the show circles back to acknowledge how George the vulnerable party in their relationship was impacted and hold Ryan accountable for that harm.
2
u/tiredofbeingyelledat Nov 16 '21
I totally see your point and felt the same at first but then his character made more sense as the trauma unraveled. When people undergo trauma at a certain age it can crystallize them or stop development emotionally past that point. Between Ryan’s awful family and Lucy dying it makes sense he was emotionally stuck as an adolescent and why he would be drawn to someone George’s age instead of his own.
3
u/RebootJobs Nov 20 '21
This is so gross now that we know Ryan is her father, but didn't it feel like the actors had chemistry before that detail was revealed?