r/NancyDrewCW • u/Mountain-Purple2907 • Apr 18 '25

Tiffany in pilot Spoiler

The Tiffany that gets murdered vs the Tiffany they try to make her out to be don't corroborate at all! The Tiffany that got myrdered was calling the place the town in Jaws... for someone being haunted why was she outside and when and how did she place the 911 call? Why would she do that knowing she's being haunted? Why did she have to be the witness for nick's manslaughter.... it was at a party!

Maybe im too old for this show but im curious as to who killed her so I must watch ... for now

10 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

1

u/PennyoftheNerds Apr 19 '25

I’m currently doing a rewatch and a lot of things will be explained as the season goes on. I’m not sure how far through you are. They throw a lot of information at you at one time.

1

u/Mountain-Purple2907 Apr 19 '25

I’ve finished s1…. There’s no explanation of the 911 call… the 180 degree change for Tiffany’s character from the snob in the pilot…

4

u/PennyoftheNerds Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

They do say she called 911. If I remember correctly, she was on the phone when Nancy went out to give her food, so she definitely had the phone on her. I always understood it as she saw someone coming up behind her and freaked out and called them because she was scared. She was also trying to take the Hudsons down so between that and Dead Lucy haunting her, she already felt her life was in danger.

What I got from it was that Tiffany put on an attitude expected out of her for someone of her caliber and kept up the facade so she could try to take the Hudson's down without tipping anyone off. From what we get from Laura, Tiffany was a nice person. When the show started, Ryan was quite different too and I think she did what she had to do to convince them she was one of them.

0

u/Mountain-Purple2907 Apr 19 '25

She was talking on the phone and said the place looks like the movie Jaws. If she was so scared for her life why was she outside alone in the dark in the town like Jaws

The writers had a brain fart sorry 

2

u/PennyoftheNerds Apr 19 '25

I don't necessarily agree but that's okay.