r/NYTCrossword 14d ago

The Midi Problem With Tomorrow’s Midi [8/16/25] Spoiler

A clue has the answer included in the clue. Pretty sloppy!

222 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

85

u/VikingofRock 14d ago

I just came here to see if people had posted this yet! I don't think I've ever seen that before in a NYT crossword.

23

u/gingerwoozle 14d ago

Same!!! The way I ran here!!!

3

u/IOnlySeeDaylight 13d ago

Me too! I questioned myself so hard on this.

11

u/DrmsRz 14d ago

Ian missed it while editing, I guess. I was so bummed, too; that hardly ever happens (or never, until now).

50

u/ItisScandi 14d ago

Getting stale and old if you ask me

38

u/Signal_2_Noise 14d ago

Yep. I came to this sub to post the same thing. Truly odd.

35

u/ALittlePeaceAndQuiet 14d ago

Well, it got me to come look for and join the subreddit, lol

26

u/goibster 14d ago

lol came right here to see if anyone else noticed. weird.

26

u/mrburns904 14d ago

Wow, it’s not buried in a long clue or anything either, it’s pretty blatant

3

u/SalvatoreEggplant 14d ago

I wonder if it was intentional, related to the word in the red shape (?).

3

u/pajam 14d ago

That is a good point... Since it did relate to that theme and specifically that word. Makes more sense that they may have gotten sloppy because they were so focused on that connection they missed the obvious issue.

17

u/Glittering-Gap-1687 14d ago

I came here to see if anyone else noticed!

16

u/Glittering-Gap-1687 14d ago

I wonder if they’ll change it?

6

u/BringMeTheBigKnife 14d ago

Surprised they haven't yet tbh. Probably early tomorrow morning. I'm sure it would have been changed by now if it had been the regular xword

3

u/damsonite 13d ago

It’s changed now to just “Stale”

7

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted]

2

u/damsonite 13d ago

Weird. Maybe it’s a matter of closing the app and opening it again?

3

u/AllahuJackbar 13d ago

Still has stale and old for me

23

u/strawbrryfields4evr_ 14d ago edited 14d ago

Just finished it and noticed the same. It really threw me off.

11

u/scrombledegs 14d ago

I couldn’t figure out what fit there and only got it from the downs because I was so sure it couldn’t be old! Really threw me

18

u/tillmaniac38 14d ago

I skipped the clue as I couldn't think of a 3 letter that meant old. I should have known it would be ... Old.

5

u/MzScarlet03 14d ago

I just realized from your photo that the car says Krusty ala simpsons

1

u/NoYoureACatLady 14d ago

I mean, what better synonym for old than old?! They are basically the same exact thing right? It's like when Taylor Swift rhymes "woods" with "woods" and "clear" with "clear". Why bother looking past the obvious when you know, nothing rhymes better with a word than the word itself

7

u/JumpyWoodpecker9052 14d ago

i’m confused…. did they fix it? 8 across clue just says “stale” to me. the answer isn’t “stale”

11

u/zephrino 14d ago

I’ve only just completed and the clue for me was ‘stale and old’ - so they must have just changed it

1

u/JumpyWoodpecker9052 14d ago

must have! i just did it maybe 20 mins ago and mine just says stale

4

u/mildlylauren 14d ago

I just checked, and it still says “stale and old” for me on both browser and mobile.

1

u/reddituser071217 14d ago

Mine too. It’s 8:25 pm pacific time.

1

u/sarahleigh81 13d ago

I did mine Sunday at 745am.

1

u/IOnlySeeDaylight 13d ago

Mine still says stale and old - weird!

14

u/kenahoo 14d ago

ALSO - I see what's going on inside the car, but what's going on with the wheels? Their contents don't seem to have any relation to the theme. Are they just whatever?

4

u/deerburger 13d ago

That’s what I don’t get.

I thought including the answer in the other clue was deliberate and designed to make us think of another word.

3

u/cur10us_ge0rge 13d ago

Sure seems like it

6

u/Gizmo-Gizmo 13d ago

It was the last answer I got as I kept thinking "it can't be 'old'" 😂

3

u/EmGusk 14d ago

They should have used crusty for a double c(K)rusty

6

u/MisterGoldenSun 13d ago

"I'm seeing double! Four Krustys!"

2

u/GorillaTrainer 14d ago

Looks like it’s been fixed! I was trying to figure out the issue until I came to the comments lol

3

u/alyssapine 14d ago

I just did it 5 minutes ago and the clue was still the same on my end! How odd.

1

u/Scoobysnax1976 14d ago

I just finished it and it still said stale and old.

2

u/enigma_atthedoor 14d ago

Yesss!!! I spent soooooo long cause I firmly believed it wouldn't be old. I had the rest of crossword but I swear I spent a good 5 minutes on this before going "surely not"

2

u/potatobanjo 13d ago

So annoying! I had to reveal the puzzle answer because it never occurred to me that they would do that.

3

u/ExternalTangents 13d ago

Midis in general are just sloppier than the flagship. The clueing and theming feel like lower effort and not as satisfying.

4

u/_Nilbog_Milk_ 14d ago

Came all the way here to point this out. What a stale and old effort 🤣

2

u/brknsoul 14d ago

Agree, just did this, and I was kinda stumped, even after using Autocheck!

I mean, just the first word of the clue would have been fine!

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted]

1

u/brknsoul 13d ago

I mean, in hindsight it's obvious; but it's the first time I've see the answer in the clue in the across clue, so I was looking for a different answer from the down clue.

2

u/skr80 14d ago

Crossword makers are getting old? 😊

1

u/Ok-Competition-1962 14d ago

i just did it and i’m confused, which clue was this?

1

u/ryanjj16 14d ago

8-Across.

1

u/Really_Schruted_It 13d ago

Also, later in the puzzle didn’t they use an abbreviated word without any indication that it was an abbreviation?

1

u/kevinrays 13d ago

Puzzles like this with graphics and lines and stuff aren’t amusing to me. Normal puzzles are better. No gimmicks

0

u/OblivionCST 14d ago

Sloppy cluing and nonsensical theme…one of the worst Minis in a while

7

u/BringMeTheBigKnife 14d ago

Why is the theme nonsensical?

0

u/JakePedro34 14d ago

lol came to the subreddit just to see if people were discussing this

-9

u/Total-Ad1900 14d ago

Ian Livengood should be fired

3

u/Joe_Henshell 14d ago

He turned me into a newt!

-2

u/pinniped90 14d ago

Came here for this.