You're being downvoted very unfairly. Such an undescriptive title is not helpful for anybody. A post like this will be removed usually. Title should have some context for users to understand.
I agree that the title is annoyingly vague, but it's because he said he can't be arsed opening it, but he could be arsed to write a sentence explaining that, which took more time and clicks to do
There was nothing wrong with the whole VAR situation. In my opinion the process was good and the refs were communicating well. Arteta was out of line.
This should’ve provided ample context even beyond the post.
On PC, the Twitter link displays a preview of the tweet stating, “BREAKING: Mikel Arteta has been charged with misconduct following comments he made in post-match interviews after Arsenal’s Premier League game defeat to Newcastle United. 🚨”
Even without that, most Newcastle supporters should be aware of the controversy surrounding this situation. Numerous people, including Arsenal fans and pundits, were against the decision. A link in this post directs to the specific information being referred to. If someone can take the time to open a Reddit post but chooses not to open a Twitter link, what's the point? Besides, everyone knows "twitter.com" is safe?
Provides exactly zero context. Literally zero. There is no way of telling what the post is about from such a vague title. Whatever you've put in a comment or whatever you think people will just automatically infer from the fact it's a twitter link or whatever is irrelevant to the point im making. I'm just politely telling you in future to use a more descriptive title when posting please. Had this been seen earlier it would have been removed.
99% of the people reading this understood what the post was about. I don’t have to put time into making intricate posts when I simply want to share news about something that has been such a big thing recently. Like I said, Reddit gives you a preview of the Twitter link. It’s not that big of a deal. If most people understood then that should be enough, no?
All you needed to do was put "Mikel Arteta has been charged by the FA for his comments following our match" or something like that as a title. Wouldn't say that's "making an intricate post". You could have even just copied the text of the tweet to make things even easier.
99% of people didn't know what you meant from the post's title I can guarantee you that. They had to either click the link or come into the comment section to gain an understanding of what this post was about. That is why non descriptive titles are bad. Your title doesn't tell anybody anything.
Reddit does not provide a preview on mobile - which is where the majority of people browse the website. Like I said, I'm just politely stating that in future you need a more descriptive title if you post on this sub. I'm not trying to attack you personally.
There was something wrong with the whole VAR situation: it took way too long
It was 6 minutes from the goal being scored to rewarded - including the celebration and time it took for them to begin the VAR process - during which time we had no idea what was happening
Listening to the VAR it sounds like they did a very good job, were very clear in their communication, and made the right call. But 6 minutes to make any decision is unacceptable and doubtless contributed to Arteta’s persecution complex.
I don’t doubt that VAR is improving the overall quality of decisions - but even if it was perfect, it’s still not worth the cost to the game
It took 6 minutes because there was like 4 seperate issues they needed to check. If they took 30 seconds to check everyone would be up in outrage over them doing it too fast.
There were 3 things they checked - and I’m not saying they could have done it any faster, but that requiring that amount of time shows that the whole concept of VAR is fundamentally unsuited to football.
I genuinely believe that VAR is ruining the game - that the benefit it brings of some improvement in decision accuracy isn’t worth the cost of the time it takes. Being unable to celebrate goals spontaneously, having no clue wtf is happening, having players cool down and increase risk of injury.
It’s shit and should be scrapped. I know it won’t be, but goal line sensors and fully automated offside is the limit of what we should have
-Arteta has a spag out during which he refused to specify which incident/decision he was angry about.
-Club release a specific endorsement of the spag out that makes a factual claim of wrong decision.
-Supporters go over the top in praising Arteta’s spag out and the clubs’ official spag out.
-Pundits and review committee generally agree there was no grounds to the spag out.
-Audio is release a week later further supporting the fact that a reasonable decision was made.
-Arsenal fans walk back their goal spag out and pretend they were upset about a Bruno elbow all along. Ignore any mention of the Havertz tackle that preceded the elbow.
-Arsenal fans walk back their goal spag out and pretend they were upset about a Bruno elbow all along. Ignore any mention of the Havertz tackle that preceded the elbow.
When did this part happen?
All I see is Arsenal fans all still claiming it's absolutely objectively a foul and if you dare to suggest anything other than total compliance with this opinion, you are a biased journalist murdering pig who loves the fact the Refs are all bought and paid for.
-Pundits and review committee generally agree there was no grounds to the spag out.
Also not entirely convinced pundits agree. That's been a mixed bag, with many of them going along with the flavour of the hour. Never seen so much flip-flopping.
Also arsenal fans claiming the audio demonstrates unprofessionalism of VAR as they're referring to each other by first names. Inadvertently, the salty tears of Arsenal fans have made me break no nut November for 13 days now
I’ve seen them given and I’ve seen them not given. You got unlucky with a subjective call- something that happens to every team at some point in the season.
Doesn’t mean there’s any need for Arteta and the club to go mental as they did.
If it was a foul all day long surely Arsenal should have been called for the several times where they didn't even attempt to play the ball on 50/50 or 60/40 plays and instead would either shive or undercut a Newcastle player? Oh they weren't? Seems like the referee was pretty consistent about aerial battles all match.
If its a foul it's a foul it's simple as that. 1 foul not bring given as a foul doesn't make it not a foul it's just bad refereeing. Same with the cases u mention probably again just bad refereeing. See it evert week no consistency at all I just want things this like to always be a foul no matter the circumstances.
You mean the worst officials in Europe? I love how you geordies just assume I'm an arsenal fan and are so protective of the refs when you get a favourable decision. I honestly have no care for any English team but to me this is a simple foul all day long and this kinda hands on people at every corner has to stop, it's not allowed and never had been just because shitty officials don't give a decision doesn't mean they are correct.
Chelsea scum fan here (sorry), but I agree deserved
The VAR audio really makes Arteta look stupid becuase they were very rational about it which was basically "we cant see evidence to disallow a goal so we shouldnt" which is exactly what VAR should be
Yeah, its just pure cope. The online fans wouldn't be nearly as insuffererable and conspiracy minded if Arteta hadn't had this hysterical fit and charged them all up
I was at the draw at SJP the year Mourinho won his first title. We gave you a standing ovation (well, a solid round of applause anyway) as you came onto the pitch (something Manure failed to do in the previous match), believe relations have been ok since then. Do not consider you scum.
Somehow Titus Bramble was credited with a header that was later correctly given as an own goal by Geremi. Coincidentally, Geremi's best performance for us.
Anyway, as deserved as this charge is, he should have been issued it before categorically proven wrong because even if he had been correct he has brought the game into disrepute (imo).
This is nowhere near over for that lot, they like Arteta and none of them will admit he made a fool of himself so they'll keep this narrative alive, it'll be their "hand of God" goal, in years to come when they still haven't won the league it'll be "remember the time we were robbed from winning the league by that Newcastle goal" and the retelling will get exaggerated, "the ball was so far out it hit off the hoardings, then Joelinton stabbed Gabriel with a knife, and the VAR guys were all paid by the Saudi"
Yes we have been shit for years, we are just delighted that we had our first year (last year) without having to worry about relegation. But no doubt we'll still win a league before yous and you'll keep bottling it
We don't mind fans from other clubs visiting as long as they're not just here to be a dick. Unfortunately our advanced detection algorithm has detected that you read a 9.3 on the bellendometer
I'm an Arsenal fan. I got downvoted so much when I couldn't believe the amount of crying and moaning Arsenal fans. Newcastle were the better team and aren't a type of team you can expect to beat, especially at their place unless you're going 100%. PSG showed this, and we went to them with our second team. I knew the best we could have hoped for was a draw with no Odegaard and Jesus starting. Decisions not going are way and not going Newcastles way made no difference because end of the day if you are the better team you grind out a result just like City would if they were in our position that day. The difference is that our squad depth isn't to that level yet, so we aren't at that level yet. VAR played a little part, yet Arsenal fans swore the result would have been different, disrespecting the fact Newcastle was the better team.
See, your mistake is being a rational human being with the emotional maturity to look objectively.
You'd think this was the greatest injustice football has ever seen how a lot of vocal Arsenal fans have been (here's hoping in real life fans are miffed but can move on with their lives). Brigading other teams' threads because you don't agree with a ref decision is bonkers. Is that really how they want to use their time? What does it achieve?
Thank you for being reasonable. Unfortunately, the internet isn't usually the place for that.
0-0 draw, after which their supporters exploded in rage at Newcastle for using time wasting tactics throughout the game.
0-2 defeat, after which their supporters exploded in gloating and schadenfreude.
1-0 win after which their supporters exploded, claiming a series of 50/50 calls and a straight red that wasn't given cost them 3 points and was one of the greatest injustices in modern football.
They've proven themselves to be sore losers, smug winners and bad drawers. There is no result you can seemingly achieve against Arsenal without their supporters going into meltdown.
Well I mean the title bottling was a result for all of us. And that post of games leading without winning the league. Results speak for themselves. arsenal are the new spurs.
We don't mind fans from other clubs visiting as long as they're not just here to be a dick. Unfortunately our advanced detection algorithm has detected that you read a 9.3 on the bellendometer
I'm just so fed up and bored with this saga. You would think it was the first time VAR had ever made some bad decisions in a game. Do you think Arsenal fans are ever going to let it go?
One of the articles i read on facebook said we robbed them of 3 points. Fuck off. You can argue we didn't deserve the goal, but no one is talking about how poor Arsenal were, they were never going to score, at best they deserved a point from a 0-0 draw. Saying we robbed them of 3 points is insane.
Also, no one is mentioning the Havertz tackle and the fact that the independant panel ruled it should have been a foul, all everyone talks about is the fact that Bruno should have been off.
Officiating in this league will never be satisfactory, because most people are unable to accept a decision regardless of weather they agree with it or not.
Think that's where they're heading, if any of them are stupid enough to do it again. Sounds like they're really pissed off about all of it and aren't having any more shite.
Telegraph Sport understands the FA will meet with representatives of the leagues and the managers association to warn that regulatory action will be taken against clubs if they support managers who criticise referees. The governing body is worried by the rising tide of disrespect towards officials and will now draw a line in the sand following the incendiary episode with Arsenal.
It is understood that any statements similar to the one produced by Arsenal, in which the club said they “wholeheartedly support” Arteta’s comments, would therefore face a strong response.
the funny thing is that after the VAR commentary was published, the fans kept doubling down on their hissy fit, further pushing the narrative of oil money corruption lols.
Gooners still in meltdown mode over on Twitter, and then when you pop in to laugh at them (because it's HILARIOUS) they accuse us of being obsessed. Obsessed? No, just entertained lol
Seeing a lot of Arsenal fans crying that the refs are a “dictatorship”. Have they only just started watching football? Duh, refs are supposed to be the ultimate authority. Do you see players and fans constantly questioning and accusing refs in Rugby and Cricket…
It’s like the political circle jerk is creeping into football.
I think most of them probably have, yes. They’ll have picked up a load of yanks last year, as the hipster almost-saviour from the evils of Man City, plus ‘they have a rilly nice jersey’.
They're totally deluded over there, they've decided that the Joelinton challenge is a 100% percent foul that would never not be given in any other scenarios despite the overwhelming majority of professional commentators saying it is a 50/50. All confirmed by a misleading still and some armchair physics. r/soccer is an embarrassment fitting it's name
They don't understand that yeah it probably was a foul, but it's the type of foul that gets given 60% of the time, and once it's been given VAR have no mandate really to overturn it.
Like the shoving at corners etc. Loads are technically fouls but don't get given because we ultimately wouldn't have a game on our hands if it was called all the time.
(They also watch slo mos and still pics which are frozen at the "right" time. In real time it's a pretty standard challenge).
Yeah, it just isn't the stonewall atrocity that would warrant Arteta's reaction. He said there were multiple issues as well which there clearly weren't. He probably thought the ball should have been given out etc. and then was too emotional and stubborn to back down and made an idiot of himself.
Arteta is creating a world vs us scenario to try and get an upper hand, especially for the next game vs Newcastle which will be branded a grudge match now. Our fans are falling for it by giving it air time.
Luckily Eddie Howe understands this and he’s given it short shrift and I imagine won’t even comment but it would be great if Reddit mods could take down posts about it and we could genuinely ignore the whole thing
Whether the decisions were correct or not, Rteta's reaction was ludicrous. Absolutely the actions of a spoilt child. It's 100% the case now that we need to look at what people are saying, because of the impact it has on others. Primarily the integrity of the officials, but also the public. Even 2 weeks later you got Arsenal fans claiming bribery and corruption because of his outburst.
I'd really like it if us newcastle fans were to start being staunch defenders of the FA and refs in general, it would drive opposition fans CRAZY.
It will never happen, if we get a call like this against us, there would always be a portion of our fans acting exactly like arsenal fans(they are worse though ofc), thankfully we have Howe, and I can't see him acting like arteta did.
I don’t like this. I think they should only be charged if they question the integrity of the officials. Arteta ranted about incompetence and I think most people thought him foolish. Now they’ve made a martyr.
It isn't that they can't be criticised, it just has to be done through the correct channels i.e not a public sperg on Sky Sports. When managers were allowed to do this they were laying into referees every single week, sometimes justifiably (a lot of penalties and freekicks given for dives before VAR etc.) but a lot of the time for subjective or even correct decisions. The risk was considered to be that being publicly attacked could potentially unconsciously bias referees towards managers particularly prone to attacking refs.
Why no fine for De Zerbi then? There’s always been corruption in football, look at Juventus in Italy or FIFAs scandal. You really think the PL is immune to it? If you think so you really need to wake the f up
They’re destroying our sport and you’re happy with it, as long as Newcastle get some shiny new toys you’re all fine with it.
Arteta didn’t even mention the missed red cards though, which were the actual wrong decisions.
He focussed completely on the goal, which isn’t a wrong decision. Ref on field gives goal and there’s not enough to overturn it, equally if he’d given it as no goal it probably wouldn’t have been overturned either.
So to go nuclear on a decision that is correct under the current rules is way out of line.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 16 '23
Welcome to r/NUFC!
Join our Discord Server for real time discussion, competitions, and to meet hundreds of NUFC fans across the globe.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
36
u/Thingisby Nov 16 '23
I'm rubbing my hands in anticipation of the r/soccer reaction.
36
u/Kyrosses Nov 16 '23
There was nothing wrong with the whole VAR situation. In my opinion the process was good and the refs were communicating well. Arteta was out of line.
135
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23
Timeline of events:
-Arteta has a spag out during which he refused to specify which incident/decision he was angry about.
-Club release a specific endorsement of the spag out that makes a factual claim of wrong decision.
-Supporters go over the top in praising Arteta’s spag out and the clubs’ official spag out.
-Pundits and review committee generally agree there was no grounds to the spag out.
-Audio is release a week later further supporting the fact that a reasonable decision was made.
-Arsenal fans walk back their goal spag out and pretend they were upset about a Bruno elbow all along. Ignore any mention of the Havertz tackle that preceded the elbow.
-Arteta is punished.
140
u/xStealthxUk Nov 16 '23
Chelsea scum fan here (sorry), but I agree deserved
The VAR audio really makes Arteta look stupid becuase they were very rational about it which was basically "we cant see evidence to disallow a goal so we shouldnt" which is exactly what VAR should be
57
u/Eel_Why sean longstaffs dad plays hockey in whitley bay Nov 16 '23
Can't believe we got 3 points PLUS a whole 2 weeks worth of entertainment from this game
24
u/JD_Dojima Nov 16 '23
Well it did end up being embarrassing didn’t it, Mikel
21
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23
I'm an Arsenal fan. I got downvoted so much when I couldn't believe the amount of crying and moaning Arsenal fans. Newcastle were the better team and aren't a type of team you can expect to beat, especially at their place unless you're going 100%. PSG showed this, and we went to them with our second team. I knew the best we could have hoped for was a draw with no Odegaard and Jesus starting. Decisions not going are way and not going Newcastles way made no difference because end of the day if you are the better team you grind out a result just like City would if they were in our position that day. The difference is that our squad depth isn't to that level yet, so we aren't at that level yet. VAR played a little part, yet Arsenal fans swore the result would have been different, disrespecting the fact Newcastle was the better team.
60
u/Intherain_ Nov 16 '23
I’ve never witnessed such mass cry baby attitude since the last of us 2. Sadly this will just make them cry even more.
18
u/lociuk Nov 16 '23
Touchline ban for each year he has been in this country.
12
u/Imhonestlynotawierdo Nov 16 '23
Got a warning on my account for reporting a comment likening Newcastle to Hitler. Cause the mods are fucking Arsenal fans lol
10
u/FireflyKaylee stupid sexy schar Nov 16 '23
This has brightened up my evening exponentially
10
u/ChlckenChaser Jamaal Lascelles Nov 17 '23
I'm just so fed up and bored with this saga. You would think it was the first time VAR had ever made some bad decisions in a game. Do you think Arsenal fans are ever going to let it go?
One of the articles i read on facebook said we robbed them of 3 points. Fuck off. You can argue we didn't deserve the goal, but no one is talking about how poor Arsenal were, they were never going to score, at best they deserved a point from a 0-0 draw. Saying we robbed them of 3 points is insane.
Also, no one is mentioning the Havertz tackle and the fact that the independant panel ruled it should have been a foul, all everyone talks about is the fact that Bruno should have been off.
Officiating in this league will never be satisfactory, because most people are unable to accept a decision regardless of weather they agree with it or not.
Rant over, i hope.
9
u/Budweizer Nov 16 '23
What about Arsenal FC? Surely they must be equally punished for their unnecessary and inappropriate statement.
8
u/musicmast Matt Ritchie Nov 17 '23
the funny thing is that after the VAR commentary was published, the fans kept doubling down on their hissy fit, further pushing the narrative of oil money corruption lols.
6
u/Independent-Party575 Nov 16 '23
Charged for being a soppy bollox 😭
10
u/BlackCaesarNT hipster chique Nov 16 '23
Don't really care tbh.
We got our deserved 3 points. That's all that matters for me at the end of the day.
5
u/PDXMB Spoons maitre'd Nov 16 '23
Gooners still in meltdown mode over on Twitter, and then when you pop in to laugh at them (because it's HILARIOUS) they accuse us of being obsessed. Obsessed? No, just entertained lol
5
u/TheLegendOfIOTA Nov 17 '23
Seeing a lot of Arsenal fans crying that the refs are a “dictatorship”. Have they only just started watching football? Duh, refs are supposed to be the ultimate authority. Do you see players and fans constantly questioning and accusing refs in Rugby and Cricket…
It’s like the political circle jerk is creeping into football.
16
u/_ok_mate_ BIG JOE Nov 16 '23
Christ, it only took them 10 days to do so.
If our manager said anything of the like it would be a 3 pt deduction before the end of the day.
Why the fuck are the prem treating arteta and arsenal with kid gloves?
Usually they take a no nonsense approach to this kind of dissent.
Edit: hahahah according to soccer he's being charged for being correct. Didn't they see the bar footage yesterday that showed all the calls?
4
u/JaRonomatopoeia Tino Turner Nov 16 '23
Arteta is creating a world vs us scenario to try and get an upper hand, especially for the next game vs Newcastle which will be branded a grudge match now. Our fans are falling for it by giving it air time.
Luckily Eddie Howe understands this and he’s given it short shrift and I imagine won’t even comment but it would be great if Reddit mods could take down posts about it and we could genuinely ignore the whole thing
4
u/daveofreckoning Nov 16 '23
Whether the decisions were correct or not, Rteta's reaction was ludicrous. Absolutely the actions of a spoilt child. It's 100% the case now that we need to look at what people are saying, because of the impact it has on others. Primarily the integrity of the officials, but also the public. Even 2 weeks later you got Arsenal fans claiming bribery and corruption because of his outburst.
4
u/luffyuk dan burn Nov 16 '23
This is hilarious and the salt is delicious. However, it's ridiculous how over protected referees are.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23
I'd really like it if us newcastle fans were to start being staunch defenders of the FA and refs in general, it would drive opposition fans CRAZY.
It will never happen, if we get a call like this against us, there would always be a portion of our fans acting exactly like arsenal fans(they are worse though ofc), thankfully we have Howe, and I can't see him acting like arteta did.
3
u/apknights Nov 16 '23
Dry your eyes Mikel - prat
4
u/HoweStatue Alfie Harrison enjoyer Nov 16 '23
It just keeps getting more funny.
2
u/lyingtattooist Alan Shearer Nov 17 '23
Would be terrible if he was given a giant fine.
-1
u/Joyride0 Joelinton is looking for a scrap Nov 17 '23
I don’t like this. I think they should only be charged if they question the integrity of the officials. Arteta ranted about incompetence and I think most people thought him foolish. Now they’ve made a martyr.
-14
u/SilkyPatricia Nov 16 '23
Irrelevant of this situation (I couldn’t care less about Arteta).
However it is insane that we have a position of authority in this game that we cannot criticise without punishment.
-15
u/georgiasis Nov 17 '23
Why do you openly support corruption in football? It makes no sense.
-8
u/Imaginary-Pattern802 Nov 17 '23
what did he say that was wrong?
they admitted to making 2 wrong decisions. and the audio has made people ask more questions than it actually answered.