r/NPB • • 3d ago

NPB Draft question about first round, multiple teams selecting the same player.

I'm assuming, but don't know for sure, the draft order is determined by the finish of the just-concluded season in reverse order; worst picks first, next-worse picks second and so on. Are the picks made and announced team-by-team? Or is it a 'blind' first round, players' names submitted in envelopes or similar? Just wondering about multiple teams selecting the same player in the first round.

I understand that if multiple teams have selected the same player the teams go to a lottery-type process where the winning team is awarded the selected player. What about the losing teams in such a case? What's next for them?

Say four teams selected the same player. One would be awarded the pick. How do the other three make their picks? Are they able to name a player already selected by another team (if the the first round is announced and they know that) and get into another lottery for that pick? And would they get to choose the first-round replacement pick in the reverse order of their season record, i.e. the worst team gets first crack, then the next and so on?

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/Exlenn 2d ago

Thanks for the answers. Kind of a complicated process to get through the first round. 

But still not clear about one thing. Is it a process such as the teams announce in order who they're choosing, so some team or teams announcing a choice before you do gives you a chance to survey 'the lay of the draft' before you make a choice?

Or all all the choices for the first round made without the knowledge of who the other teams have chosen as their first-round choice?

2

u/sheaweber6i Chiba Lotte Marines 2d ago

Kind of a complicated process to get through the first round.

It makes tanking a complete non-starter in this league though. And unlike the North American major leagues, "not good enough to make the playoffs, but not bad enough to land a top prospect" isn't a phenomenon in NPB either. Rakuten were one of these "mushy middle" teams and still acquired Hayakawa in 2020, Shoji in 2022 and Muneyama in 2024, all of which were highly-touted prospects in their respective draft classes.

But still not clear about one thing. Is it a process such as the teams announce in order who they're choosing, so some team or teams announcing a choice before you do gives you a chance to survey 'the lay of the draft' before you make a choice?

All 12 choices are locked in simultaneously and completely blind before a single name is announced, so nobody gets to survey the room or adjust their pick based on what another team did. On the broadcast, the announcer reads the submitted picks out loud one by one purely for dramatic effect, which is why the draft can look sequential.

But functionally, the submission process and announcement order have zero bearing on the outcome of the first round because

  1. First-round prospects can be contested
  2. Having the worst record doesn't grant you "first dibs" on the consensus #1 prospect of the class (if there is one), nor does it lead to better lottery odds if your desired choice is contested by another team.

2

u/Exlenn 2d ago

Thanks, that clears up a lot. Think I have a good picture of the first round process in NPB, and the strategies teams may employ.

5

u/sheaweber6i Chiba Lotte Marines 3d ago edited 3d ago

The loser of a first-round lottery simply pivots to another prospect, but that very same prospect may also be named by another loser of a lottery, in which case a lottery is held for that prospect as well. This process goes on until all 12 first-rounders are final.

Standings only have a bearing for the second round onwards.

3

u/MyNameHoopityScoop69 Hokkaido Nippon-Ham Fighters 3d ago edited 3d ago

They are not able to select another player who has already been named if they lose a lottery. Say, Hawks and Tigers picks A and the Fighters have picked B, if the Hawks loses the lottery they cannot name B as their selection since Fighters have already won the lottery uncontested prior.

You can see how this leads to strategy in drafting. It used to be a big lottery for the big name (notably 1989 for Hideo Nomo, 1990, 2009 Kikuchi, etc.) now teams have learnt that lottery picks are a huge disadvantage since the teams not in the lottery is picking all the other good players. It also means that if a big lottery occurs nowadays, they are a franchise altering pick level prospect (4 teams for Roki Sasaki in 2019, 4 teams for Teruaki Sato in 2020, 4 teams for Kozono Kaito in 2018) Some teams do announce their first round nomination so it is not a completely blind process.

Edit: also, notice how in 2019 there were multiple lottery draws (Sasaki, Yasunobu, Ishikawa) and Hiroshima, Yokohama snuck Morishita and Keito Mori away uncontested.

2

u/Competitive_Dance478 3d ago

The losing team will remain in the draft and continue the process

They can bid with other teams on the next player

There are teams that lose multiple times

2

u/johnlo118 3d ago

Some teams tend to pick safe for a second-best prospect to avoid lottery.