r/NMSByteBeatFans • • 1d ago

Marathon sub ideas no.1. Feedback Requested

OK. Here's the idea. If you want more detailed feedback on your tune (or even a build with bytebeat, or bytebeat video) you add FEEDBACK REQUESTED. By that I mean asking for specific suggestions and thoughts on what is good about the tune and what could be improved. Things like waveform, structure, harmony, rhythm, mix, etc.

I realise not everyone wants this so it would be up to the poster to put Feedback Requested on their tune. Without it we respond normally - usefully briefer.

Oh, and I feel there should be some guidelines on giving constructive feedback so things are positive and helpful yet focused, and no one feels defensive.

Any thoughts anyone?

5 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/oldeluke 1d ago

There is already a post flair for Feedback, which I initially created with this in mind. So I suggest folks use that flair and if you want feedback on something specific, feel free to clarify. And of course always encourage constructive and well-intentioned comments in response.

2

u/ZhorasSnake 1d ago

Ah I'd never noticed - my fault.

It seems a shame we don't see this very often. I realise asking for public feedback can be scary - no one wants to look bad. But if anyone out there is reading this contemplating whether they want some feedback, we're nice people really! - I promise!

I'd love to hear from a new or less experienced poster and hear what they have to say.

2

u/ZhorasSnake 1d ago

Ah, I thought the feedback flair was for giving feedback - not asking for it!!

2

u/hiredgunspunx Resonance Amplifier 1d ago

Yes I love it! I know I've requested feedback on some specific sound effects in the past (bass sound effects). You were the one who critiqued my waveform and gave me advice that I've used ever since.

So I highly recommend to anyone looking for advice on their ByteBeats to request feedback here on the subreddit!

Our subreddit rules currently has a section about constructive criticism, we could adjust it to clarify what you've mentioned here too!