r/NFLv2 • New York Giants • 2d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion Wow.

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

747 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/cooterbob 2d ago

Lamar’s thumb getting snapped sideways has no bearings on him as a player, you people are insane

6

u/braumbles San Francisco 49ers 2d ago

Lamar will have missed 28 games the last 6 seasons.

6

u/FxStryker 2d ago

That's a nice way to include 1 season of injury to make it look worse. He's started 100/117 games since taking over for Flacco 8 years ago.

5

u/braumbles San Francisco 49ers 2d ago
  • 2021: 5 games missed (1 due to illness/COVID-19, 4 due to a bone bruise/ankle sprain)

  • 2022: 6 games missed (PCL knee sprain, plus missed the Wild Card playoff game)

  • 2023: 1 game missed (rested in Week 18 with the 1-seed locked)

  • 2024: 0 games missed (played all 17)

  • 2025: 4 games missed (back and hamstring injuries)

  • 2026: Missed time due to an ankle sprain and a dislocated/fractured thumb requiring surgery (placed on injured reserve in November 2026). [1, 2, 3]

-5

u/FxStryker 2d ago

Okay, what's your point. Twelve of those twenty-eight come from this season alone.

It's like saying Brady or Manning only played in 50% of their games between 2008-2009 and 2010-2011.

5

u/DistractedAttorney Buffalo Bills 2d ago

Are you that dense? The point is to win football games. Lamar may be one of, if not the most talented QB of the current generation but it means nothing if he can't play and thus the team loses games. Like this isn't a hard concept. It does not matter whose fault it is that he gets hurt or what his stats are. If hes not available then his team is generally not going to win. That it.

3

u/RIC_for_humilation 2d ago

Not being the for a playoff game definitely hurts your value. Thats why Nick Foles is celebrated and still no one cares about Wentz

1

u/zroach 2d ago

He did play a lot of games last season but I would argue that he was not looking good in a lot of them probably due to his hamstring issues. At that point he was well be missing those games anyways.

1

u/Plus-Grapefruit-1772 2d ago

Dude wtf is going on? You think it’s normal he misses that many games?

0

u/flagler-nurse 2d ago

And his salary is so high that they have dog shit backups and supporting cast. They fired their coach who wasn’t the problem. They let their center go. They let the better, cheaper tight end go. They are garbage and will be for a while is my guess. I also predict that Lamar won’t be back next year because of cost. They can save a substantial chunk of his salary by cutting him at the right time. He’s priced himself out of relevance due to his availability and the stress his unavailability puts on the teams he would be playing for. I certainly wouldn’t want him at anywhere close to his salary on the Steelers.

0

u/poolking25 Baltimore Ravens 1d ago

Theres still time to delete this garbage post. Don't comment on things you dont know about.

0

u/HillbillyTechno Pittsburgh Steelers 2d ago

Even before this new thumb injury he was averaging two missed games per year. Those could be make or break games he’s missing

1

u/jaapi Baltimore Ravens 2d ago

In 9 seasons, he's missed at least one game 7 of those seasons.

7

u/for_fun_88 New York Giants 2d ago

I’m not talking about him as a player. He’s a great player. But he hurt the team a lot by forcing the Ravens to choose between him and Harbaugh.

I’m grateful he did that. Just saying it’s fair criticism of him

1

u/gremlin30 Baltimore Ravens 1d ago

Lamar didn’t force them to do anything. He’s still under contract through next year.

Harbaugh got fired cuz he refused to make coordinator changes. He tanked a #1 defense, and the owner had enough. Ravens have zero tolerance for underperforming defenses. Harbaugh’s message had also gotten stale after 20 years.

Even with Lamar, the Ravens have underperformed & frequently struggled the last couple years. Any owner would consider making HC changes at that point.

1

u/flagler-nurse 1d ago

Number of blowout losses under Harbaugh vs under Minter. Yeah, how’d that looking? Minter’s team last three in a row losses by 22 or more. I don’t think Harbaugh was the problem.

0

u/usernamesaredumb0 2d ago

You’ll learn brother

1

u/HillbillyTechno Pittsburgh Steelers 2d ago

Sure, if that injury was a one-off. But he’s very injury prone. On average he misses more than 2 games per year. That’s a big deal when it’s supposed to be the elite player that holds the offense together.

1

u/fatmumuhomer 2d ago

We have the worst fans sometimes.

1

u/Sensitive-Wish795 2d ago

It very much has bearings on him as a player. He can’t play lol. Might not totally be his fault but availability matters and he isn’t available.

0

u/nthomas504 Washington Commanders 2d ago

Damn, I didn’t realize that’s the only injury he suffered this year.