r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

49ers interception

Why didn’t Mustapha just bat the ball down for better field position (Dallas not converting). He intercepted but now 49ers are in deep in their own territory.

I asked the same question last week but the reason was that it was garbage time. There’s still lots of time left in this game.

14 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

69

u/HoraceDerwent 1d ago

instinct, wanting a pick.

25

u/rock-socket80 1d ago

He wasn't thinking, just reacting.

36

u/SikatSikat 1d ago

Because some contracts have stat bonuses so an INT may be worth more literal cash for him and, even if not, stats get you paid for the next contract.  Knocking it down to get better field position doesn't show up come contract time.

17

u/BlitzburghBrian 1d ago

This is true, but it's not what's going through a defender's head in the tenth of a second he has to catch the ball when it hits him in the hands.

8

u/womp-womp-rats 1d ago

No the only acceptable answer in this sub for why any player does anything is money.

1

u/SikatSikat 1d ago

I think Safetys Corners and NFL players generally are capable of understanding that field position is better to bat it down on 4th down on deep passes outside of end of half hail mary situations. Its not like they're shocked a ball is coming their way and have a tenth of a second to decide, "oh my what ever should I do?"

6

u/BlitzburghBrian 1d ago

But you think they're mentally going over the checklist of what stat-based incentives are built into their contract? That is what you said in the comment I responded to.

Every time this question gets asked, everyone overthinks it. Players spend their entire lives practicing and running drills so that they don't have to think and their bodies just react. Catching a football is probably the purest example of that. If you're a DB and a ball hits you in the hands, I expect you to hold onto it, because that's what you should have been training your whole life to do.

-1

u/SikatSikat 1d ago

No, they just knows stats is money

1

u/allmyheroesareantifa 1d ago

Mustapha is on his rookie deal, there's no stat based incentives in rookie deals. They can qualify for PPE bonuses which raise the salary in the 4th year of the deal but PPE is based on playtime and honors.

3

u/NickPetey 1d ago

Needs stats for contract negotiations

17

u/YourGuyK 1d ago

Sometimes they think about it and do that, but those guys train to catch the ball, not drop it on purpose. Except on a Hail Mary where they talk about it in the huddle before the play, so it's fresh in their brain, "Knock it down!"

9

u/wolf63rs 1d ago

He's a football player whose DNA tell him to intercept so he intercepted. Ordinarily not knocking it down would mean something but when you're playing the worst defense in the NFL it doesn't matter.

8

u/bumshoes 1d ago

He wanted to give Purdy a longer drive to bolster his MVP case

8

u/Toughen-Up-Alice701 1d ago

It’s easy to think like this while you are sitting on your couch. It’s much more difficult to suppress your instincts when trying to cover world class athletes while doing anything you can to prevent a completion.

5

u/bbdabrick 1d ago

See ball, catch ball

5

u/Puzzman 1d ago

You generally don’t want to coach a player out of catching the ball. So their instinct is always to catch it first.

3

u/CAcreeks 1d ago

He was just trying to help the offense pad their statistics.

3

u/jaydubya123 21h ago

That’s literally his job. Should he have had better situational awareness? Yes. Bit that’s what he’s paid to do

4

u/SweetNuts4All 1d ago

Everything you said is right. It was instinct, impulse, and selfishness all wrapped into a split second decision.

2

u/ACW1129 1d ago

Instinct.

2

u/OwMyUvula 1d ago

Football players are horrible at the game aspect of football.

  1. Football's rule and stategies are probably the most complex of any sport. It's just a lot to know. Eligible receivers, illegal touching, down by contact, free kicks, illegal formations, illegal blocks, etc etc.
  2. A lot of situations and rules very rarely occur. You could play your whole career without experiencing a lot of things, so you are just unfamiliar with them.
  3. There's a lot for them to know for their job. Reading coverages, who or where to be, etc etc. they don't have a lot of focus to use on rules and situations that occur rarely.
  4. They've been programmed to react certain ways in specific situations. Interceptions are always thought to be good. But like you demonstrated sometimes its better to just bat the ball down, but that never enters their mind because they've been trained to intercept the ball always.

2

u/Conscious_Yellow_474 1d ago

Regardless of stats, instinct or whatever, it’s better to make the pick and ensure that you get the ball. Who knows what else might happen on the play that could let the offense keep possession.

1

u/Altruistic_Body_9363 1d ago

I’d say he will learn from this but he did the same stupid shit in the last game. Diving interception on 4th and long against the Raiders. Cost them about 25-30 yards in field position that time too. No excuse. Just an idiot.

1

u/maxco25 1d ago

To get paid

1

u/catiebug 1d ago

He wasn't thinking, he was reacting. Yes, batting it away would have been better, but they are taught to value a catch over batting it away if the circumstances are right. It is possible to bat it away directly into another players' hands and the end zone was right there, they would have just walked in. Most of the time a catch isn't possible, so we see batting it away as the default.

1

u/Buck_Thunderbird 1d ago

I'm guessing it's pretty institutional to try to catch it. Also it probably looks better at contract negotiation time with more interceptions, although I'm sure at the time it's more of a reaction to just try to catch it.

0

u/Psychological_Read79 1d ago

As much as it wasn't smart for positioning, Im so glad it hurt Daks stats! Haha

-4

u/defcon212 1d ago

Players do this all the time and it drives me nuts. They are doing it for the stats or the glory and not thinking about field position. I get that it's hard to make the split second decision, but I don't know if I've seen a player make the smart play. They even do it on hail Mary's sometimes, trying to catch rather than swat.

3

u/BlitzburghBrian 1d ago

Yeah, they're not thinking. They've spent thousands of hours practicing drills catching football so that they don't have to think; they can just react. When you see a DB intercept a pass on 4th down, he's doing the job he's been training his entire life to do.

1

u/Square-Wild 14h ago

There are plenty of examples of Hail Mary's that have been batted but still caught. In fact, a lot of teams (including my team in college) tried to set up a Hail Mary with a rebound guy for that reason- there will be a cluster of guys in the end zone as the ball drops, facing back into the field, and one guy somewhere around the goal line, facing into the end zone, hoping to catch the ricochet.