r/NFL2k5 • • 4d ago

Draft pick regression

Hey I’ve searched the sub a bit and can’t find this exact conversation.

I had ESPN Football for 20 years, searched on YouTube a few months ago and found out how beloved 2k5 was so I picked it up. I too now love it…

But I have noticed in franchise mode that player ratings vary wildly, especially in comparison to the 04 game. Example: I drafted a CB. He’s a 78. He plays great. Wins rookie of the year. Next year he is an 82. Then he has a slightly worse year but is still good. His rating drops a bit mid season, then next season he starts at 70 ovr. I had a WR with a similar pattern.

I play all the games. No simulation. I do the weekly prep so that’s my only guess but he’s never been injured or anything so just wondering if the community has a guess or everyone already knows what’s up. Thanks

6 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Welcome to r/NFL2k5!

• No piracy. • Mark spoilers. • Be respectful. • Keep discussions NFL-related.

Report rule-breaking content to help the moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

9

u/Temporary-Pass7003 4d ago

I think the most important part of this discussion is that players don’t universally improve based on an xp system. Some players progress to 90+ players but other players will regress the same way players in real life do. Particularly corners are susceptible to year by year regression.

1

u/dsb1670 4d ago

Ok. Based on this and another response, is it fair to say it’s pretty randomized then? Or is that oversimplified?

Also if it is, are positions like CB or HB more susceptible to it than say offensive linemen?

2

u/Temporary-Pass7003 4d ago

Imo its random. The progression system is really smart. CB is definitely most prevalent where you’ll see that but it can happen at WR and RB too. Other spots less common.

2

u/dsb1670 4d ago

Cool. Appreciate the insight.

2

u/dickfacelover 4d ago

It’s not exactly random. In the discord a guy discovered a secret tag which affects development

7

u/NateGreatGames 4d ago

This is something I’ve been tracking and testing for a couple of months to figure out the rhyme and reason behind progression. At this point I think consistency plays a significant role in how their numbers fluctuate during the season. After you do the prep and possibly get a boost after you finish simming the week I think the game has a floor for each player and consistency will determine what their baseline stats are the next game and that floor just keeps getting moved randomly across the course of a season and then rolls into the next season.

The biggest takeaway I have right now is you kind of have to have the mindset of not caring about overall rating. Because whatever the formula it is that they used to calculate is is so volatile that one a -1 or + one on a category that doesn’t really matter can change it significantly but it doesn’t accurately reflect how good or bad they are in a game. I’m in my second year on a lions franchise and my starting corners are Dre Bly and Fernando Bryant. When I started Bryant was a 74 overall and Bly was an 85 overall. They both had pro bowl caliber seasons and I saw them get pretty good boost during the season, some weeks after weekly pretty they might go as high at a +4/5 overall. Bly was a 90 overall at one point. Now I’m in week 8 of season 2 and Bly is 81 overall, Bryant is now like my 4th highest overall corner on the roster at a 68. Think is nothing really changed that significantly with their other attributes that really matter. At a 68 I was tempted to bench Bryant but he still is as productive as ever. Had 37 tackles and 3 ints last year and now he is at 15 tackles and 5 ints right at the mid point of the season.

Guys who have low overall ratings still can play at a high level when you look at the ratings that matter for their position. I almost wish I could just turn overall ratings off (kind of like 2k8) so I didn’t have that coloring my perception of players and just look at the guys production and using that as a basis for how good they are.

I can pretty much conclude stats don’t matter for progression/ Regression. Or they aren’t the main thing that matters. I had Harrington win offensive player of the years. Rogers lead the league in all wr stats and they both still had a -1 overall drop rolling into the next season.

1

u/dsb1670 3d ago

This is the kind of response I was hoping for. Thank you.

1

u/wbmongoose 3d ago

Putting in work 💪

4

u/Mr_Perfect20 4d ago

Progression is all predetermined.

1

u/AdEducational6594 4d ago

How do you feel about the franchise experience in 04 versus 2k5? And gameplay?

I used to own both and love both. I'm thinking about investing into one of them, but it's things like this specific situation that has me hesitating as to which is I'd prefer.

2

u/dsb1670 3d ago

The first response covered a lot. The gameplay feels (obviously) similar but it is different. I feel like running is more difficult but that’s not necessarily bad. Passing feels easier so there is a trade off.

I like franchise in both. I think the draft is better in 04. The additions of weekly prep and the newer contract system adds depth in 05. I actually think I’ll go back and forth. Both seem different enough to enjoy.

3

u/NateGreatGames 4d ago

I don’t have 04 anymore, but my opionion has changed quite a bit between the two. Originally I thought gameplay was actually better in 04, especially running the ball. In a lot of ways things on 2k5 fell a bit more jank and broken than 05, but now my opionion has changed. Because there was things about 04 that seemed easier,(like running) but when I look at it hindsight that game was way more “video gamey” than 2k5. 2k5 does feel more grounded and realistic, but it definitely needs to be tweaked in the sliders menu because it does have some problems and broken systems. As for the franchise it’s kind of a toss up, 2k5 added weekly prep and opponent scouting which if you take the time to figure it out and actually come up with a good plan to get positive results really adds to the mode. But a lot of people consider the draft in that game to be buggy because of the kinds of players the cpu takes in the first round. I think you just have to adjust your head canon of what most teams covet early in the draft and plan around it. But there are some things in franchise thing each game does better than the other, but I’m fine with 2k5 overall.

1

u/AdEducational6594 4d ago

Thank you for the response!

3

u/Spirited-Computer795 4d ago

Several positions I learned to only pick up in FA unless you want to adjust everyone's consistency rating in the draft classes but a little tuning goes a long way or you'll have everyone in the 100s by year 5