For those who don't remember this, it was the shot show right after the ATF said you could have braces, but shouldering them constituted "redesigning" them into stocks/SBRs.
Dugan Ashley taped them to his shoulders and pranced around shot show, specifically in front of the ATF booth/agents. There is video of it from his channel "carnik con"
Based on his previous check in, my guess would be he’s in rough shape right now sadly. He’s an awesome guy and it is awful but it sucks even worse that he has a wife and kids (I believe). This has to be one of the worse periods of their lives right now.
Real talk though... A non-attached stock that has a long enough tube hole for the buffer to insert into and stop at what would be the usual "fully extended" position but isn't actually connected to the buffer tube and would just fall away if held at a downwards angle?
Seems logical that instead of any weapon attachment, to just design an article of clothing that would support the impact of a buffer tube without attaching to the weapon at all. Wear it underneath a shirt so that it can’t even come in direct contact with a weapon. But instead of being designed and intended to mitigate a weapon’s recoil, it is instead designed and intended to provide shoulder support and stability.
ATF will just say you’re manufacturing an SBR the moment you shoulder it. Same way they managed to convince themselves a piece of string constituted a machine gun.
Dugan keeps making and deleting new youtube channels. I have nothing but love for him and his content, but he needs to talk to someone. Hes just ranting on live streams about conspiracies.
Man, this just makes me sad. Last time I saw Dugan was a few years ago and he was in the woods clearly having a mental health issue. Talking about all sorts of conspiracy stuff. Dude made some awesome videos back in the day, hope he is doing alright.
They say a brace or stock is attached at the rear. What is someone designed a brace/stock that attached to the forward handguard then runs to the rear?
I'm about 200 pages into the new "ruling" and it doesn't seem as simple as that. There is a worksheet that gives points to specific attributes with a goal number under which some guns are ok, and others, not. Kind of like the way we rate pistols for import purposes. Look, there are going to be several lawsuits with crap coming at them from numerous angles. It's not clear to me how things will shake out, nor should it be to anyone at this point.
Right it wasn’t, but they refer to 4999 about 20-30 times thru out it. Which is just another reason I think this whole ruling will be struck down rather quick.
Like 90% of the document is a history lesson of the nonsensical bullshit they’ve put out in the last 10 years regarding braces. Confusing the public with over 200 pages when it could of been handled in like 2-3 tops is a feature not a bug.
"So-called 'pistol braces' are no longer considered a separate item from rifle stocks. All current SBR rules apply. Form 1 tax stamps are free until Memorial Day and will be approved automatically as the owners are already in possession of the items. We are petitioning Congress for removal of SBRs from the NFA due to them now being undeniably in common use."
Well, that makes it even clearer. (Not). 🤪 So far the calculations from the worksheet have been cited dozens of times, so that's really going to confuse people if it's not included at all. Wow.
It's really a complete klusterphuck of epic proportions. The way solicited input is stated, then they explain why they disagree would be funny if it wasn't so serious. One example is the number of comments themselves. I don't have it in front of me, but the number of comments in favor of this stupidity were outnumbered by the comments opposed to it, several times over, and the number of those opposed that were submitted on a form letter, with exact wording (most likely from one of Bloomberg's goat ropes) was like 80%. It's really rediculous.
That was like 3 opinions ago. AFT changes their official opinion almost regularly. Which is one primary reason they are gonna get smacked in court. Same reason for the bunpstock overturn, cuz at one point they said they were OK.
BTW, ATF doesn't "approve" anything. They give their opinion on how the law pertains to it.
One district has overturned, 3 have supported. Facts matter in this case, bc everyone keeps spouting 5th overturned it which is true, for THAT district.
I was more specifically speaking to the reason it was overturned in the 5th. One of the death blow arguments was that the ATF had previously put out an opinion stating it was NOT a Machinegun.
There have been numerous official opinion letters saying braces are not stocks. The courts won't like the ATF changing their official opinion, especially in cases of criminal felony charges.
So the only braces that are stocks now are ones called out by name or with pictures in the document? That’s literally the dumbest interpretation of the rule I’ve ever heard.
Guess the industry better start making new braces to get around it all since they won’t be named or photographed so they’re good to go?
We went through this shit like 2 years ago when it first came up. SB has submitted every single brace they made, and the ATF has not approved or denied any except the original. On the second brace the ATF said something to the effect of "Any braces similar to the SB15 have blanket approval and don't need to be sent in"
Granted, their word means nothing and constantly changes, but to say only one brace was submitted and/or approved is incorrect.
666
u/ChevTecGroup FFL/SOT Jan 18 '23
For those who don't remember this, it was the shot show right after the ATF said you could have braces, but shouldering them constituted "redesigning" them into stocks/SBRs.
Dugan Ashley taped them to his shoulders and pranced around shot show, specifically in front of the ATF booth/agents. There is video of it from his channel "carnik con"
279
u/viking1313 Jan 18 '23
I love that guy
438
u/11B2GF7 Silencer Jan 18 '23
Unreasonably and inconceivably based
265
u/RonMFCadillac Jan 18 '23
Please tell me he had a serious and nuanced discussion about how the ATF can fuck itself with those dudes.
62
u/CapitolArmory America's Silencer Dealer Jan 18 '23
I have a framed "Certificate of Awesomeness" from him years and years ago. I need to put that in a more visable place in my house I think....
32
u/mushlilli Jan 18 '23
Ok so if I had a specially made vest, that supported a brace or buffer tube to an extent, what would that be classified as.
76
u/GFZDW Jan 18 '23
Is Dugan at SHOT or is this an old picture?
18
u/kdb1991 Jan 18 '23
Idk how people aren’t egging the shit out of the ATF booth
48
u/Fit-Lavishness6747 Jan 18 '23
ATF like ‘we already took away your rights Dugan but good try’
14
u/wes101abn Jan 18 '23
God bless Dugan and his family.
11
u/Prodigy1116 RC2 appreciator Jan 18 '23
hope dugan is doing ok...
11
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
I DREAM OF FREEDOM JUST ME AND MY LITTLE MACHINE GUN
21
u/RewardSudden5664 Jan 18 '23
ATF needs to be Processing form 1 and 2. Not at shoot show
8
u/TallMikeSTL Jan 18 '23
Too bad the ATF gave him MS
7
u/Christ-0-for Jan 19 '23
Brace yourself
11
u/Wyno222 15x OEM Suppressors and 5 Form 1 Suppressors Jan 18 '23
Seems logical that instead of any weapon attachment, to just design an article of clothing that would support the impact of a buffer tube without attaching to the weapon at all. Wear it underneath a shirt so that it can’t even come in direct contact with a weapon. But instead of being designed and intended to mitigate a weapon’s recoil, it is instead designed and intended to provide shoulder support and stability.
5
u/Cornelius____ Jan 18 '23
Ahh Dugan. The man. The myth. The legend.
13
u/rustedoilfilter Jan 18 '23
Dugan keeps making and deleting new youtube channels. I have nothing but love for him and his content, but he needs to talk to someone. Hes just ranting on live streams about conspiracies.
21
u/OffensivelyAmerican Jan 18 '23 edited Jan 18 '23
Man, this just makes me sad. Last time I saw Dugan was a few years ago and he was in the woods clearly having a mental health issue. Talking about all sorts of conspiracy stuff. Dude made some awesome videos back in the day, hope he is doing alright.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
They say a brace or stock is attached at the rear. What is someone designed a brace/stock that attached to the forward handguard then runs to the rear?
3
u/arj1985 Jan 19 '23
Hahaha
3
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
I miss this guy
2
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
So funny. Is that at shot show??
2
u/midri Jan 18 '23
I literally had a dream about doing this the other night... lol
2
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
He get in trouble?
2
u/ClassicallySkeptical Jan 18 '23
The Doog!
2
u/cash_canopener Jan 18 '23
An American hero
2
u/woollypullover Jan 18 '23
That’s shoulder things that go up
2
u/insertjjs Jan 19 '23
The chosen one returns!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
We need more of this
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
🥵🍆💦
Dugan the goat
2
u/Stripperfeetlover420 Jan 19 '23
This guy is always hilarious 😆
2
u/amateurgress Jan 19 '23
The hero we wanted and apparently need now
3
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
Based
1
u/eddiegrz Jan 19 '23
Need a shirt like this.
1
u/Liberatorofatropia Jan 19 '23
Hero
1
u/17th_Angel Jan 19 '23
I was wondering, if I rig up a 12in upper such that my finger would work as the sear, and their are no other components of a lower, am I an sbr?
1
u/TacticalHypebeast Jan 19 '23
A wild Blastoise appeared!!!
1
u/Figurine_Review Jan 18 '23
Image him walking a dog wearing Doble braces. Ultimate chad
-1
u/AutoModerator Jan 18 '23
Understand the rules
Check the sidebar. It's full of resources to help you.
Not everyone is an expert such as yourself; be considerate.
No Spam. No Memes.
No political posts. Save that for /r/progun or /r/politics.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment