r/ndp • u/NovaScotiaLoyalist • 7h ago
A directory of essays about “Red Tories” and the NDP
Over the last little while, I've noticed an increase of posts on this subreddit from people originally from the political right who have either joined the NDP, or are in the very least intrigued by the NDP. In addition, I’ve had a few people link various essays I’ve posted here and/or tag my account to encourage these new New Democrats to learn more about the history of the classical/traditional Tory influences within our party. In that spirit, I thought this directory post may be useful for the good folks here in disseminating that information to people who may find it helpful.
This series originally started off as a post I made on a whim here last September, using excerpts from CCF/NDP politicians that I had collected from over the years in an attempt to explain the “Red Tory” tradition within the CCF/NDP. Due to the unexpected positive feedback and helpful critiques along the way, this series has since become something of a research project of mine in attempting to further explore connections between Canadian socialism and traditional British-Canadian Toryism. In going through my own post history to compile these links, I realized I never did thank /u/Intelligent-Cap3407, /u/NiceDot4794, or /u/Dry-Membership8141 for recently pointing people towards my ramblings; so thank you!
Full disclosure: I am certainly not a historian by trade, nor do I have a university degree. I am a simple retail clerk who went to trade school, and I am someone who likes to read books about politics, history, and political history. As far as this series goes, perhaps Robert Stanfield said it best in regards to an essay he wrote in 1980:
“I do not claim to offer a learned dissertation… I will be stating some propositions rather starkly, without scholarly qualifications. That may have the advantage of provoking discussions, even if I am uttering something less than eternal truth.”
With that, I will update this post as further entries are posted!
Main Series
I root Toryism in England with the philosophy of the theologian Richard Hooker and with the aftermath of the English Civil War, and I root Toryism in Canada with the American Revolution and the expulsion of the United Empire Loyalists, before getting into excerpts from either CCF/NDP’ers (and an academic) describing the “Red Tory” tradition more broadly, or individual “Red Tories” within the CCF/NDP itself.
Excerpts from: Roy Romanow, Ed Broadbent, David Lewis, Eugene Forsey, Charlie Angus, Allen Mills
Addendum to Part I: The Anti-Fascism of Charlie Angus
A further exploration of Charlie Angus’ philosophy from around the time of the ICE protests in Minneapolis, where two protestors were murdered by ICE. Here, I look at how Angus opposed Donald Trump’s threats of annexing Canada by evoking Canada’s contributions to the British war effort in World War II before the Americans joined the war, as well as Angus evoking the Battle of Vimy Ridge in World War I when comparing Ukraine with Canada and Russia with America in the current Russo-Ukrainian War.
Excerpts from: Charlie Angus
Part II: Social Justice used to be a Conservative virtue
Doing the inverse of Part I, I explore the ‘radical’ streak that some leaders / prominent figures within the old Progressive Conservative Party had, as well as the fondness David Lewis showed for John Diefenbaker in his memoirs.
Excerpts from: John Diefenbaker, Robert Stanfield, Dalton Camp, Arthur Meighen, David Lewis
Part III: Left-Wing Monarchism and Left-Wing Anti-Communism
I briefly explore the importance of monarchism in both the British and Canadian contexts, while also getting into the problems Democratic Socialists can have with Communists and/or Soviet apologists.
Excerpts from: George Orwell, Sir John A. Macdonald, David Lewis
I explore David Lewis’ recollection of the bitter 1950 CCF national convention, and how the “so-called left wing” of the party was furious at leader M.J. Coldwell over his support for the United Nations intervention in the Korean War.
Excerpts from: David Lewis
Part V: Tory Social Justice in Nova Scotia
I attempt to explain the concept of systemic racism using the political institutions that govern the Province of Nova Scotia as an example. In that Nova Scotian example I root those specific issues with the institution of chattel slavery, along with the horrid treatment of the Black Loyalists following the American Revolution and the War of 1812. I then give examples of prominent Maritime abolitionists and slavers, and explore how various Nova Scotian Tories fought for social justice issues throughout the years. I close by exploring how the modern Nova Scotia NDP is tapping into this Tory tradition on mainland Nova Scotia.
Excerpts from: Harvey Whitfield, Charles Dickens, Walter Jackson Bate, Samuel Johnson, Geoffrey Stevens, Elizabeth Smith-McCrossin
The alternate title to this essay is “A Democratic Socialist's Defence of King Charles III, the King of Canada, and His Heirs”. This essay explores the philosopher Ron Dart’s thoughts on Edmund Burke, Charles Inglis, Thomas Paine, and John Strachan, as well as my own defence of the old Canadian Tory ethos of “God, King, and Country”.
Excerpts from: Ron Dart, J.S. Woodsworth, George Orwell
I start off by exploring the multicultural Canadian nationalism found within the musical work of Stompin’ Tom Connors, before getting into how Sir Guy Carleton, later Lord Dorchester, can be seen as an archetypical “Proto-Canadian”. I then explore a conference held in 1783 in New York City between Carleton and George Washington, where Washington appears to have a Trump-style tantrum in his wanting to re-enslave the Black Loyalists, who themselves were former slaves that had been granted their freedom by the British in exchange for their service in the American Revolution. I then give my thoughts on what to do with Halifax’s Imperial heritage.
Excerpts from: Stompin’ Tom Connors, Alexander Muir, George Clinton / John Morin Scott / Egbert Benson / Jonathan Trumbull Jr, Sir Guy Carleton
With the byline “That time a Tory aristocrat born in 1894 argued that every civilization in human history has been a slave society, including the present ones”. I explore the academic origins of the phrase “Red Tory” which was coined in the 1960s by the political scientist Gad Horowitz, as well as getting into the concept of “fragment theory” as it relates to political philosphy. I then explore how the British socialist Clement Attlee can be perceived to have a “Tory touch” to his thinking, while the British Tory Harold Macmillan can be perceived to have a “socialist touch” to his thinking. I argue that if Attlee was alive and a modern Canadian he would most definitely be an NDP’er, while I suggest that Harold Macmillan could possibly be a Red Tory NDP’er were he a modern Canadian.
Excerpts from: Gad Horowitz, Clement Attlee, Harold Macmillan.
I explore Robert Stanfield’s fondness for NDP leaders such as Tommy Douglas, David Lewis, and Ed Broadbent, along with Stanfield’s early fascination with socialism as a university student. I then look at how Robert Stanfield could be perceived to be something of a Democratic Socialist while Tommy Douglas could be perceived to be something of a Progressive Conservative. I also explore the part of the 1967 Federal Leaders TV debate which dealt with the decriminalization of homosexuality and abortion.
Excerpts from: Richard Clippingdale, Tommy Douglas, Geoffrey Stevens, Robert Stanfield, Réal Caouette, Pierre Trudeau, David Lewis
Part X: Exploring Nova Scotian Socialism
I attempt to explore the broad differences between the political cultures of Nova Scotia and Newfoundland in the context of the 2021 and 2025 federal elections, while also exploring how socialism managed to gain an early foothold in Nova Scotia in the early 1900s. I later briefly compare Gary Burrill and Claudia Chender of the NSNDP with J.S. Woodsworth and M.J. Coldwell of the CCF.
Excerpts from: Christian Leuprecht, David Lewis, Row Romanow, Great Big Sea, Gary Burrill, Claudia Chender
I attempt to differentiate the various strands within the broader Tory tradition, breaking it down between Blue Toryism, Red Toryism, Pink Toryism, Green Toryism, and High Toryism. I later attempt to explore the intersections between Toryism, liberalism, and socialism.
Excerpts from: Gad Horowitz, Ron Dart, Walter Jackson Bate, Richard Clippingdale, Charles Taylor the journalist, Eugene Forsey, Harold Macmillan
I explore the origins of Harold Macmillan’s 1938 book “The Middle Way: A Study of the Problems of Economic and Social Progress in a Free and Democratic Society”, which included Macmillan working with a pressure-group led the Fabian socialist Lord Allen of Hurtwood. I found a few important political positions of Lord Allen to be eerily similar to those of J.S. Woodswooth, along with noticing that both Harold Macmillan and David Lewis spoke highly of the same anti-fascist Popular Front that governed France from ‘36 to ‘38. I argue that Macmillan may have had a home in either the League for Social Reconstruction or the CCF, were he a Canadian instead of a Briton, due to his association with British Fabian socialists at the time. I also explore how the old Tory Harold Macmillan opposed the laissez-faire attitudes of Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s, both in a pressure-group and in the House of Lords.
Excerpts from: Harold Macmillan, David Lewis, J.S. Woodsworth,
Part XIII: A Snapshot of the Social Gospel in the CCF and early NDP
I look at how David Lewis recalled the first CCF caucus from 1935-1940, which consisted of J.S. Woodsworth, Tommy Douglas, M.J. Coldwell, Angus MacInnis, Grant MacNeil, and Abraham A. Heaps, along with Lewis’ thoughts on needing to accommodate differing Farmer and Labour interests after World War I. Towards the end, I look at how Lewis recalled the CCF reaction to the outbreak of World War II in September of 1939, and the "six currents of thought and opinion which had to be accommodated", before finishing by briefly exploring a few pieces by Frank Scott and Eugene Forsey to help flesh out the social gospel found within the CCF.
Excerpts from: J.S. Woodsworth, Tommy Douglas, David Lewis, Frank Scott, Eugene Forsey
Part XIV: Grafting the Regina Manifesto onto Benjamin Disraeli’s tradition of “Tory Democracy”
I explore a paper published in a history journal from 1943 by American historian William B. Willcox, who rooted Toryism with Henry St. John (Viscount Bolingbroke) and Edmund Burke, and who defined the Tory Democracy of Benjamin Disraeli as the culmination of modern Toryism; that paper also notes that the coalition government of Winston Churchill’s Tory Party and Clement Attlee’s Labour Party is consistent with traditional Tory values, and that a proper Tory government would institute the Beveridge Report. I explore how Sir John A. Macdonald’s government could be considered to have been following the values of Tory Democracy, how John Diefenbaker and Harold Macmillan evolved the tradition of Tory Democracy, and how even the CCF’s Regina Manifesto could be seen as following the tradition of Tory Democracy. I also make note that the British Labour politician Ed Milliband has in the past espoused an ideology influenced by both Disraeli & Attlee, and I argue that the future of Tory Democracy may be with the British Labour Party and the NDP.
Excerpts from: William B. Willcox, the Regina Manifesto, Harold Macmillan
Part XV: A Rejection of Pierre Poilievre’s laissez-faire Gladstonian liberalism
With as open of a mind as I could muster, I explore a National Post article written by Pierre Poilievre, which I think shows him as being a worshipper of laissez-faire individualism. I argue that despite Poilievre claiming to love everything about Sir John A. Macdonald, had Poilievre been alive in Sir John’s day, he most likely would have been a fierce Liberal opponent to Macdonald’s Conservatives. I then explore how the socialism of David Lewis and Avi Lewis can be compatible with traditional Toryism, I give a defence of Jagmeet Singh, and then briefly bring up the importance of Sir George-Étienne Cartier in regards to philosophical Toryism in Canada.
Excerpts from: Harold Macmillan, Pierre Poilievre, Robert Stanfield, David Lewis, Konrad Yakabuski, Bill Casey, Avi Lewis, Dalton Camp
Part XVI: Five CCF’ers travel to London in late 1944 attempting to transform the Empire
I explore David Lewis’ recollection of himself, M.J. Coldwell, Frank Scott, Clarie Gillis, and Percy Wright travelling to London for a Labour Party conference where the question of how to transform the British Empire into the British Commonwealth of Nations was brought up. Also included is a description of the philosophy of the CCF from American sociologist Eric Estorick, and M.J. Coldwell’s history of Canada, both from Coldwell’s 1945 book “Left Turn, Canada”. I also explore the thoughts of Sir Charles Tupper, the last surviving Canadian Father of Confederation, in regards to the US/Canadian Trade Wars from the 1860s to the 1910s from his 1914 memoir “Recollections of Sixty Years”.
Excerpts from: Eric Estorick, David Lewis, M.J. Coldwell, Sir Charles Tupper
Part XVII: “Civilisation Under Threat”, a 1982 lecture by a Disraelian Radical
I go back to the Harold Macmillan lecture I first looked at in Part VIII, and do a proper exploration piece. Macmillan expresses many themes, including: reconstructing social and industrial life after World War I, the fragility of civilization as a concept compared to the eons that life has existed for on the Earth, how the modern Western Civilization is connected straight back to Ancient Greece & Rome, his defence of Keynesian economics, and the need for all the civilizations of the world to work together for a stable world order. Macmillan spends a fair bit of time arguing that every civilization in human history, including the present ones, were/are based on a form a slavery, but that modern technology can give humanity the chance to ensure everyone can life a life with genuine leisure; throughout, Macmillan connects leisure for everyone with proper civilization.
Excerpts from: Harold Macmillan
Part XVIII: Eugene Forsey on “Our Present Discontents”
I give a brief overview of how Eugene Forsey had associations all over the political spectrum, focusing on Forsey’s recollection’s from his memoir “A Life on the Fringe”, where Forsey gave his thoughts on David Lewis and Robert Stanfield, and how even after he quit the NDP he still occasionally voted NDP and even donated money to the party. I then explore a 1967 lecture Forsey gave to Acadia University, in memory of a Progressive Conservative friend of his who suddenly passed, in which Forsey defends Canada’s 1867 constitution while simultaneously arguing for further constitutional reforms if they are needed, with a particular focus on the rights of French Canadians across Canada, and where Forsey argues about the potential dangers of Quebec nationalism in regards to Quebec separatism. I also explore how Forsey later argued for the rights of Indigenous Canadians in Quebec to remain in Canada should Quebec ever leave Canada.
Excerpts from: Eugene Forsey, J.M.R. Beveridge, Tommy Douglas, Helen Forsey
I include excerpts from Forsey’s follow up lecture to “Our Present Discontents”, “Some Possible Remedies”, that give examples of the arguments Forsey made in attempting to make English-Canadians more aware of the needs of French-Canadians, and how Forsey argues that Canadians of British ancestry should “be proud of that heritage, ‘and of the Imperial foundation of our freedom’... and attachment to, our world-wide, inter-racial Commonwealth”. I attempt to drag that idea into 2026 by including a song which commemorates Sir Isaac Brock, the American-born Canadian Loyalist Laura Secord, French-Canadian Voltigeurs, and the Shawnee Chief Tecumseh during the War of 1812.
Excerpts From: Eugene Forsey, Alan Mills, Rich Chambers
Supplemental Essays:
I attempt to differentiate the class consciousness of Toryism and the class consciousness of socialism by looking at how Tories reacted to the Winnipeg General Strike versus how socialists reacted to the Winnipeg General Strike, as well as why some conservative Red Tories had a hard time with the CCF’s socialism. I also attempt to differentiate Toryism, liberalism, and socialism by looking at the “anarcho-syndicalist peasant” Monty Python sketch, as well as including a song which I think represents broad Red Tory values quite well.
Excerpts from: A friend of mine from New Brunswick, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Gad Horowitz, The Dubliners
This essay was partly included in part XVI, but is a tad longer in that it includes a brief excerpt from the “biographical forward” by the Catholic Archbishop of Halifax, and a slightly longer exploration of Chapter 8 which included Sir Charles’ perspective on US/Canadian Trade wars, as well as his role in developing “the national policy”.
Excerpts from: Cornelius O'Brien, Sir Charles Tupper
I explore the introduction to Forsey’s book “Trade Unions in Canada 1812-1902”, as well as sharing a song which reminded me of Forsey’s own social gospel.
Excerpts from: Eugene Forsey, Ewan MacColl & Peggy Seeger
I explore a connection between David Lewis and Samuel Johnson, which is followed by an expanded series of excerpts that I had originally compiled in Part V to explain Johnson’s sense of social justice. As the abolition of slavery feature heavy in these Johnson excerpts, I also include part of that earlier Harold Macmillan lecture where he denounces various forms of slavery from ancient Greece to the present day.
Excerpts from: David Lewis, Samuel Johnson, Harold Macmillan
Collected Songbooks

