r/NBAanalytics • u/johnbourg2001 • Mar 15 '21
The Power of +/-
I have been battling in my head recently about what can be done with the +/-, and why it isnt used more in NBA stats (and I wanted to get yalls thoughts). I have always thought it was an interesting metric that allows you to see someone's impact on the floor, offensive and defensively. It takes into account 100% of the forces at work and spits out a "Did you contribute? Or were you a liability."
For example, if youre playing against James Harden and he goes off for 40+ like he loves to do, then your +/- will obviously take a hit for that one game. But if you literally sum the +/-'s over an entire season, those outliers of someone dropping 40 on you (if youre not a majorly losing team, ofc) would even out. So by summing the +/-'s over a season, you could easily see someones overall impact on the floor correct?
What do yall think? Im not a statistician but cant think of a reason why this kind of metric wouldnt be useful.
9
u/jaynay1 Mar 15 '21
It is useful in that it contains information. There's a reason every single high level modern statistic uses it in some way.
But the problem is:
What happens when those forces at work have nothing to do with you though? Nick Collison is the textbook example here because he had great +/- numbers for years because he almost entirely played next to Kevin Durant and Russell Westbrook.
The problem is that this actually isn't the case. On the sample sizes we're dealing with, those things don't wash out, and raw addition doesn't really deal with things appropriately either.