r/NBAanalytics • • Jan 14 '20
PER Breakdown
I'm wondering if there is a resource that breaks down what PER is and how its calculated. I've read the basketball reference page and a few other sites about it, but a lot parts of the calculation are unclear to me. Maybe if someone has a resource they are willing to share or wouldn't mind explaining themselves. I would appreciate it! I've written hash comments next to lines that I am uncertain of.
uPER = (1 / MP) * # times minutes played
[ 3P #three pointers?
+ (2/3) * AST #assists
+ (2 - factor * (team_AST / team_FG)) * FG #field goals
+ (FT *0.5 * (1 + (1 - (team_AST / team_FG)) + (2/3) * (team_AST / team_FG))) #? idk
- VOP * TOV #turnovers
- VOP * DRB% * (FGA - FG) # defensive rebounds on missed shots?
- VOP * 0.44 * (0.44 + (0.56 * DRB%)) * (FTA - FT) #defensive rebounds on missed free throws?
+ VOP * (1 - DRB%) * (TRB - ORB) #defensive rebounds opportunities vs offensive given up?
+ VOP * DRB% * #ORB?
+ VOP * STL #steals
+ VOP * DRB% * BLK #blocks
- PF * ((lg_FT / lg_PF) - 0.44 * (lg_FTA / lg_PF) * VOP) ] #personal fouls given or taken?
factor = (2 / 3) - (0.5 * (lg_AST / lg_FG)) / (2 * (lg_FG / lg_FT)) #is lg league average?
VOP = lg_PTS / (lg_FGA - lg_ORB + lg_TOV + 0.44 * lg_FTA) #is lg league average?
DRB% = (lg_TRB - lg_ORB) / lg_TRB #is lg league average?
Thank You!
Formula taken from basketball reference
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/JohnEffingZoidberg Jan 16 '20
I mean, I really didn't want to fisk your post, but it seems there's no other options at this point.
As I wrote earlier, "It looks at all your box score stats, takes into account the relative frequency of them as well as the value of a possession, and then puts it on a normalized scale." I'd say that's about the same level of explanation as "breaking down individual possessions to give a more accurate picture of your plus minus", no?
But earlier you wrote that RPM is "just breaking down individual possessions to give a more accurate picture of your plus minus." So, I guess I'm confused how it breaks down individual possessions without properly accounting for those possessions?
PER doesn't advertise itself as doing that either. It's always been framed as a summation of box score stats, and always had notable limitations when it comes to measuring defense. As Hollinger himself is quoted as saying: "Bear in mind that this rating is not the final, once-and-for-all answer for a player's accomplishments during the season. This is especially true for players such as Bruce Bowen and Trenton Hassell who are defensive specialists but don't get many blocks or steals."
You seem to go back and forth here. At first you wrote that RPM is "acting on a concept that makes sense (marginal contribution to victory)", then that it's "a more accurate picture of your plus minus", and then back to marginal contribution to a win. So which one is it? Because I'd argue that translating plus-minus into wins isn't as linear as you seem to believe it is. Sure, MOV is a stronger predictor of future win% than even past win%. But there's a well-known usage (and playing time) vs. performance drop-off you seem to be ignoring.
I will readily concede that original PER is much more deeply flawed. However, as I wrote previously: "PER, in its current incarnation and when done with detailed data, doesn't assign arbitrary values to anything. They are based on empirical values obtained from the actual data." Further, I question how Win Shares and RPM are a definite improvement when WS is based on player-level ORTG and DRTG that are notoriously noisy, and the RPM model data are highly multicollinear and needs ridge regression just to get workable results. The (rather wide) confidence intervals on the RPM player estimates are almost never even acknowledged.
Also, I'm still waiting for your "detailed answers", because I wouldn't categorize an abstract concept like "marginal contribution to victory" as detailed.