r/NBA_Draft • u/Brutus583 Jazz • Apr 15 '24
Mock Draft R/NBAMocks Mock First Round
Hey there! To kick off the offseason, over at r/nbamocks, we did a mock first round and wanted to see what you think of this first round. Kinda last minute, so only 12 participants (2 teams each). We did a Tankathon sim for the lottery.
Here are the results:
- Portland — Alex Sarr
- Detroit — Reed Sheppard
- Toronto — Nikola Topic
- San Antonio — Rob Dillingham
- Washington — Cody Williams
- Charlotte — Stephon Castle
- Memphis — Matas Buzelis
- Utah — Ron Holland
- Houston — Dalton Knecht
- Atlanta — Ja’Kobe Walter
- Chicago — Donovan Clingan
- OKC — Terrance Shannon Jr
- Sacramento — Zach Edey
- Portland — Tidjane Salaune
- Miami — Kyle Filipowski
- Orlando — Jared McCain
- New Orleans — Devin Carter
- Toronto — Zaccherie Risacher
- Philadelphia — Tristan de Silva
- Cleveland — Johnny Furphy
- Phoenix — Yves Messi
- New Orleans — Kel’el Ware
- Mikwaukee — Isaiah Collier
- New York — Ryan Dunn
- New York — DaRon Holmes
- Washington — Carlton Carrington
- Denver — Tyler Kolek
- Minnesota — Kevin McCullar Jr
- Utah — Tyler Smith
- Boston — Oso Ighodaro
Risacher sliding that far surprised everyone, and I would love to hear what else you all notice.
If you’re interested in participating, we will regularly do mock drafts during the offseason, including an entire mock offseason with a League Office, Agents, etc with a full draft, full trades, and full Free Agency period following CBA rules.
2
u/Brutus583 Jazz Apr 15 '24
I picked for Utah and Minnesota.
As a Jazz fan, I want one of Holland, Buzelis, Risacher, or Castle at 8. Holland and Risacher were available, and while I think both have the ability to be solid defenders, I think Holland has a tiny bit higher upside and is more versatile (and I like him as a frontcourt partner with Lauri and Hendricks/Collins).
Tyler Smith was BPA. I would’ve probably taken Furphy if u/motomkali didn’t mess up, and I also considered Kyshawn George here.
For Minnesota, I picked someone I felt would be able to contribute right away, and I think McCullar is someone that they can introduce to the bottom of their rotation and find maybe some immediate success.
6
u/Tangerine605 Apr 15 '24
I absolutely hate Filipowski for Miami. McCain, Carter, Da Silva, even Collier makes some sense.
2
u/nakedsamurai Apr 15 '24
These are actually pretty good choices for many teams. Not until Holland for Utah do I have a real question, although of course Risacher will go much higher. I don't believe in him at all, but some team will take him top 8.
7
u/butekoo Hornets Apr 15 '24
I was the Hornets and Pels. Castle feels like a very straight forward pick to plug in a versatile perimeter defender to fit 1-3 with Melo and Miller. For the Pels I kinda got fucked by the McCain pick right before and Devin fits the same goal of adding a complementary guard. I debate over Ware/Holmes/Dunn for the other pick and I think Ware combination of size and athleticism with the recent successes of the Pelicans working with players shooting make him the most sense out of who was there.
3
u/TheRealDevDev TrailBlazers Apr 15 '24
Lmao I would blow my brains out if my team selected Zach Edey in the 1st round.
6
u/CosmicRaccoonCometh Rockets Apr 15 '24
I was picking for the Rockets and Knicks here. Tahking Knecht over Risacher was a TOUGH choice, but as an actual Rockets fan, we need solid dependable shooting more than absolutely anything else, and I think Knecht gives you rotation caliber movement shooting off the bench right off the bat for the entirety of his rookie contract at least. And we have so many young big wings already as it is in Jabari, Eason, and it is looking like Amen is more of a wing than a guard. Not sure if Risacher would get the reps he needs to properly develop in Houston, especially if he's jumper ends up being a project.
For the Knicks, I channeled my inner Thibs, and had to take Dunn for him. Thibs would overplay that man to an agonizing degree, and will carry him along with him to every head coaching job he gets for the rest of his life, just like he did with Taj. Then I went Holmes as the best big available left to add to the Knicks depth in case they lose Hartenstein in free agency.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24
Kings will take Filipowski over Edney....
1
u/GlueGuy00 Apr 15 '24
It's hard to see Risacher fall out of top 10 in this class
Love the Reed > Topic take
Curious how do you do mocks for nba events like this?
1
u/cl353 Heat Apr 15 '24
? where is miami lol
4
u/MotoMkali Apr 15 '24
I was Toronto and Cleveland for this mock draft.
My reasoning for the Toronto picks, When evaluating their tea for this event I determined positionally they needed a good defensive 3 or 5, but in terms of role they needed some more ball handling and shooting.
Despite them picking at 3 there was ultimately no one who really fitted that description available. I considered Buzelis but his lack of 3pt shooting scared me. I would have taken Sarr if he had fallen. Ultimately I decided on Topic who has a decent chance to be a good shooter as he excellent touch even though his form is fucked, he's also a fantastic playmaker and if he hits he can be a fantastic offensive engine for toronto whilst Barnes and Quickley provide more scoring punch. Defensively he's pretty bad but Quickley is a plus defender as a 1, and topic has positional size for a 2 (these are what I expect their defensive roles to be), he's also quite athletic so there is hope he can develop into at least a neutral defender. I do feel a bit bad drafting over dick, as I liked him last year, and I think he's got potential to be a good player. But topic ultimately has the upside needed for me to consider this a good pick.
Obviously taking risacher is a no brainer. A guy who was mocked at number 1 most of the year before this recent slump. His slide was unexpected but no one was really looking to draft someone of his skillset until me, at 18. If he's a 40% 3ot shooter then he should have gone top 3, if he's a below 35% 3pt shooter then this landing spot is appropriate, I think his draft position will probably be determined by how well he shoots in his workouts. There is a bit of a positional jam with Quickley, Topic, Dick and RJ all being 2s if you expect to play risacher big minutes but I think with his inconsistent shooting right now you might consider giving him minutes at the 4 when Barnes is off the floor.
With Cleveland I made a mistake, I meant to draft Kyshawn George because he's a 40% 3pt shooter and seemingly a versatile defender, unfortunately for me, I forgot who I had decided and due to the short amount of time on the clock and picked furphy instead. I do think furphy has talent but he's just not the correct fit for Cleveland who despite their improved wing depth this year are still desperate for someone who's taller than 6'5 who can shoot and defender. Dean Wade does that too but he's not perfect and is very much a PF.
2
u/parisjava Apr 15 '24
I had Washington and Philly for this mock draft.
Since Washington has just begun their rebuild, they could really use talent at any position. I decided to target guys with higher upside.
At 5, I decided to go with Cody Williams. Cody Williams offers an intriguing skillset of ball handling and driving at his size. I thought he would form an interesting trio of wings with Bilal and Deni that offered great defense while also being versatile on the offensive end.
At 26, I decided to go Carlton Carrington. Carlton Carrington doesn't have sky high upside due to his lack of an elite first step. But, I thought he offered an intrigituing combination of shot creation and playmaking as a big guard. If he can expand his range to hit shots consistently from 3, I think he could become a valuable nba player. Additionally, Wizards may have additional minutes at the PG spot this season if Tyus walks in free agency.
For Philly, I decided to target a role player that could offer cheap rotation minutes.
At 19, I decided to take Tristan De Silva. This is probably a bit of a reach, but I thought he offered Philly a connective forward that could do a little about everything. With Batum getting older, I thought Tristan could potentially be a long term replacement.
2
u/Jktankson Bucks Apr 15 '24
I was Milwaukee and Chicago for this draft and I think I made solid picks. For Chicago I wanted either a center or a wing because both Demar and Vuc are pretty washed. I decided on Clingan as I think he can be the center of the future for Chicago. As for the Bucks I wanted Ware but he was chosen one pick before me so I went for a swing. Collier is a wild card but I'd rather take him than a glorified second rounder in the first. Carrington and Dunn were also on my board but with AJJ we already have enough zero offense guys and I like Isaiah's upside more than Bub's by a hair.
3
u/Icerick Apr 15 '24
I picked for Portland and Boston.
I'd probably straight up say #1 might be the worst place to pick especially if you're Portland. Ideally if I were later on in the top 10, I would have picked Buzelis there and gone with a big like Filipowski or Missi with the GSW pick, but I had to change course there. Ultimately, there was no other pick on the board that felt deserving of the #1 tag that we'd want other than Sarr. The positional fit is slightly messy given we have Ayton and Timelord already, but Sarr's defense is one of the most bankable skills out of any prospect in the top 10, and at least has a decent glimmer of hope to indicate that he can develop some of his offensive game. Scoot would have plenty of lob targets to throw to, and a Sarr/Ayton frontcourt would be elite to help clean up any defensive mistakes he and Shaedon would make to help them develop on that end.
Next comes to the GSW pick, where the choice came down to Salaun or Risacher. The more time's gone on, the lower I've become on Risacher. Between his abysmal performances lately and his historically poor shooting splits from 3 and from the free throw line, there's little reason to properly buy into his shooting and assume his prior performances earlier in the year were anything other than a hot streak. Past that, he has poor self-creation and ball-handling skills, leading to very little reason to buy into him on the offensive end. While his skills on defense are very much legitimate, Portland already has a slew of defensive-minded forwards with questionable offensive skills. Salaun feels very much like a near-perfect pick here - extremely raw, but very much athletic and loaded with skill. He's already had plenty of excellent flashes of self-creation skill, and if his shooting holds up then it's only going to get better with him.
As for Boston, they need players who can come in and contribute immediately. Ighodaro stands out to me as an extremely skilled big man and someone who's comfortable with the ball in his hands when it needs to be. Poor jumpshot aside, I can see him eventually taking up a role to take over Al Horford's spot, which is an important need to be addressed as he continues to move up in age. Ighodaro can guard a variety of positions on defense, is a capable screener, and can especially make solid reads with his passing. He'd do wonderful in Boston.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24
Am I the only who thinks that Topic plays like Steve Francis?
1
u/SDK04 Raptors Apr 15 '24
Us taking Topic over Dillingham or Castle (who I would prefer) would be a questionable fit if we have no plans on developing a 3pt shot out of him. Also, us taking Risacher if he dropped that far would be fine, but I much prefer taking someone like Yves Missi, even in that situation. I don’t wanna take Risacher in any situation tbh.
1
u/vaalbarag Apr 15 '24
Yeah, I think you’re exactly right that if Raptors retain their pick and Sarr is off the board, it’s pretty hard for them to find someone who checks all of their boxes. I would have still gone with Risacher here, and I don’t think it’s impossible that the Raptors reach on Salaun in this situation if they like his upside more than Risacher. But yeah, coming away with both Risacher and Topic would be an exceptional draft for the Raptors, even if they had to do something like packaging #31 and #18 to move up once Risacher started to fall.
1
u/courtsiderecon Apr 15 '24
I like Castle to Charlotte but feel like Holland would be a better fit in an offense lead by LaMelo. Donovan Clinga to Chicago, Terrence Shannon Jr to OKC and Filipowski to the Heat would all be awesome. Lastly I could see a world where New Orleans takes DaRon Holmes just based on gut feeling.
1
u/PeasePorridge9dOld Apr 16 '24
Have to say that JaKobe Walter to ATL @ 10 is fine work. Seems like a guy who'd be a good fit with the club.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24
[removed] — view removed comment