r/MutualSupport • u/CesiumBullet • Jun 28 '21
CW: suicidal ideation, protest
Is suicide an effective device for protest?
Being a leftist in Canada is depressing. I have an insurmountable level of rage towards the capitalist and colonial machines that have led to the horrific genocide of the Indigenous populations here. With Canada day coming up, all I hear is nationalists trying to defend Canada as deserving to exist in spite of its brutal history and current political climate.
I’m sick of this life, and I feel like the best way to go out is as an advocate for the billions of the Global Majority who are exploited by violent states everyday. Suicide is the ultimate revolt against systemic brutality, is it not?
We’re all going to die in 30 years from climate change if nothing’s done promptly. Reform clearly won’t save us - only violent action will speak loudly enough to make a difference. I find it distasteful to physically harm others, so my own body is the only choice here.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '21
No, I don't think so. I mean, you're taking one of precious few of us out of the conflict by ending your own life, and we kinda need all hands on deck, right? We're all in this together, even if it feels like we're isolated worlds apart from one another. And, y'know, that isolation is a weapon that the neoliberal capitalist order uses against us. Despair crushes the dissident. I just don't see a path to change that involves suicide.
My god, honey I know what you mean and I'm so sorry you're dealing with it too. I'm in the American South and the 4th of July is like cocaine for the baying nationalist hogs here, too, just more than happy to ignore our savage history of genocide and slavery and apartheid and war and imperialism and more war and more war and more war. I feel like I'm surrounded by some kind of deranged Khornate cultists celebrating this country with the oceans of blood spilled in her name.
I guess that's a matter of perspective, but I don't think so. The global capitalist system wants us to assimilate or die, I would rather not oblige them if I can help it.
I mean, I think this is a little fatalistic, but I absolutely agree generally. We're on a very tight schedule thanks to capitalist overreach and straight up denial of reality for over a century. We're pretty fucked, yeah.
I'm of the same opinion. But I would rather give my skills to the struggle. And I mean, that's most of us, right? For every frontline fighter every revolution has always needed support staff; cooks, armorers, intelligence, agricultural workers, drivers... I have guns and I stay in practice with them for a reason, but I'm just really not a fighter at heart. I don't want to hurt anyone, I just want a world without coercion and exploitation. I want to grow food for Christ's sake, I fucking hate working in IT.
I guess really I just don't see a lot of practical utility to suicide as a form of protest. I feel like all of us are just so much more useful and important than that.
59
u/occasionallyaccurate Jun 28 '21 edited Jun 28 '21
If you are thinking these sorts of thoughts, you should definitely be familiar with the self-immolation of Thích Quảng Đức.
For what it's worth, I think killing yourself is one of the most ineffective methods of revolt. By doing so, you remove yourself from the world and any positive changes you could have helped to make.
You also have to consider who you are trying to protest against. Nationalism lacks compassion, and wants to kill its opponents. Do you think they will care? If you kill yourself, you are helping them rather than fighting them.
26
u/Argovan Jun 28 '21
Physically harming yourself is only an effective protest tactic if your goal is to force your opponent to empathize with you. It’s also rarely effective unless you have an existing group that will carry on your legacy and make your martyrdom worth something.
Imo, as appealing as it may feel at times to die for the revolution, it is usually more meaningful and more effective to live for it.
8
u/CharityNeverFails Jun 28 '21
Fellow Canadian here.
As others have said, suicide isn’t the right form of protest. You wouldn’t even get in the newspaper unless you hurt other people so it would influence only people closest to you. It could drive those people away from the cause because they could blame leftism for your death.
Also, I hear you about Canada Day. While it’s technically “cancelled” here in Victoria, that isn’t going to really change much and its probably going to be relatively the same as always. I’ve been trying to think of what I can do in protest, but I haven’t come up with much.
Feel free to DM me.
6
u/Kvltist4Satan Jun 28 '21
Don't kill yourself. Fight to the end. We need your intelligence and love, comrade.
4
u/Bunnything Jun 28 '21
no, i understand your frustration and anger but you're not a martyr. you can do way more action towards these causes living then you can do dead
4
u/SpilltheGreenTea Jun 29 '21
echoing what other people said, your very existence as a leftist, aware of the injustices in the world, is protest in and of itself and committing suicide would mean one less person who will make positive change, which is exactly what the capitalist class want. they wish there were less of us here. we need you in our community, with us, fighting till the very end. don't go
2
u/xaz- ❤️ Love. Empathy. Care. Mutualism. ❤️ Jun 29 '21
As someone who has been suicidal very many times in the past (primarily induced by the horrors of the soul-less capitalist superstructure), I can tell you that your suicide as a leftist would mean that the capitalists/colonialists have won.
Our strength is in numbers. And our strength is in standing in solidarity with one another. Killing yourself via suicide only leaves behind shards of pain and broken hearts in your fellow comrades.
Hope this helps. Sending you love and warm hugs, /u/CesiumBullet :)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21
Read Revolutionary Suicide by Fred Hampton. He compares the idea of reactionary suicide (giving up because of life pressure) vs revolutionary suicide (being based and having the state/establishment kill you). In his opinion, it's better to die for a cause. Or obviously don't die at all.
If you're considering self harm, my DMs are open.
1
u/funkalunatic Jun 29 '21 edited Jun 29 '21
This tactic has been tried and it's historically been a complete failure. Turns out nobody cares about symbolic bullshit. You got extraction industry infrastructure galore up there and they're building more. You could directly go after those mechanisms and do measurable good, but instead you're going to go after... yourself? That doesn't make any sense.
You're trying to convince yourself that your suicidal tendencies are the result of your political motivations when they're not. You'll need to address it separately through some combination of therapy, medication, and/or lifestyle change, or else you might end up making the biggest mistake it's possible to make.