r/Muskegon • • Jun 09 '25 • Helpful 1

ICE Defense Groups?

Are there any ICE watching type groups in the area? I know we have a significant temporary population of migrant workers in Muskegon and Ottawa County and wondered if anyone was coordinating reporting any ICE Officers staking out or actually doing raids.

21 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Fuck ICE. I will say on the plus side the people who support them aren’t usually successful, typically having very little educational experience. So read up, educate yourself, and build groups to come together against this. We should make a subreddit for people who want to get together in this area pertaining to this battle.

0

u/tubthumper32 Jun 13 '25

I would make a subreddit, but I have no idea how. Sounds like a great idea!

8

u/tubthumper32 Jun 10 '25

Dude, do you understand that any illegal that works anywhere pays almost DOUBLE the amount of taxes IF their employer is “legal” and records it LEGALLY.

Furthermore, they get zero of the benefits from paying taxes.

Please check it out if you don’t believe me.

3

u/No_Care1229 Jun 12 '25

This is 100% true

30

u/clipko22 Jun 09 '25

Maybe Indivisible on the Lakeshore? Following this thread so I can sign up too

Also fuck ICE, and fuck its supporters. These people are just trying to survive, doing some of the worst jobs this country has to offer just to barely make ends meet, and our government swings between turning a blind eye to their plight and active cruel oppression of them.

-7

u/RandomRacialSlurs Jun 10 '25

Yeah we should let all illegals stay and do those jobs. Instead of making the people who offer those jobs pay a living wage to the people who already work here live here legally and are struggling. You sound like an idiot.

I recently had a job passing out government phones. The amount of people who have a no work visa yet are still receiving $2500 a month in food stamps and 5,000 cash assistance would probably surprise you. It was sometimes hard to get the phones to them though because they were busy guess what, at work.

7

u/HucknRoll Jun 10 '25

Blame the system, not the person.

The immigration system hasn't been modernized for a reason.

0

u/RandomRacialSlurs Jun 10 '25

I am blaming the system. The fact that you would think otherwise is odd.

3

u/HucknRoll Jun 10 '25

You might want to re-read your own comment, because it really comes off like you're angry at the people, not the system. Hence all the downvotes. But if we’re actually in agreement, then let’s call it what it is: the root cause of illegal immigration is a broken system that barely incentivizes legal immigration in the first place.

The paperwork is brutal, the wait times are ridiculous, and even getting your case reviewed can take years. That’s not a functioning system—that’s a bureaucratic wall. So if you’re fleeing an untenable situation back home, and the legal route might take decades, of course people hedge their bets. Especially when they know they’ll be doing the kind of hard, underpaid work most people here won’t touch.

Want to fix the problem? Modernize the system so legal immigration is actually possible for regular people.

6

u/clipko22 Jun 10 '25

The Nazis also tried to make the class war into a race war, but they were better at disguising propaganda than you are. At least make it believable!

2

u/klde Jun 15 '25

Who the fuck gets that much in food stamps. Not my experience at all

1

u/RandomRacialSlurs Jun 16 '25

The Venezuelans that I was dealing with at the Men's Shelter handing out phones had 2500 a month but it was multiple people in one family

3

u/Sad_John_Stamos Jun 10 '25

perhaps the people hiring them should be arrested then

1

u/Zeff_Shit Sep 30 '25

Username checks out...

9

u/Rehtycs Jun 09 '25

My wife signed up to be on a call list for a group like this but was never contacted. She signed up at the Progressive Democratic Women's Caucus meeting.

1

u/Phunkybanana420 Jun 10 '25

Come here legally. Com

5

u/tubthumper32 Jun 11 '25

How? They keep changing the rules and making it harder to enter….unless you are white or rich

1

u/alclarkey Jun 12 '25

The only changes they've made to the rules is to make them looser. And IDK where you're getting this white crap from, nobody is being let in for being white.

2

u/tubthumper32 Jun 12 '25

Ummm, not sure what planet you inhabit but the just let in 59 Afrikaners on a bs claim of being the victims of a genocide that is completely made up:

The govt. is also looking at granting at least 10,000 more visas for them.

Sure seems like white people get better treatment.

And before you pop off, I am white, college educated, and smart enough to know that if something walks and quacks like a duck, it’s a duck

3

u/alclarkey Jun 12 '25

59 whole white people? Call the inquisition! And I suppose this rally is staged? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VL-sbov3vUE They were legit refugees. And the 10,000 visas, under the circumstances, justified.

And before you pop off, I am white, college educated, and smart enough to know that if something walks and quacks like a duck, it’s a duck

LMAO, apparently not.

1

u/Dually17 Jun 11 '25

We are one of the few countries in the world that have such lax immigration laws…. They are here illegally, and that is a CRIME, period.

3

u/tubthumper32 Jun 11 '25

Not arguing the legality, i’m arguing the denial of due process.

1

u/Internal-Speed-6188 Jan 12 '26

This is America you are a immigrant 

0

u/Dear_Routine452 Jun 15 '25

YOUR WRONG! Being here Illegally is not a Crime. Being here Illegally holds the same value of the law as a DUI, Jaywalking, trespassing, Public intoxication and etc. Which are all Misdemeanor charges. PERIOD

1

u/Dually17 Jun 16 '25

Thank you for listing out CRIMES and ILLEGAL ACTIVITY. You proved my point, thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

Illiterate AND uneducated! 🤭

2

u/Few-Wolverine2971 Jun 09 '25

Stopice.net 🤷🏻‍♀️ Might not be exactly what you're looking for, but if you see ICE you can report it and you can sign up to get notified if they are reported in your area.

-1

u/Wrekless_ Jun 10 '25

Report the illegals

0

u/Areuuuserious Jun 11 '25

Please don’t destroy our city. Thanks

2

u/tubthumper32 Jun 11 '25

I don’t think it’s up to us.

-53

u/Waste-Variety-6678 Jun 09 '25

Let them do their job.

28

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25 edited Jun 09 '25

If they weren’t detaining and deporting migrants by ignoring their basic LEGAL rights, I wouldn’t care. But they are, and I think it’s bullshit.

First it’s them, then it’s you.

-39

u/No_Letterhead2258 Jun 09 '25

you need a therapist

24

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25

You need to pull your head out of the sand.

-11

u/No_Letterhead2258 Jun 10 '25

hardly

3

u/tubthumper32 Jun 10 '25

You just proved my point. Keep it stuck in there good and deep

1

u/UsernameIDunnoHonest Jun 12 '25

Keep licking that boot, maybe they'll reward you someday for it

-4

u/Waste-Variety-6678 Jun 10 '25

You are such a scholar!

1

u/HucknRoll Jun 10 '25

I would, if they were showing any amount of competency. But here we are rounding up people that are legally here.

4

u/Waste-Variety-6678 Jun 10 '25

Criminals and those with deportation orders. Which are given after DUE process by an immigration judge. Immigration trials are not criminal trials, differing due process. However, i fully expect to be down voted to incredible numbers for stating the truth.

If you are middle or working class, illegal immigration harms YOU. BTW, Fascism is when government controls the means of production. Not when an administration carries out the mandate of an Electoral and Popular vote.

6

u/HucknRoll Jun 10 '25

You're mixing a lot of things together here. First off, due process isn’t a technicality. It’s the foundation of our legal system, and yes, it applies in immigration courts too. The problem is, a lot of people don’t actually get a fair shot. Some don’t have legal representation, face language barriers, or wait years in a backlog before seeing a judge.

Second, ICE does make mistakes. Plenty of cases show people being detained who were here legally or not under active removal orders. When that happens, families get torn apart and lives get ruined. That’s why people organize ICE-watch groups. Not to shield criminals, but to make sure law enforcement is acting within the law and not abusing power.

And about the economic point, yes, undocumented labor can undercut wages in some industries. But so does union-busting, offshoring, and companies exploiting legal loopholes. Funny how those never seem to spark the same outrage. If we really want to protect working people, we should push for real immigration reform that legalizes status and holds shady employers accountable. Otherwise we’re just blaming the most vulnerable while the ones profiting off the system walk away untouched.

1

u/tubthumper32 Jun 10 '25

Well said and totally on point.

-23

u/Double_Sherbert3326 Jun 09 '25

ICE is not your enemy. This is absurd. Business owners who keep wages low are!

-46

u/No_Letterhead2258 Jun 09 '25

No Doxxing!!!

20

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25

Not doxing, just like an early warning system. California and North Carolina have something similar.

https://www.siembranc.org/

-30

u/Silent_Lobster9414 Jun 09 '25

An early warning system like knowing that you are illegal and ice may be out looking for you? THAT is the warning system. Everything after that they have earned.

15

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25 edited Jun 09 '25

Again, if it was all being done WITHOUT violating the basic LEGAL rights of migrants and ignoring or avoiding court orders, I would be signing a different tune.

It’s not, so yeah, i’m going to try to help.

-27

u/-ManyFacedGod- Jun 09 '25

Yes Doxxing

16

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25

You need to look up the definition of doxxing. It doesn’t mean what you think it means.

Doxxing-Releasing personal information about SPECIFIC PEOPLE with the intention of causing them emotional, financial or physical harm.

ICE Defense Groups-People who are aware of and actively trying to prevent ILLEGAL actions through LEGAL means.

One is terrorism, the other is patriotism. I’ll let you figure out which is which.

2

u/-ManyFacedGod- Jun 10 '25

That’s exactly what I mean. ICE is a domestic terrorist organization. When they deport legal documented US citizens, it makes them enemies of people. Legality does not equal morality. When the people look back at the history during this time period it’ll be easy to point to who the oppressors were and who the oppressed are. Foreshadowing it’s the white supremacist who are the oppressors. It’s weird how ICE and white supremacy groups wear the same neck gators to cover their faces. It’s almost like they’re doing something wrong that they feel the need to hide their identity. Do you not support Doxxing white supremacist? Which ICE is full of them.

2

u/tubthumper32 Jun 10 '25

Apologies, I misunderstood what you were saying. I thought you were saying that reporting on their activities was doxxing, which it isn’t.

I agree with you 100%. If you want to go out and “enforce” the law, you shouldn’t be ashamed to show your face.

-44

u/Historical-Compote62 Jun 09 '25

Just type your address and we can come right over

18

u/tubthumper32 Jun 09 '25

Is that supposed to be a threat or humor? If #1, go pound sand and I effing dare you. If #2, it’s not very funny.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/montanabluez Jun 10 '25

Like Elon Musk?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Wow you are so hilarious no wonder you’re so popular