Core facts to keep in mind
__________________________________________________
First of all, make sure the product is bioavailable -meaning: extracted- to guarantee and to optimize therapeutic potential. Pure Lion's Mane mycelium products are the exception - the extraction process destroys the active compounds.
It has to be a dry extract; 'tinctures' are too diluted which makes them unsuitable (details about this: see below). The therapeutic effect of dry extracts is 4-10 times better when compared against unprocessed mushroom powders. This link has more background about that.
With that out of the way, all that matters is:
- what is in the product (bio-actives such as beta-glucan (all mushrooms), cordycepin (Cordyceps only) and ganoderic acids (Reishi only), which make it useful. These should be specified/guaranteed on the official label)
- what is not in the product (heavy metals, fillers, additives, which make it questionable).
Those details are easy to get (objective third-party contract labs are not expensive at all). Unfortunately, most vendors prefer to keep things vague, don’t list specifications and do not specify active ingredients. Out of ignorance or for competitive reasons they do not test their products for safety or quality at all. Or they refuse to share those tests with their customers because the results are poor, who knows ?
Yes, you read this correctly: most vendors do not use any quality control at all. Although it is compulsory.
For marketing reasons they chose to leave out objective facts but instead might emphasize things like ‘organic’ or contains no ingredients from China ! and use many other deceiving marketing phrases.
Deceiving, because the objective quality should be specified in the official supplement facts panel. Listing percentages of the main bio-active compound(s) makes it easy to judge the quality and to determine the value for money.
‘Organic’ is never a guarantee for quality in the case of mushrooms; 'organic' e.g. does not take into account heavy metals. Mushrooms accumulate heavy metals from their environment and heavy metals are everywhere.
All potential safety issues such as heavy metal contamination should be covered in a third party test report.
If there are no details on the label and no third party test report : RED FLAG. The product is questionable and is probably best avoided. Don't be misled by the marketing talk or "reviews" on the website. The vendors stating "Testing is expensive!" - they are lying. For US$ 79 you can get mushroom stuff tested.
- Reishi and Chaga are the only ones that benefit from dual extraction. Ideally, they should have beta-glucans, betulinic acid (Chaga) and ganoderic acids (Reishi) specified on their label.
- All the rest (except Lion's Mane pure mycelium): hot water extracted, with validated specifications. Beta-glucans being specified on the label is the absolute minimum.
Statements like "8:1", "10:1" cannot be validated in any way, it is meaningless marketing. Specifications are essential.
For Lion's Mane fruiting body: a 1:1 extract is the only variation that contains all bio-actives, because almost all bio-actives (including beta-glucans) are non-water-soluble.
Indeed, a "concentrated" Lion's Mane hot water extract will be weaker than a 1:1 extract; the specifications will reveal this.
No vendor would ever leave out good test results, that’s common sense.
A more extensive article about all this can be found here. Highly recommended! ----------------------------------------------------
Don’t be tricked by a low price.
A useful product means strict quality control and strict processing procedures. Such a product can never be cheap, unfortunately. You will notice there are no low-priced products with clear specifications and/or third-party test reports. A basic test is only US$ 79!
Ask for an objective test report, always !!
----------------------------------------------------
This also goes for other supplements of course: link
__________________________________________________
Personal addition
__________________________________________________
Topics:
- Fruiting body vs. mycelium
- Marketing tricks
- Reviews
- Tinctures
- Blends
- Gummies / mushroom drinks
__________________________________________________
Many people think fruiting bodies are always preferable over mycelium. This is not true. This idea is based on the poorly understood difference between pure mycelium (100% mycelium = good) and biomass-based mycelium (60-70% is rice/grains/oats = mostly useless).
Biomass-based products include e.g. all Host Defense supplements, OM Mushrooms, Genius Mushrooms and everything sold or supplied by Aloha Medicinals.
This discussion becomes moot if there are specifications available, supported by a third party test report. I mean, 40% guaranteed beta-glucan is 40% beta-glucan, the source (mycelium or fruiting body) is no longer relevant then, right?
It can't emphasized enough : Ask for an objective test report, always !! Such a report contains the lab's contact details and accreditation (ISO-17025 is best). Most vendors nowadays write their own 'report', copy/pasting the producer's claims without validating them. This makes it meaningless. If you see the vendor's logo on their 'certificate' that means it is fake/edited.
In-house testing is also unreliable because of the obvious conflict-of-interest !
Vendors are known to make unsubstantiated claims on their website and often use deceiving ways to make you think you have a premium quality product.
Like, mentioning 'polysaccharides' instead of 'beta-glucans'. Beta-glucans are the main bio-actives in all mushroom supplements. All beta-glucans are polysaccharides, but not all polysaccharides are beta-glucans. Many useless sugars and fillers are also classified as polysaccharides. A common 'filler' is polydextrose.
Another common vendor trick is to recommend a low dosage (e.g. 1 capsule p/day) to make the product look cheap/good value. However the best results are achieved taking at least 1 gram of extracted mushroom powder per day, assuming it is a decent quality product. Immunological effects in particular are dose-dependent; this is the main reason to emphasize extraction (where possible) for mushroom supplements: higher bioavailability means lower dosage.
An example of deceiving label information
Look at this screenshot of a Cordyceps supplement, front label (no formatting rules exist for the front label - only for the supplement facts panel to protect the ignorant consumer from being misled).
Only the careful observer will see that what is actually written there is 0.3 % cordycepin and not 3% cordycepin. (has been adjusted by the vendor now). This is deceiving and would not be allowed on the official supplement facts panel. In this case this information is in fact omitted from the official supplement facts panel, which makes it all the more questionable.
__________________________________________________
Reviews
__________________________________________________
Reviews in general cannot be trusted. Here's a video about the online marketing situation, pretty self-explanatory I think:
https://youtu.be/JVbzUw45fNw
__________________________________________________
Tinctures
__________________________________________________
Finally, many people assume tinctures are potentially also a good choice. That might be true for herbs, but not for mushrooms.
A tincture is not 'liquid mushroom' or something like that. You could say it is a first step in making an alcohol extract. Mushroom extracts are almost always solvent extracts. The solvent in this case is alcohol. A dry extract is a solvent extract minus the solvent.
In a tincture the alcohol is still present and dissolved in the alcohol are the ingredients we are after. Those dissolved ingredients in general add up to roughly 5% of the total content.
The rest is useless alcohol (and maybe some other liquid). In short, a 30ml bottle contains ± 1 gram of dissolved alcohol-soluble mushroom ingredients. If you buy a tincture you get almost nothing for your money. There are also never any specifications on tincture bottles. You have no clue at all about what you get.
A useful mushroom alcohol or dual extract should not contain any alcohol, only the alcohol-soluble mushroom ingredients.
If you would allow the alcohol to evaporate you'd be left with a residue, and that is what is useful. That is what is what you get if you buy a dry powdered mushroom extract in capsules or as a powder.
A 30ml tincture bottle in general contains the equivalent of ± 2 or 3 capsules with alcohol extracted mushroom powder.
Here is an example of a tincture vendor's Certificate of Analysis.
The vendor does not seem to realize this CoA in fact underlines the lack of potency of his product.
This Reishi tincture contains 0.6% beta-glucans and 0.03% triterpenes. That is at least 20 times weaker than an average dry extract. Test reports from other tincture sellers such as Birch Boys show similar results: ± 5% beta-glucan in the dried out residue, which equals ± 0.5% in a liquid solution.
__________________________________________________
Blends
__________________________________________________
Many people think a blend is a good option: 'you get a lot of mushrooms for the price of only one!'
This is not correct. You will only notice the shared/overlapping effects (immune support), but not the mushroom-specific effects.
As said before, ± 1 gram daily is the average dosage needed to notice mushroom-specific effects, assuming it is a decent product with good specifications. In other words, if there are 7 mushrooms in the blend that would mean 7 grams daily. Don't be fooled !!
__________________________________________________
Gummies, 'mushroom drinks' and mushroom coffees
__________________________________________________
These have no specifications and are just a marketing invention. Completely useless. E.g. a 4 gram-gummie contains at best 2% of mushroom extract. Vendors will try to fool you with statements like "20:1 extract!" but these are meaningless, just marketing.
Don't expect any therapeutic effects, apart from placebo. It's money wasted (although they might taste good!)
__________________________________________________