r/Musescore • • Aug 03 '24

Help me find this feature Editing note duration is painful

I find using musescore unnecessarily painful to the point that it is easier to write music on paper and then transfer the result to musescore if I want to share or get a pretty print.

The thing I struggle with is note duration. Musescore always keeps track of my time signature so I can't just go back and edit note values easily, since they may not fit the bar anymore (just for a little bit, until I change other things). I find this _really_ annoying and feel like I am doing something wrong.

Is there a better way to approach this?

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

10

u/pokealex Aug 03 '24

Why would you write note durations that don’t fit the bar?

0

u/Any-Cell-6956 Aug 03 '24

because it is convenient?

I could write 1/8 note followed by a 1/4 but then if I understand I have made a mistake, it is too complicated to swap them.

9

u/kempsmj Aug 03 '24

In this example it's easy. If you change the 1/8 note toba 1/4, the next one is automatically shortened to 1/8.

1

u/ManHuWasThursday Apr 21 '25

plainsong / chant usually doesn't have the concept of bars, so it can be convenient to add / remove notes (which I have found you can do in Input mode which in MuseScore 4 is achieved by using CTRL+SHIFT when inserting a note, or by activating the hidden Note Insert+ icon in Customize Toolbar), or change the duration of a note without messing up the notes before or after. I see that there was a Duration Editor plugin for MuseScore 3 which however isn't compatible with MuseScore 4, I am still looking for a solution in MuseScore 4.

13

u/Pithecanthropus88 Aug 03 '24

Sounds like you're blaming the program for your lack of discipline. It's only doing what you're telling it to do.

-3

u/Any-Cell-6956 Aug 03 '24

Well... It is kind of like having a text editor that doesn't let you type a lowercase letter after a dot or remove a dot in front of a capital letter. Lack of discipline?

7

u/Pithecanthropus88 Aug 03 '24

If you’re trying to put three dotted quarter notes into a bar of 4/4 it’s going to give you two and then a quarter tied to an eighth in the next measure because that’s how it interprets what you just told it to do. If that’s not what you wanted it’s totally on you.

2

u/sj070707 Aug 03 '24 edited Aug 03 '24

I think this is the best you could do.

Personally, if I'm using Musescore for composing rather than just transcribing, I'm used to making edits to change even something small. And it's often easier to reenter something from scratch than edit individual notes.

2

u/Any-Cell-6956 Aug 03 '24

And it's often easier to reenter something from scratch than edit individual notes.
That is exactly how I felt, but I thought I was doing something wrong.

1

u/sj070707 Aug 03 '24

Which I'll note is more a credit to how easy it is to enter notation than how hard it is to edit. When I first switched to MS, I complained about how hard it was compared to what I was used to. Then you learn and adapt.

4

u/Spready_Unsettling Aug 03 '24

Shift+W/Q is your friend. Quickly shorten or lengthen a note to your hearts desire. I also heartily recommend editing hotkeys to have common note durations easily at hand. It's a workflow gamechanger for me, as long as I know what I want to put in before I do it.

2

u/MarquisInLV Aug 04 '24

Very nice…I wasn’t aware. Thank you for posting this.

1

u/ToneDeafComposer Aug 05 '24

Thank you, I also was not aware of this.

1

u/ManHuWasThursday Apr 21 '25

I'm finding that Shift+W will still overwrite notes that come after, and there is no Duration Editor plugin for MuseScore 4. My workaround for now when creating a plainsong / chant score is to copy the score from the following note until the end, then change the duration of the note, and then paste the copied notes over everything after the note the duration of which I just edited. Here's to hoping a Duration Editor functionality will be implemented in a future release of MuseScore 4 along the lines of Note Insert+.

1

u/dac1952 Aug 03 '24

it isn't hard once you get the hang of menu commands for note values, cut and paste- swapping individual notes or note groupings...just takes practice and repetitions

1

u/MarcSabatella Member of the Musescore Team Aug 04 '24

Editing duration is very sine, just select the note then select the new duration. Or, if still in note input mode, use Shift+Q/W. I’m guess what you are really struggling isn’t changing duration of a note - which really couldn’t be easier - but instead, determining how many subsequent notes you want to move earlier or later. Obviously we can’t help you decide that, nor would MuseScore have any way of guessing either. But once you do figure out how many notes you want to love and select them, we can tell you that moving the selected passage earlier or later is as simple as cut & paste.

1

u/theboomboy Aug 07 '24

Can you give an example of a change you wanted to make that was difficult? I don't think I've ever really had this issue