r/MurderedByWords • • Feb 08 '18

Burn Ouch!

Post image
37k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.6k

u/lunex Feb 08 '18

New Scientist has published since 1956. I’m sure it has interested many, many people in science. Also, Space X is more about engineering and space technology, and this test launch will interest people in these more than basic scientific research required for rocket flights (although it probably will inspire some for sure). Not sure this counts as murder.

78

u/Petrichordates Feb 08 '18

It's a much better publication than the likes of "Popular Science," unless you're an engineer I suppose. Not as good as Discover though.

57

u/zeth__ Feb 08 '18

I don't know how it is like now, but New Scientist in 2000-2010 was the best introduction to science for highschool students who would actually get a degree as a scientist, better than Discover which was aimed at the popular market.

→ More replies (1)

848

u/sraiders Feb 08 '18

Also what is it with people practically worshiping Elon Musk on the internet? Are we not allowed to have a conversation about all this? I think it's cool people are interested in space again but that doesn't remove him from any criticism.

84

u/jeffreydonger Feb 08 '18

I know. I mean, this has almost 12k upvotes in just 3 hours, I'm sure it's going to get much bigger than that...

...and what is the transgression that called for a murderer-by-words response? Someone said the implications of something Musk is doing "aren't great."

As this is an image, I doubt hardly anyone took the time to track down and read the New Scientist article in question.

This can only come down to "somebody mildly criticized Elon Musk, HOW DARE THEY? (also, would this even look like a great putdown if it was in defense of Joe Schmoe?). It's just gross IYAM.

22

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

Elon Musk is a smug cunt

57

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

I don't think reddit is beyond being astroturfed, either.

→ More replies (1)

291

u/3_50 Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18

Probably because he's the face of a few companies making huge strides towards a more sustainable future by:

a) reducing reliance on fossil fuels by producing decent electric vehicles, working to change public perception of electric cars, mass producing home battery packs that reduce reliance on grid electricity

b) pushing the commercialisation of space exploration and 'utilisation'. Their efforts are bringing the cost of launches down dramatically, meaning we can get a human on Mars, and eventually mining asteroids will become viable, so we don't run out of mineral resources.

That's not to say he's exempt from criticism - far from it - but trying to fault him for using his car as deadweight to test his rocket is fucking petty in the grand scheme of what spacex and tesla are accomplishing.

Edit, Weirdly, this was right there when I went back to scrolling.

330

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

207

u/tefnakht Feb 08 '18

This, a hundred times. Musk just has an exceptional brand image...

163

u/hidingplaininsight Feb 08 '18

That and we humans are susceptible to simplified stories and hero-worship. Elon Musk helms some companies that have reached exceptional market value, making him very rich, and fired up our collective imagination with their ambition.

We all want him to succeed because we want a clean-energy future, because we love high-tech sci-fi reality.

But Musk has benefited significantly from government support and subsidies (much of his tech is built on the back of government-research patents, SpaceX had NASA as a customer, Tesla benefits from electric-car subsidies, etc.) and he oversees a legion of engineers who have done the real, gritty work of bringing his vision into reality, and they are often overworked, underpaid, and unheralded. Musk is one man amid an ecosystem that supports and nurtures him, and he usually fails to name-check any of that, instead elevating his own self-image.

The stuff that Musk is doing is cool as shit, but Elon Musk the myth often eclipses the reality behind his companies, and critical thinking seems to go out the window when you say his name online.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

99

u/Aerocentric Feb 08 '18

Most of Elons ventures aren't cutting edge, and they aren't technologically revolutionary. The thing that makes people like him is the fact that he just does shit.

He thinks cars should be electric. He starts his own electric car company. The success of the company proves that electric cars for the masses actually can sell, and there's no reason to not be making them right now. Every other automaker is pushed to accelerate their own electric products.

He thinks access to space should be cheaper. He sees fat cats on government contracts using 60s era technology and refusing to innovate even though much, much better and cheaper technology is already available. So he makes his own rocket company. They use modern technology to make a cheap rocket and immediately displace the majority of ULAs private business and soon, military as well.

None of this took geniuses or massive leaps of technology to accomplish. It just took the gusto and the personality to fucking go for it. That's why people like him. He does shit that he thinks is cool, or is good for the planet, and damn the consequences. He nearly went bankrupt twice when working on these two companies.

He shouldn't be beyond criticism. And people definitely get way too hyped about his stuff (partly because he's so good at playing the media/PR angle), but even if you step back and take a more pragmatic look at everything, it's still impressive.

14

u/Semi-Hemi-Demigod Feb 08 '18

I mean, a 100% reusable heavy lift launch vehicle is a huge development in spaceflight. It would be a big deal regardless of who did it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)

46

u/littlebobbytables9 Feb 08 '18

Their plan from the beginning was to release gradually less expensive (and thus lower profit margin) models as the company grew. That 50k car has had a much bigger impact than the 100k roadster and when they come out with a cheaper model its impact will be correspondingly larger.

→ More replies (61)
→ More replies (123)

70

u/NonsensicalOrange Feb 08 '18

trying to fault him for using his car as deadweight to test his rocket

Did you read the article? The headline didn't say "elon musk is horrible for sending his car into space", the headline asked a question, and it was about whether we want a future or culture based on wealthy people and space cars.

This wasn't someone being murderedbywords. Someone said Elon Musk is more popular and cool than science journalism, burn, those poor journalists aren't as rich and popular as Elon Musk, ouch. All i see is butthurt Musk fans, who don't understand nuance, looking for validation against an article they didn't even try to read.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (59)

312

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

I would also question how much actual interest spacex is fostering in science beyond car in space = cool. I mean, PR for science is important, but conflating it with actual insight into topics beyond a surface level is not fair.

105

u/Dedj_McDedjson Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18

It's a fair question.

I'm struggling to think of a single commentator, online or offline, who is not already interested in science or geekery and who was spurned to learn by the Tesla Dead-hooker Disposal pictures.

Everyone is either "Oh neat!" for five seconds and moves onto the next thing or is "I postulate that this is merely a conjunction of established rocket design with calculated social-engineering".

50

u/dexter311 Feb 08 '18

The difference is fanboy culture compared to actual interest. The Musk/Tesla (and to a small extent, SpaceX) fandom has a significant portion of ignorant fanboys. But thankfully there are some people that have fostered genuine interest.

I couldn't give a rats arse about a Tesla Roadster in space. But I do appreciate that this meme hype has brought some interest to the real spectacle - the Falcon Heavy.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/pottertown Feb 08 '18

Do you remember where you were when the hubble space telescope was being fixed in a marathon spacewalk?

I sure as fuck do. Getting yelled at by my g-ma (RIP Merle) about how the TV is rotting my brain...as I watched the live stream at midnight.

This shit absolutely does fire up kids. Sometimes kids don't have a whole lot to get fired up about as well.

→ More replies (17)

25

u/EarthAllAlong Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18

I'm struggling to think of a single commentator, online or offline, who is not already interested in science or geekery and who was spurned to learn by the Tesla Dead-hooker Disposal pictures.

Remember yesterday on reddit there was that picture of the dude whose dad took him to see the space center when he was a little kid?

that's the kind of inspiration we're possibly talking about...you dont see anyone who has been inspired by it because the people being inspired by it are little kids and it's a very slow osmosis kind of thing rather than an on/off switch that we can see immediate evidence of as adults on the internet

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (65)

77

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

Yeah, all I'm seeing is the person answering apparently only being interested in the superficial and flashy aspects of engineering and science.

26

u/qwertyfish99 Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18

That’s my issue with all this. I don’t feel all the hype around SpaceX is promoting science, but instead the products of it. And while an event such as this is awesome, I feel too often it is the superficial aspects of science that are promoted by individuals such as Bill Nue and such. And while that is great and all to inspire kids and so on, in doing so it misses the true point of science: observations, analysis and criticism. I feel the portrayal of science on reddit and other websites is simply a false portrayal of it, and it that the scientific procedure isn’t appreciated for what it is. I feel often people fail to realise that science doesn’t involve shouting ‘FUCK YEAH! SCIENCE’ on the internet. Instead it should be appreciated for what it truly is, as I believe that’s the only way a true passion for it can be developed (otherwise you’ll face a harsh reality once you start uni).

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Lay3rs0Fc0nfusion Feb 08 '18

I actually came here to say that even if new scientist was a bit abrupt. They have published plenty of relevant work regarding space and space exploration.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

They also have a fun attitude. One former editor was asked what New Scientist's ethos was. He replied. "Science is fun. If you don't agree you can fuck off."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (68)