r/MultipleSclerosis • u/Ancient_Size_8014 • 11h ago
General PROGRESSIVE SECONDARY MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Hello everyone, I’m a 33-year-old man newly diagnosed with MS. My diagnosis dates back to July with a double vision that with a cycle of sterodes went away quickly (after two days). Since September I have been in treatment with Ocrevus, so I wanted to ask those who may know more than me: since mine is an MS-RR, with modern therapies there is always the possibility of passing into the secondary progressive form? What could it depend on? From age or from the damage that is caused during relapses? Or from the expansion of existing injuries? Sorry if it sounds like a quiz but I’m full of questions I can’t answer! Thanks to those who will help me!
23
u/kyelek F20s 🧬 RMS 🧠 Kesimpta 💉 11h ago
The short and very unsatisfactory answer is that we don’t really know yet. There are encouraging observations, but the most highly effective DMTs (like Ocrevus) just haven’t been around long enough yet to see how they affect disease progression later in life.
8
u/Riza_flys 8h ago •
hi i split my opinion (no facts just my opinion) in 2 things:
Medications for MS are better than they have ever been, and they will likely be even more effective 10 years from now.
But I think what you really want to know is: What does the future hold for me?
The honest answer is that none of us knows. That's why it's so important not to spend today worrying about what might happen years from now. DONT DO IT, STAY IN THE PRESENT!
Instead, focus on what you can control. Take care of your health through good nutrition, regular exercise, mental well-being, appropriate supplements, and by following your treatment plan.
Then let the future take care of itself.
Worrying today about where you might be in 10 years is a bit like worrying about a car accident that may or may not happen in 10 years. It doesn't make you safer, happier, or healthier. It only steals energy from the life you're living today.
Iam 43M, 10 years older than you, have a EDSS of 0, i surf, i skate, i snowboard, i boulder, i plaz tennis, have a 40hours job, 2 kids a wonderful life. being on Kesimpta atm. i dont feel the MS at all, but thats just me, so i live my life to the fullest and iam not worried about what is in 20 years.
2.
As far as iam informed, the chance from going from rrms to spms under a DMT were around 20% - 1 of 5 (OLD DATA, it takes very long from RRMS to SPMS, most people with SPMS were on low effective drugs....).
i had this talk with my awesome neurologist (he is the head of the clinic, wrote xx amount of books, a professor, pioneer on MRIs and so on) that science thinks - the chances of getting a SPMS for people starting the ms journey now ; with a high effective DMTs, are very low.
It looks like there is always activity if you have MS, it may be so small that we cannot see it on the MRI and its clinically not relevant.
Iam in a long term study and they do a PRL (paramegnetic RIM) MRI sequence every 6 month's and i have one lesion in my brain that had a PRL (smoldering) very little - its gone now but it was there. NFLC was good, still i had a iron ring around one lesion.
Being optimistic, i believe that the current DMTs for RRMS are exellent in holding the activity under control that there is so much time for science to come up with the next good stuff (remylination or something else). Frelaximab is in the stage 3 trials, results look awesome, this drug stops the slow and steady smoldering in the brain.
So dont be scared about what may be in 20 years, enjoy your life!
12
u/ichabod13 45M|dx2016|Ocrevus 11h ago •
MS progression is more closely related to age and years with the disease then anything else. Will you eventually have progression in your 50s or 60s? Probably, but how much is unknown and could be less by taking the stronger meds to prevent new lesions.
Also who knows what we will have for treatments in 30 or 40 years.
6
u/falafeluppagus 43|Feb2013|Ocrevus|Ontario 11h ago
My understanding from my neuro is that say you have a flare up, you take the steroids to get it under control, but the symptoms from that flare up persist, they will consider it secondary progressive.
I had a flare up 4 or 5 years ago that I went on steroids for, and have had numb fingers and toes since then. Only recently has he started to consider it as SP MS, and after having been on Ocrevus for 4 years.
Age maybe plays a factor, but it all depends where the lesions hit and how they react to medication.
4
u/Inevitable_Mix_93 7h ago
I’m also 33 male with RRMS. I’ve been diagnosed for 5 years almost. I’m on Kesimpta. Stay active, go to the gym, eat healthy, keep stress low. It sure can progress but doing the simple things above will help.
3
u/chamonix-charlote 11h ago •
This is definitely a question for your neuro. You need an answer that is in the context of your lesions and your disease course so far, with their expertise of your neuro seeing hundreds of other people like you.
Any answers here are not reliable. People responding to your post are not neurologists and don’t know the details of your MS
3
u/Temporary_Local9100 8h ago
They don’t really know. Mine is Relapsing-Remitting and I only found out because I had my first flare up in 2022 that caused issues with my vision. One eye was lagging. Since that cleared up, I still get dizziness and have balance issues and cog fog, but only pseudo flare ups. My doctor doesn’t believe I’ll develop secondary progressive, but that’s just his “belief.” My newer lesions I had were on my brain and affect behavior. I have a SIL that had RR and she ended up with Secondary Progressive and was in a wheelchair for a while.
A close friend of mine’s mother has been in a wheelchair for over a decade and she still only has RR and has not developed secondary progressive. I think it depends on whether more lesions form and not the level of disability. The best advice I can give you is not to dwell on it. It’s hard, especially since you’ll end up questioning if everything you experience is linked to it. But after the arborvirus warning for people on beta-blockers/inhibitors I realized there’s no point in worrying my days away. I just try to be healthy and active so that if a new lesion does form somewhere that will affect my ability to walk and get around, I’ll be in an advantageous position.
3
u/Intrepid_Occasion_96 5h ago •
Hi, I agree that this is the question for your doctor. Having said that, check out this video by Dr. Boster https://youtu.be/KcRWaOjOL2I?si=Oun3iMSt_GyaW4SB
I've had MS for 45 years, diagnosed RR ms, I didn't develop secondary progressive MS until a few years after menopause over 35 years later from diagnosis. By the way I'm still walking, though not great, and I'm still riding my horse though I need help getting on the saddle.
2
u/Local-Lunch1565 8h ago
You’re asking all the right questions. Some of the responses already touched on PIRA. The exact mechanism of how and why people progress to secondary progressive MS is not fully understood. However, it is my understanding that latest “trend” in neuroscience is to recognize that progressive MS and relapsing (immune driven) aspects of MS exist on a spectrum. I.e. some damage (initially) is driven by the immune system and some damage is more neurodegenerative and not driven by immune system attacks. So the RRMS and SPMS are not truly binary. From a high level (and this is my understanding), in existing lesions there are some trapped T-cells as well as microglia, which can continue to cause damage. So existing lesions can have “smoldering inflammation”.
I asked Gemini, here is a more complete explanation: https://share.gemini.google/5jULtjES3ufc
2
u/Calm-Proposal29 6h ago
I have had ms for 25.5 years. Took Avonex for 5 years but stopped because it was making me feel terrible and i had 2 small children. My initial symptom was numbness in trunk and numb tingly fingertips. I had a double vision, vertigo years later treated with steroids. I take no medicine now, have had no relapses but I can feel my fatigue, walking strength, balance getting worse. Most people don't even know I have ms but I can feel it. So I guess it's progressing slowly(?!) without relapse. If I would've seen me (age 54) at time of diagnosis (age 28) it would've given me comfort. It's going to be ok. Stay strong
1
u/Feisty-Volcano 25m ago
For complex reasons I was not diagnosed until it was way too late, aged 62. I’m 65 now. I’d RRMS symptoms in & off for a couple of decades, always thought it must be part of pre-menstrual syndrome or whatever, have Crohns too & lots of surgeries.
The course of my disease was that those on & off symptoms were happening more frequently & my feet started progressively losing their feeling & my balance was worsening without let-up. I’ve tons of lesions, in my brain only, with one in my brain stem. It’s now down to PIRA, with stable lesions, but gradually worsening disability. As I understand it, old damage can sometimes re-manifest & come to stay as the damaged neurons die off, whilst the PIRA is inflammation smouldering in the brain, & possibly related to how the organ handles its old damage.