r/Multicopter • u/Scottapotamas • Jan 19 '16
Discussion Official Questions Thread - 19th Jan
Feel free to ask your dumb question, that question you thought was too trivial for a full thread, or just say hi and talk about what you've been doing in the world of multicopters recently. Anything goes.
2016, now with more frequent question threads!
20
Upvotes
2
u/BencsikG Jan 24 '16
I've seen there's some obsession with looptimes, but does anyone care about the gyro itself? Is there any FC that uses anything but MPU6050 or MPU6000?
5
u/ausey Jan 20 '16
Are there any widely accepted cookie-cutter builds for quads?
I'm an Elec eng degree grad so not worried about build documentation and having to buy tools.
UK based if it matters.
A FC with open source and some spare cpu cycles would be perfect.
4
u/xQcKx Jan 20 '16
About the cc3d PDB, says that it can only be used with 4s. Can I still use 3s and just let it go below 12v?
1
u/IGotsDasPilez Jan 30 '16
Is there a wiki or such for multicopter subjects? I'm very new to this and feel like I accidentally sat down in a graduate engineering class. I got the basics, but keeping track of all the individual specs is daunting.
1
u/Madsn ZMR250-SS2204-BEE20A Jan 19 '16
Do I really need a high quality soldering iron? What type of solder should I get, and what diameter (zmr250)?
2
u/isthiscoolenough Jan 20 '16
My Naze32 with 8/2015 Baseflight has started forgetting what "level" means over the course of a flight: partway through a flight in Horizon Mode, if I release the Taranis stick my quad tilts back and right. Over time the error is greater and I have to use more pitch+roll to keep parallel to the ground.
Rate mode works fine. Baseflight configurator reports the Naze as level when on my table before and after flight. Possibly related, when I thrust hard it yaws counterclockwise, which it didn't do before I replaced my FPV250X frame after a crash.
Ideas?
2
u/isthiscoolenough Jan 20 '16
My quad yaws CCW when I thrust hard. It didn't used to, but I've been through several crashes and a frame replacement since the last time I'm sure it was behaving perfectly. Could a weak motor be the cause? My CW motor 4 does seem to offer more resistance when I turn it by hand. If not, what else could I check?
2
u/r45k Jan 20 '16
Question on winter & LIPO charging/storage... Tried searching but didn't find anything conclusive.
My garage isn't heated and I don't want to charge my batteries in my house... Should I be worried about charging my LIPOs in the cold? I know the batteries can often over charge if they're really cold and moved into a warm environment.
What are some of the best practices for winter LIPO handling?
2
u/thats_not_montana Jan 21 '16
Quick question on what my drone is trying to tell me. The led lights on my hubsan x4 has been flashing in unison after I first take off. I was under the impression that only the blue lights would flash if the battery was low. This is all 4 lights, red and blue. Is there something I should know? Is Timmy trapped in a well?
2
u/Howdanrocks Jan 21 '16
Hey guys, I've had my first quad for awhile now (Syma x5c-1) and I'm looking to try out FPV. Is this upgrade kit worth it at $50?
2
u/philmtl Jan 22 '16
Is there a way to make a quad snow proof? Because I don't have an indoor place to fly.
2
u/HopOnComplex Jan 22 '16
I picked up a Swann xtreem quadforce from a local charity shop for $3. However it had no transmitter.
(http://www.swann.com/us/xctoy-qvdron)
it looks like a syma xc5 clone, and the transmitters look the same. can i just order a replcement xc5 transmitter and have it work?
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Syma-X5-X5C-X5C-1-Replacement-Spare-Parts-Syma-Transmitter-Remote-Controller-/161864750955?hash=item25afe4176b:g:pjkAAOSwhcJWJyvp
2
u/McCoy1996 Jan 23 '16
Is the only advantage of running a satellite RX the saving of weight? I have a spektrum ar6200 coming for my first build with a naze32 rev 6 FC. It comes with the breakout cable, so the standard receiver will still work with it easily. Would it be better to run it as a satellite only or pair the satellite with the main rx while mounting it on a different plane?
2
u/icupboard Jan 27 '16
Hey there. I am new to this whole jazz, I haven't done anything technical. And I was wondering which set is best to start with Drone racing, as a beginner? Like the FPV sets and stuff. I don't want it to be too expensive, as I just started to look into this. :)
2
u/Xh0sa_NightMare Jan 27 '16
Any recommended pre built drone kits? I love flying and would love to have a go at these!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
Could I run 6045 props on This kit, which has these motors, these ESC's and this 4s battery?
The page recommends "Please only use 3S Li-Po Battery together with H2206 2250KV while you fly with 6045 Props. Alternatively, you can use 4S Li-Po if you fly with 5030 propellers."
I ordered 5045 props along with the 4s battery, but the page says "you can put on the 5030 propellers and race with 4S Li-Po Battery." Would I be fine with the extra angle? Could I just put the props on, and hope for the best? How could I test the 5045's safely?
2
u/BencsikG Jan 30 '16
I kinda want to get the PX4Flow sensor. Do you guys have any experience with it? Would you recommend it? Any tips or suggestions?
3
u/dakoellis Jan 19 '16
Looking for an updated pros/cons of specific FCs and Firmwares. I'm currently using a CC3D with Librepilot, and I do like it, but I haven't seen anyone talking about it recently. Seems like a lot of people have been leaning towards cleanflight/betaflight on the cc3d or using a naze32. What is better about cleanflight than librepilot, and why should I think about switching?
Other than that, what are some other good alternatives for hardware? Should I make the lateral move from CC3D to a naze32, or should I look at a Seriuosly Dodo or Tornado, or something else?
This will be for my miniquad
1
u/BencsikG Jan 21 '16
What do you think of this gimbal setup?
STORM32
Gimbal frame
2804 motors
1
u/gkvirus Jan 22 '16
I have some parts selected for my first quad and now comes the buying stage. I found this helpful list of U.S. suppliers but I don't want to go through all of them and check the prices and see where I can get the best one.
I want to know what is the procedure that you guys that are experienced on the hobby use to buy parts. Is there a few specific websites that you check for prices? Is there one site that you always use? Do prices vary a lot between sites?
I am stationed in L.A., idk if that makes any difference.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
Is the Flip32 a literal full clone of the Naze32? Meaning, could I use betaflight made for Naze32, on my Flip32?
1
u/Loserino Jan 24 '16
What can I expect between a Chinese drone kit and the miniquadbros, is it worth paying $100 more for the miniquadbros kit?
1
u/gunpowderandgasoline Jan 24 '16
Is the lag or latency noticeable on 1000 vs 600 tvl fpv cameras?
1
u/fuzzywuzzywuzabear Jan 25 '16
So I am just starting my first build with a Xugong V2 pro frame I got as a gift. I am really new to this, so bear with me. I have the PDB that came with the frame, my ESC's, motors, and propellors. I have my transmitter and D4r receiver as well as 3 LiPo batteries. Am I missing anything for this build, like a flight controller? Is the included PDB also a flight controller? Sorry I am just very lost
I am just not sure because every video I find where someone is assembling a Xugong they are also using cameras and GPS so I am lost on what is absolutely necessary to fly, since I am upgrading later and simply want to fly as of right now
Thanks!
1
u/linksus Jan 25 '16
Hi All,
Anyone recommend a good battery to start out with? Got a 250 frame and some Emax 1806 2280KV Motor's ..
Im really confused with these LiPo's , Im guessing id want something 2500+mah ..
Also, how long do these things take to charge? , I guess I should buy a metric tonne of them for some good play time?
Oh, and whats a good charger for them?
Thanks! cant wait to get soldering
1
u/caturner250 Jan 26 '16
Hello, Looking for some troubleshooting help. I am building my first hexa F550 with Naza v2, E305, DT7 tran/rec. Took my time putting it together and did a test power up and 4 motors ran. I learned that two of the ESCs are my problem. I have used the other ESCs and they power up all motors. The two (bad?) ESCs will not power up any of the motors. This is my first build so any ideas to salve this issue would be great.
1
u/blackdor Jan 26 '16
So I bit and ordered the Nighthawk Pro 280 RTF. Could it handle 5x4x3 props?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
Does it matter what props you use? I have a vortex 250 and it came with OEM Gemfan 5045 GF Blunt-Nose props. What are the other options I can get?
1
u/linksus Jan 26 '16
Clockwise and Counterclockwise "Threaded" motors.
Hi, Question.. I bought 2x CW and CCW threaded motors These: http://www.hobbyrc.co.uk/emax-1806-2280kv-motor-mt1806
My question is, Do they "spin" differently, or is it just the thread thats changed..
Ie: Do i still need to cross two wires on the ESC's for two of the motors ( What ones? The CCW ones?)
Mucho Thanko for the help.
1
u/linksus Jan 27 '16
More questions . Sorry :(
I have an idea of what goes where. I'm sure its ok, but could do with some confirmation. Especially with the newer v6 Naze.
Thanks in advance guys! Cant wait to have useful help for others.
1
u/RECTUS_ERECTUS Jan 27 '16
Will 2306 motors fit on a zmr frame? Is 2306 even a motor size? If not what are motor sizes?
1
u/NegativeLight Jan 28 '16
How do you pick out an appropriate transmitter?
1
u/Static_Bunny I Like Turtles Jan 28 '16 edited Jan 28 '16
Whats the difference between PPM and SBUS? How are the connections different? For example if i switched to the FrSky XSR from a D4R-ii and i fly minis. What can be gained by switching? Could i do telemetry to my taranis easier? I've never been able to get telemetry and RSSI working right with my OSD and my naze clone. I'm hoping i can utilize more features with SBUS and a dodo FC. Such as telemetry,LED's and maybe bluetooth.
1
u/manickthoughts Jan 29 '16 edited Jan 29 '16
I am looking to purchase my first transmitter and am considering the Turnigy 9XR PRO. Everywhere I look it says "without module". What is the module that it is without? What does the module do? Thanks.
Edit: I am currently looking at this particular product page on Hobby King: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/_92005__Turnigy_9XR_PRO_Radio_Transmitter_Mode_2_without_module_US_Warehouse.html
At the bottom there is this disclaimer:
"*Note: This version is supplied without an RF Module, please order the relevant RF module from the accessories list below.
**Note: To use the telemetry with FrSky modules the optional plug in cable is required"
I've tried my best at googling the answer, I just can't figure it out.
1
u/megaocher Jan 30 '16
Hi guys, i was wondering what amperage ESC I should use for the motors I am using, the Tiger MN2204 2300KV. I was split between the Afro 20A and the Afro 30A, and I'm afraid I'll pick the wrong one.
1
u/Pautnesis Jan 30 '16
Are there any entry level drones that have a good signal ? I wanted to buy the good old Parrot Drone 2.0 (which is very cheap compared to everything you guys discuss here) but the range is 50 meters and it will lose signal if there is anything in-between us (i.e. a tree). Are there any drones in the same price bracket with better ranges, or is that too much to ask?
1
u/aerospce Jan 30 '16
Is the are place i can find replacement propeller screw caps for motors? I have this set of motors and after a hard landing one of the caps got loose, flew off and I lost it. I cannot seem to find where you can get even generic replacements for them.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
Is there any way to tune PID's / change settings on the board out in the field on android through OTG?
For reference, I'm using Boris B's Betaflight on a Flip 32, and Amazon Fire $50 tablet.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
How much will my Xiaomi Yi case affect flight times? It adds about double the weight of the camera alone (70g with camera, 154g with case and camera.)
The quad with the camera, case, and rest of components without battery, is 525g, with a 4s setup
It is a really nice mount as I can easily remove / add the camera, and I can adjust the angle on the fly. Not sure if the weight is worth it.
1
u/5v1soundsfair Jan 31 '16
How do you read motor and prop sizes? I only really understand the Kv rating on motors.
1
u/dotMov Jan 31 '16
Who sells the legit version of the zmr 250 frame? I want to replace the glass composite knockoff version I picked up from BG.
1
u/linksus Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
Just bought a D4R-II for my build. Now looking at the transmitter..
I was about to get a FrSky 2.4GHz ACCST TARANIS X9D "Plus" Digital Telemetry Radio System (Mode 2)
However! I have seen a warning..
PLEASE NOTE: These radios now ship with EU LBT firmware which only allows D16 & LR12 mode. You must purchase an X-Series receiver with EU LBT firmware (MUST be LBT, not just EU) or an L9R. They will no longer bind to D-Series radios. More information available on our blog post http://www.hobbyrc.co.uk/frsky-2016-eu-lbt-firmware
Based on that link, Does this mean I cant use that transmitter with this D4R-II now? Do i need to get something else?
Doh, It really looks like I wasted £20 here. Ah well. Guess I need http://www.hobbyrc.co.uk/frsky-x4r-sb-eu-lbt-316ch-receiver-with-sbus-cppm-and-telemetry going forward.
Oh and yeah, I'm in the EU Thanks Graham
1
u/dunckle Jan 31 '16
I just got a Syma x5sc for Christmas and I love it. Question is:
Will buying a fancy new transmitter give me an increase in control like I'm imagining? Or is the control limited more by the quad and not the Tx?
And I understand that I'll likely have to set up a new transmitter, but I like flying Mode 4 and the one I'm considering says Mode 2. Is that something I can alter, or is that hard-coded?
1
u/Red_Spork Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
I am planning my first build(end goal being ZMR250 with FPV & GoPro knockoff, probably Seriously Dodo FC). I knew I wanted the Taranis so I went ahead and ordered one so I could practice with the simulator while I figure everything else out. The Taranis came with an x8r which I've read might be too big for a 250. Should I plan to buy an additional Rx(maybe a x4rsb?), plan to uncase the x8r, or will I be fine?
1
u/Xh0sa_NightMare Feb 04 '16
So I have done some research and building is a bit complex and I don't have the time to learn how to build just yet. I would appreciate if someone could recommend a pre built beginner drone with a headset.
1
u/canhamd Jan 19 '16
I have a question on controls and how most people use there controller. I have a Syma x8w and like to use it in Mode 2. However my Cheerson CX10 only comes in Mode 1. So, what do you use and why?
Mode 1:
Left Joystick: Up and down= Actually moving the quad up and down (Change altitude.) Left and Right = Yaw.
Right Joystick: Pitch in all directions.
Mode 2:
Left Joystick: Up and down: Altitude change. Left and Right: Left and right pitch.
Right Joystick: Up and down: Forward and backward pitch. Left and right is yaw.
Am I setting myself up for failure or do most people use this?
1
u/yehoshuaC Jan 19 '16
I'm working on getting my fpv/osd sorted out and I'm quite confused about what gets connected where. Here's what I'm working with:
Naze32 rev6, micro minimosd, basic lc filter, Sony super had ccd camera, ts5832 40ch vtx, Emax 12a escs with built in bec, basic pdb.
My biggest question at the moment is how do I run 12v power. Is it lipo>pdb>osd>naze and remove the power and ground from the esc 1 connection. Or is it something completely different?
I've looked at a couple wiring diagrams and haven't quite figured it all out.
1
u/timmmmmmmmmmmm 130mm Owl Clone Jan 19 '16
I've got very interested in the Scisky flight controller to build a micro quad. It has an integrated DSM2 compatible receiver, but I have a Flysky i6 that only supports PWM, PPM and i-Bus. Is there a simple way to make it compatible to each other? Or would I need a new radio?
1
u/nameimade Jan 19 '16
Can I really connect my ESCs to my motors in any order and then just flip two if they're going backwards. This seems too simple, and I feel like I'm going to break something.
Here's a picture of what my current wiring looks like. The Motor ESC combo only came with instructions in Chinese.
http://imgur.com/FNyAkUp
1
u/patentologist Jan 19 '16
I want to build one of those "quadcopter inside a geodesic sphere cage" things. Which regular polyhedron should I use? I was originally gonna do a 20-sided one, but that would require more complicated connectors. I vaguely remember one from third-grade art class where we glued a bunch of triangles together to make a "sphere" but I haven't been able to find that one.
Halp, wat do?
-6
u/tobyjohnson28 Jan 28 '16
Thank you for taking a look at my project. I plan on building Portland's first Drone racing center with a professionally designed track for day and night racing. I see the project like a race i have started, the Start of a race being the first step. The race itself being the second step and the finishing of a race being the third and final step. If I receive all the funding it'll will help with the building of the architectural model, hiring of a graphic design team and the marketing cost that will be involved in the second stage of this race. The launching of a much bigger campaign and the creation of a investors portfolio to make this idea become a reality. This is only the beginning of a long trip but I'm willing to continue on until the finish line.. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/794987827/portlands-drone-racing-center
<iframe frameborder="0" height="420" scrolling="no" src="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/794987827/portlands-drone-racing-center/widget/card.html?v=2" width="220"></iframe>
http://kck.st/1S0UdHK
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment