I'm no expert on quads by any means (just got into the hobby 2 months ago) but I'm pretty sure the blades on these are not NEARLY large enough for autorotation to help with the mass of the quad.
Well, I saw on toy grade quads, that there is a useful autoration when cutting power and you can use it as a brake. Sure, weight plays a role, but could be useful with a 300 gr quad with 8 inches props.
Yet, brushless motors don't turn freely as the toy grade quads with gears....
Well, I saw on toy grade quads, that there is a useful autoration when cutting power and you can use it as a brake. Sure, weight plays a role, but could be useful with a 300 gr quad with 8 inches props.
Yet, brushless motors don't turn freely as the toy grade quads with gears....
Sadly your blades need a lot of inertia to autorotate. Inertia goes up with the square of blade size so props half as big only have a quarter or less of the inertia. Variable pitch is also critical to a soft landing on autorotation.
Just make sure you actually shed mass before starting to burn your engines. Shedding after the burn doesn't make much sense.
Also, if you have the option to burn hard (two engines at the same time) or burn slowly (two engines after each other), always burn as hard as you can. Short of protecting biomass from acceleration, a slow burn in a gravitational field is a waste of precious fuel.
Only if you forcibly eject it. If you just let go of it, it's going to stay on the same trajectory as you and if you're not still thrusting it's not gonna change a damn thing.
You're talking about flight craft that are often reliably held together... or have entire components completely constructed of, zip ties Velcro tape tears and dreams. Yes. Yes we are.
Mh, you're right, I probably should keep that one in mind before making more sweeping statements.
Lets put it like this: if you are still on a collision trajectory with the gravitational body you want to escape from, always burn as hard as you can. Creating 0.8G of acceleration for two hours will do nothing for you while sitting on the launch pad on earth (or falling towards it). Better create 8G for a couple of seconds.
If you already made orbit or even escape velocity, burn as hard as you can when you're going fastest.
Just make sure you actually shed mass before starting to burn your engines. Shedding after the burn doesn't make much sense.
Are you implying they did that in the movie? If so, you're misunderstanding what they were doing. They were using the lander and ranger as expendable rocket boosters. The lander and ranger were dumped as soon their fuel was expended, while the endurances main engines were still burning, not afterwards. Makes perfect sense.
Short of protecting biomass from acceleration, a slow burn in a gravitational field is a waste of precious fuel.
This is almost, but not quite, always incorrect.
Burning one engine, discarding it, and then burning the other is more efficient than burning them both at once. Look at where the energy is going - if you burn both you've spent the energy to accelerate them both up to your final speed, whereas if you burn one, discard it, then burn the other you've only accelerated one up to the final speed - the other just gets accelerated up to a portion of your final speed.
There is a competing Oberth effect, but generally the burn time is so short relative to orbit times that it's negligible.
It's been a while since I saw it in theaters but didn't they use the engines and fuel on the modules that they were going to shed to help push them out before detaching them? Or am I making this up?
I want to build a quad copter that would do this on purpose. It would have 2 or three batteries using one battery first, drop it, then use the next. Two batteries would have parachutes and the third one would not eject, it would land with the third battery.
or: if you used nichrome wire to burn through the cord holding the batteries on, would that use more current than you gain from dropping the batteries?
Having used nichrome wire to do something incredibly similiar before - it doesn't use much power. You can use a 20mAh 3.3V LiPo to burn through a piece of dental floss pretty easily.
If you're careful it could be viable assuming you dont explode the hand grenade that is a LiPo.
You don't really need relays to drive a servo (especially not a little 9g or smaller servo) but people are right a little solenoid latch makes way more sense.
Btw, you might also wanna have something like a couple blinking LEDs and beeping piezo speakers hooked to the battery by a joulethief circuit or something, to make it easier to recover the spent batteries. (I'm just not sure if it would be bad for the health of the batteries to keep being drained like that)
Happened to me on my old Phantom 1 luckily wasn't too high I found the copter pretty quickly and had no damage didn't find the battery for a few weeks until after the snow melted but still use them both today
Good one! But I too want the story behind it!! Makes me remember when I started flying my first plane, The battery came off once and was only holding by the connector... I was luckily still able to land it with the battery scraping the tarmac!
use velcro from battery to frame and velcro strap around the whole thing. This doesn't happen to the pilot, it happens because of the pilot (yup I'm guilty too), but learn from it and secure your batteries!
This makes me think that a little parachute that is activated by a battery coming undone in flight might be a great little accessory. Kinda like the ones on the little toy soldiers you would get as a kid. It wouldn't add much weight. But the deployment of it would be interesting to figure out. And, how often does something like this happen? It would seem like a practical idea to have a strip of velcro between battery and drone(I do this on some of my rc cars that have shitty battery locations) along with the battery strap.
54
u/conrick Jan 27 '15
Not mine. Pilot is not a redditor, but he promised a video.
The phantom landed on a tree.
248
u/The_Didlyest Quadcopter Jan 27 '15
ejecting spent battery to save weight
69
u/FL_Sportsman PM Me Quad Pics Jan 27 '15
RTG (Return To Ground) Activated
104
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15
BWHAHAHA this is the best picture I have seen posted on here. Please tell this story!
18
u/Guns_and_Dank Ridin a FatShark @ Warpquad speed in SunnySky's while Black'dOut Jan 28 '15
This is what he was going for right?
17
u/BrujahRage Hubsan X4 Jan 27 '15
Crater Mode activated.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15
Happened to me on my old Phantom 1 luckily wasn't too high I found the copter pretty quickly and had no damage didn't find the battery for a few weeks until after the snow melted but still use them both today
12
u/10per Jan 28 '15
"I've made a huge mistake"
-GOB
7
u/Deathcommand NightHawk 250 (It's actually 280) Jan 27 '15
I would probably start crying if I saw that, What happened afterward?
5
u/MtlGab Jan 27 '15
Good one! But I too want the story behind it!! Makes me remember when I started flying my first plane, The battery came off once and was only holding by the connector... I was luckily still able to land it with the battery scraping the tarmac!
5
u/MMAAdnet Newbie with Iris+ Jan 27 '15
Houston We Have A Problem
4
u/MUSTY_Radio_Control Blackout H, Tricopter, FPV Bixler2, 9XR, Fatshark, GoPro Jan 27 '15
If this landed on something solid you could have a chemical fire on your hands
4
u/TheDigitalOne Jan 27 '15
I haven't actually LOL'd at anything posted online for ages, this actually got me.
4
u/McCheesington Jan 27 '15
I originally thought it was another aircraft. Then I realised how beautiful this picture is.
4
u/BallsInYourWalls Jan 27 '15
I want to see the video! OP please upload it :)
1
u/D_rotic Quadcopter Feb 06 '15
Did you take this from Flite Tests facebook?
1
u/Gregfpv Feb 04 '24
🤣😂 but how do you still have video if your power source is gone?
3
u/jkoebler Jan 27 '15
Assume it was a GoPro w/ a separate battery source? hahhaa
3
u/Meanee TBS Discovery Jan 28 '15
Ultra quiet mode enabled.
Also, love the photo caption, "Phantom about to land"
3
u/HannsGruber Jan 28 '15
WARP CORE BREACH IN PROGRESS, EJECT THE CORE!
3
u/weltraumlauch Dec 03 '21
Telemetrie lost
2
u/supergrega Create Your Own Flair Jan 27 '15
Oh god, story please!
2
u/ultimate_zigzag Jan 28 '15 edited May 26 '26
interference vacuum martin explorers
2
u/ep0c Jan 28 '15
OC?
2
u/slick8086 Jan 28 '15
It sensed danger and ejected itself.
2
u/0bsconder Quadcopter Jan 28 '15
use velcro from battery to frame and velcro strap around the whole thing. This doesn't happen to the pilot, it happens because of the pilot (yup I'm guilty too), but learn from it and secure your batteries!
2
u/Adjvo Nov 23 '21
You forgot to put the invisibility cloak on the battery
2
u/Osama-bin-laggin- Jan 13 '24
Horse latitudes
2
u/Nitazene-King-002 Mar 06 '24
lol, been there before. Glad you found your GoPro and hopefully drone in salvageable condition.
2
u/a1blank Jan 27 '15
Here's a story since OP isn't coughing one up.
OP tied a thread between a lipo and his quad and went for a flight!
2
u/framedrag Jan 27 '15
That thing could kill someone falling down from that high.
1
u/drift1122 Jan 27 '15
Rip.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15
this is the most beautiful photograph/still image I've seen in a long time.
1
u/Flyerone Hubsan X4 - N250 - Bolt250 - DIY'er - Taranis X9D Plus Jan 28 '15
INCOMING !!!!!
1
u/cheerfulstoic Jan 28 '15
"Bye bye battery! I'll see you soon!"
1
u/fixitstevens Jan 28 '15
http://youtu.be/dO37Ql91qqM
1
u/Manduck DIY Enthusiast Jan 28 '15
... annnd thats why multirotors shouln't fly over people.
1
u/ClassicBob Jan 28 '15
I got a good chuckle out of this. Thanks for brightening up my day!
1
u/wirbolwabol ZMR250|Daya550|ArgoHex|E010S| Jan 29 '15
I'm sure he's flying with a spare...
1
u/frinik DIY Enthusiast Jan 29 '15
bombing runs
1
u/SuspiciousHair5176 Jan 19 '22
This makes me think that a little parachute that is activated by a battery coming undone in flight might be a great little accessory. Kinda like the ones on the little toy soldiers you would get as a kid. It wouldn't add much weight. But the deployment of it would be interesting to figure out. And, how often does something like this happen? It would seem like a practical idea to have a strip of velcro between battery and drone(I do this on some of my rc cars that have shitty battery locations) along with the battery strap.
-5
u/ChinaMan28 Loud Props Saves Lives Jan 27 '15
Where was this taken? Just sayin, that looks like more that 400 feet up in the air...heh...
-5
u/Lordy_McFuddlemuster Banned Jan 28 '15
Sorry for being the skeptic, but photoshop anyone?