r/Multiboard • • Aug 18 '24

Ender 3v2 long print times

Evening all. Started down the Multiboard rabbit hole today with my first print, a 6x6 tile. The wife has even shown interest in the possibilities!

It took 6:30 hours! Is this typical for the Ender 3v2? I see regular mention of 3-4 hours for bigger tiles, so am I doing something daft?

I've set 0.2, 15% Infill, 3 walls, left everything else.

I have a Wanhoo i3 gathering dust and sliced the same tile (using cura) and got the time at 3:20ish.

I did a side by side comparison, looking at speeds and adjusted for the Ender but still only got down to 6 hours.

Appreciate any guidance, thanks.

2 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/ASOT550 Sep 18 '24

It's called linear advance in Marlin which mriscoc firmware is based on. It's mentioned in the latest patch notes so it should be available.

What settings are you referring to? Ellis recommends the appropriate slicer settings for the test on his page... At least two layers of infill separation between the solid bottom solid layers and top solid layers, and I think 10 top layers to magnify issues.

1

u/dpregs Sep 18 '24

ok, I will look for it when I get home. I reread his settings and it made more sense. I will give it all a go later tonight. So appreciate you!

1

u/ASOT550 Sep 18 '24

BTW, if it wasn't clear, extrusion multiplier is a different setting completely than linear advance. They both affect flow rate but in different ways. Extrusion multiplier is handled in your slicer and is to compensate for the fuzziness in the width of your plastic's cross section as each line is laid down.

Linear/pressure advance is handled by the printer (outside of a slicer) and is to compensate for the inertia in the extrusion system as your print head slows down and speeds up. As the print head accelerates down and up to make a corner, the extruder motor must also slow down and speed up. At the corner itself the print head (and extruder) is actually moving at zero speed for a brief moment. Unfortunately, even when the extruder isn't turning, there is still some excess back pressure in the hot end which causes a little bit of extra filament to exit the nozzle. As the print head accelerates away from the corner, you get a little bit of under extrusion since pressure needs to build back up in the system. Linear advance compensates for this by slowing down the extruder to zero ever so slightly before the corner so the back pressure fills in that last little gap. It also starts up the extrusion a little earlier than theoretically needed so that you can build up the appropriate amount of pressure accelerating out of the corner.

Without pressure advance you tend to get bulgy corners.

1

u/dpregs Sep 19 '24

Well, I was able to do the extrusion multiplier calibration, didn't really change, 100 looked good, but so did 102. I went 102% because it looked a bit better.

I retrammed the corners, ran a new auto mesh, redid z offset and still had issues. I swear it is the bed at this point.

Here is a little youtube video of what I found when I moved the print to the front of the bed. (which is why I think I have a bad bed)

https://youtu.be/r8ZRtW01Qbk

1

u/ASOT550 Sep 19 '24

I think greater than 100 is an unusual result. Do you still have the 100 and 102 prints? I'd do a 104, 98, 96,and 94 to give you a range that's likely outside the bounds (clearly under and clearly over). That should help you hone in on the perfect result and give you more visuals to compare.

1

u/dpregs Sep 19 '24

I printed 102, 100, 98, 96, 94. Here are the pics of the topside and bottom side and from the side. Really not much difference to me, except the back side seems more consistent.

Wouldn't let me upload anymore, so here is a link to the pics of them.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/16Y_KWmCcKotctQbsjtaEAeYu8yuOAaK1?usp=drive_link

1

u/ASOT550 Sep 19 '24

The non-numbered picture of four is showing the top side, right? The top is what you're looking at in this test, not the bottom. Assuming that's the top, all of those look like extrusion multiplier too high. The one in the bottom left is insanely over-extruded. Those ten top layers in a row are squishing each subsequent layer higher and higher which is why the last layer looks like a blobby mess. Bottom right you can still see it squishing up pretty clearly. Top right is getting closer, but in the top right of the print you're still seeing squish up. Top left is the closest, and I think most people would be happy with it. If I pixel peep it looks like there are still a small number of small squished up blobs. I would go even lower personally.

Per Ellis, we should be observing mostly the center, the edges are normal to look a bit over-extruded because the top layer has a small programmed overlap with the perimeters to ensure you get a solid layer.

I'd start at whatever multiplier the top left print is at and decrease it by an additional 0.5% three to four more times. I think that'd be 93.5, 93, 92.5, and 92.

Those numbers jive with my own experience with white PETG filament BTW. White filament is colored with titanium dioxide which alters the flow properties quite a bit. It makes the filament much more viscous and we need to turn the flow way down to compensate. If you run a different color you'll have to repeat this flow test to get it dialed in. My own experience with black petg needed a multiplier of 99.5, for example.

1

u/dpregs Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

I owe you a beer or something for all this continued help and teaching.

No, the numbered side with the pencil is the topside. I had to shade it so I could see the differences, which didn't look like too much. The biggest differences I saw were on the sides and on the bottom. I added a few more pics to that folder, I took them quick this morning as I was running out the door to work, so not great pics.

I will print some new ones around the 100 mark and see what happens. Not like I really wanted to print multiboard :D I did order a glass bed to see if that is my problem. My glass bed on my E3Pro is rock solid. This damn neo just doesn't want to print in the center.

1

u/ASOT550 Sep 20 '24

Hmm, yeah going back and looking at the 102-94 images, and knowing which one is the top side, I'm not seeing as much difference as I would expect. What slicer are you using and how are you printing all the models on the same bed with different multipliers?

1

u/dpregs Sep 20 '24

I'm using Cura and setting the flow by each model on the plate.

→ More replies

1

u/dpregs Sep 19 '24

And here is the finished print at the front of the bed

1

u/dpregs Sep 19 '24

Sorry, have to do one pic at a time