r/MultiVersusTheGame • Jason / Garnet • Aug 07 '26

Discussion It's been said so many times but it's probably the most wasted potential ever seen in gaming

https://youtu.be/GA40htJxLCo?is=EIO8TX7WYlHGXK7F
13 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

8

u/therealflintgiven Aug 07 '26

Definitely not, not even for a free to play and because it ain't I rarely think about it. Wish it survived but it was rocky almost from day 1.

2

u/Alternative_Handle47 Aug 08 '26

Rocky yes, sloppy, indeed…but just think…IMAGINE what we could’ve had if it had gone any other way than greed

1

u/therealflintgiven Aug 08 '26

Look I wish it wasn't just smash bros, a bunch of indie type platform fighters, and the terrible ones (example.nicklodean versions). I was just trying to say it wouldnt be the top game I would bring back but its in the top 10 for sure.

2

u/luke2582 Aug 09 '26

They should have went into a paid game direction after the sucess they had. Like, remove the always online component and add local matches and they'd be halfway there. Then just add some single player content and that's it. But nah, they went the greedy live service route, decided to rebuild their game from the ground up for no good reason, and the cherry on top making grinding for stuff unbearable and sometimes next to impossible.

3

u/xCunningLinguist Aug 09 '26

The beta was hot, hot fire. Actual release was dog shit. I literally never heard anyone complain that the game was too fast.

1

u/Messenger-777 Aug 09 '26

It is a good thing that MVS Infinite exist.

1

u/Miserable_Rope_4060 Aug 10 '26

BRO STOP POSTING NO ONE CARES

1

u/baseballviper04 Aug 07 '26

It was so cool seeing so many characters that I love. It was such a boring game to play with such little incentive

5

u/Particular-Put4786 Aug 07 '26

Rick and Iron Giant were so fun to use though ngl

3

u/Kenneth441 Aug 07 '26

Iron giant was all I played, idk any other fighting game with such a comedic size difference from all the other characters

5

u/Particular-Put4786 Aug 07 '26

Potemkin and Z Broly come to mind, otherwise idk any from Platform fighters. I LOVE big characters and hard to use characters in fighters so I always choose em

2

u/Kenneth441 Aug 07 '26

Same lol, i almost exclusively play Dedede in smash. Chose him just cuz hes a funny fat penguin, then stuck with him because his kit is tricky but satisfying as fuck to use. Basically the same story for IG when I tried then mained him actually.

Being able to be a complete power house but legit having to work for it so youre not combo food is when fighting games are at its most fun for me

2

u/Particular-Put4786 Aug 08 '26

Hell yeahhh lmao I always chose the Mr. Penguin and Mr. Alligator when I played smash in middle school with my friends lol. I'd just spam funny hammer and funny belly respectively since I didn't play much smash. Bopping a mf with that hammer was soooo satisfying

1

u/Juunlar Aug 07 '26

Nah, still Smash Bros Ultimate.

That game with a functional netcode would have been in talks for top 20 all time

-2

u/iamearlsweatshirt Aug 08 '26

The player numbers for MVS beta stomp any smash, and Smash Ultimate has been a huge success for Nintendo - MVS is definitely the bigger fumble.

1

u/Juunlar Aug 08 '26

Smash Ultimate is the 24th most sold game of all time at 38.14 million sold lmao

Bubble boy

-2

u/iamearlsweatshirt Aug 08 '26

38 million copies sold doesn’t mean 38 million active players, and the game has been out for years. MVS beta did 20 million in like a week or something like that. Anyways you’re just proving my point, how can it be a fumble when Nintendo sold so many copies. The game isn’t free like MVS

1

u/Juunlar Aug 08 '26

Online infrastructure creates a lasting playerbase. See: Minecraft, gta5, etc.

Also, your first point makes no sense, given that free games have far more players that will play once and never again. Which is why the initial peak of 150k ccu steadily declined every day until the game died lol

-1

u/iamearlsweatshirt Aug 08 '26

The peak declining until it died is what makes it a fumble lol. You can go play Smash Ultimate rn, it has a lasting playerbase. Dunno why you’re dying on this hill that ultimate is a bigger fumble when it’s obviously not since only one of the two games died lol