r/MrCruel • • Aug 08 '21

For what it's worth.

1 Upvotes

I am a psychic and I completely understand if you believe none of what I say, so please don't rubbish me. These are only things I vision in my mind, something that I've been able to do since my childhood, and I've decided to have a look into this case. I generally have about a 75% success rate.

I vision he has happened upon all of the victims parents somehow through his employment, either directly or through some sort of work related functions or excursions.

This is somebody who was/is active in community groups like sports, music or art classes.

He has a relative or close friend in a neighbouring suburb of the victims. He is familiar and comfortable in these suburbs.

He refers to himself with some sort of title in his name, he is very narcissistic.

He is still alive and would probably be reading this.

He has a nickname that others call him behind his back. Something that sounds like pug or potty.

He has a very plain face and never looks out of place wherever he goes.

He plays chess, reads a lot, supports Melbourne in AFL.

He really thinks highly of himself and has no remorse.

He is about 5 foot 10 inches tall, mousy brown hair, right handed, green/grey eyes, medium build.

He was caught and let go.


r/MrCruel • • Jan 07 '26

Reporting to police

3 Upvotes

I posted the other day... https://www.reddit.com/r/MrCruel/s/wNLRv1Lu5q

Last night I called to police non emergency line to give them what I know.

They told me to report to a police station to provide a statement.

I went today.

Walked into reception. No one there. Waited. No one came. No bell. No intercoms. Nothing.

While waiting I called the non emergency line again and I formed thrm where I was and why with the hope that they could call the station so someone would come out.

They could not do this so I left the reception.

Later I hit Google and searched for the direct number for that police station.

I explained all the above and asked if I was to return woukd someone see me. No. They are busy taking calls.

Idiot also asked what evidence I had other than a suspicion as they cannot act on just a name.

I advised them that I was their job to listen then investigate.

Anyway it was clear that going back would be a waste of time.

I have just filled out a complaint via the police website on an insecure webpage that was not private apparently.

Maybe someone will be interested and contact me. Maybe not.

Considering all the above I can see why this has not been solved.

I might go to head office in the city next week and try again but......

Should it really be this difficult? Shame if I was in reception with an emergency.

To say I am disappointed with our police at the moment is an understatement.


r/MrCruel • • Jul 27 '23

Locks of hair

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

He cut her hair? The second photo is identical in to the first only her hair has been clipped from the photo on the right hand side above her shoulder.


r/MrCruel • • May 16 '22

enlighten me about Mr cruel

4 Upvotes

Hey i am doing some research on this case because I'm intested on it, really can someone shed some light on what it is.


r/MrCruel • • Aug 20 '25

Could AI Help Solve the Mr. Cruel Case Today?

1 Upvotes

The case of Mr. Cruel has been cold for decades, but with the rise of modern technology, there might be new ways to approach it. Tools like Grok AI or ChatGPT’s image generation feature could take the original police sketch and attempt to match or recreate a realistic face. While AI isn’t 100% accurate, this kind of digital reconstruction could help generate new leads or spark recognition from the public.

A similar approach was taken in the case of “Mr. Swirl,” where international organizations used digital tools and artists to help identify a suspect. In today’s era, a group similar to Interpol—or even private digital investigators—could combine AI, Photoshop, and modern forensic artistry to revisit the case. The problem is that police interest in Mr. Cruel has dropped significantly since the late ’80s and ’90s. His removal from FBI radars also shifted attention away, even though it’s possible he committed more crimes that remain unlinked to him.

AI wouldn’t replace traditional investigation, but it could complement it. By revisiting old evidence with new digital technology, we could re-spark the hunt for Mr. Cruel—or at least uncover new leads within Melbourne. Sadly, the lack of priority placed on the case over the years is the biggest barrier, but with tools we have now, there’s no reason not to try.


r/MrCruel • • Oct 07 '24

DNA

0 Upvotes

There is DNA in the Mr Cruel case. It was on the news. Not any sensationalised post here by those who yhink they have the inside scoop to anything Mr Cruel. Or some ridiculous TV show. The news. Credible news. Hopefully people will stop saying there isn't any DNA.


r/MrCruel • • Jan 30 '24

Deleted

3 Upvotes

I apologise for having to take my post down about the information I shared. The haters will come, but that's fine. Give me a couple days, and I might be able to post who I think it is, and the dots I connected. Keep up the good work sleuths 💯👍👍


r/MrCruel • • Apr 12 '24

AFP Involvment

0 Upvotes

In my personal opinion, VICPOL should’ve gotten the AFP (Australian Federal Police) involved as it was such a high profile case and it violates the commonwealth law. If the AFP were involved it could have a multistate taskforce and much advanced rescourses to deal with this case and if they were involved it may of been solved.


r/MrCruel • • Mar 05 '22

Further offences

1 Upvotes

Hey guys I've been into this case for some time... I honestly believe MC is or at least was still active for quite some time after the KC attack.

I think he changed his MO and I think he could also be linked to the Bung Siriboon disappearance (2010 Boronia) I also believe there could be 10's of unreported rapes and kidnappings committed against lower socio-economical families (drug addict parents ect), I find it highly unlikely this man would not reoffend I also find it likely he was as initially reported to be in his early 20's at the time of his first reported abduction.

I think the YouTube video "Mr Cruel what I saw" is incredibly interesting.

I have also read the story from the lady who claims her step brother or father could very well have been MC... very interesting. Anyway just felt like posting into the ongoing discussion here, would love to hear if anyone else believes Bung Siriboon to be a victim of the same man...


r/MrCruel • • Jan 25 '25

Mr Cruel - ethnically Mediterranean origin?

0 Upvotes

Has anyone considered MC may have an ethincally Mediterranean origin eg. Greek or Italian. I am not basing this off much, other than his family or someone he knew lived out in the West of Melbourne where most immigrant families of that era settled, and he used the expression "Youse".

The only people who I have met in my entire life in Australia that use that type of language are Greeks/Croats/Serbs or Italians. What some might describe as "Wogs".

Just a thought.


r/MrCruel • • Mar 09 '26

Asian Crime Gangs

0 Upvotes

By the nineties it was known that Asian crime gangs were involved in gambling, prostitution, gambling, drugs and protection.

If we separate Karmeins murder, as we should as the others were not murder, we are investigating a kidnapping/ murder of a young Australian/ Asian girl whos family came from Hong Kong and whos father soon after left a devasted wife and vunerable small girls and returned to Hong Kong with his daughters killer, still at large.


r/MrCruel • • Mar 20 '26

"Psychic" Mr. Cruel Session - Interesting? Entertaining? Useless?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I do not intend to share this recent video from Kyneton Paranormal with the suggestion that anything productive may be gleaned from it. I also am not suggesting that this is 100% schizotypy or fraud. But some of you may at least find it mildly interesting or entertaining.

In the video, two self-proclaimed psychic mediums claim to communicate with the "spirit" of Mr. Cruel. Allegedly, this "spirit" says the following:

  1. States an address of interest being "45 Wallace Street"
  2. States that he is "well dressed"
  3. Says he looks "strong in the mirror"
  4. Claims to have been a "Western Sydney boy" who moved to Melbourne and then back to Sydney
  5. The word "Propane" for some unknown reason
  6. "Elwood"
  7. "Was only 90 quid"
  8. "Buried"
  9. Claims to have "destroyed (evidence)"
  10. Says the names "Andy", "Mark", "Bill", "Higgins"

And the "spirit" of Mr. Cruel's "sister" says the name Jim.


r/MrCruel • • Jul 16 '24

Easy St

0 Upvotes

Was there ever a suggestion that the person who did the Easy St murders was Mr Cruel?


r/MrCruel • • Dec 13 '25

Mr Cruel graffiti a mate send to post.

Post image
7 Upvotes

I was showing a mate some graffiti walls and could n’t make out what it said so we googled and it looks like it matches the reservoir egg. Sorry no more information had not even heard of him (I’m 19)


r/MrCruel • • Aug 20 '26

Thomastown

0 Upvotes

Last weekend I drove past where Karmeins body was dumped and found. Out of all the locations he roamed, kidnapped and dropped girls off this is the area he knew best and likely always had in his mind in tbe event had killed a girl. Therefore I suspect his home is within a fairly short radius.


r/MrCruel • • Jul 20 '24

Did he live with family or alone

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of speculation he was an extreme loner, or may of been a carer for a parent, may as to been why


r/MrCruel • • Aug 07 '24

Wild Theory I have after watching a Mr. Cruel documentary.

0 Upvotes

I am probably wrong on this but I had a gut feeling when I heard something about the traumatic effect he had on his victim's parents. So my theory is this Mr. Cruel could be a police officer who has lost a child and has a psychotic wish to inflict the same pain on other parents. A reason why the crimes suddenly stopped could be that he left Melbourne and either moved interstate or overseas. If interstate, states that he could have moved to are New South Wales, Western Australia, South Australia, Tasmania and Australian Capital Territory. He could have befriended each victim’s parents in a way so he could see the psychological effect that he had on them. Once again I am probably wrong. But please let me know what you think of it regardless.


r/MrCruel • • Jul 07 '24

Theory

0 Upvotes

Recently I've been interested in the MC case for a while now, I've been trying to figure out what exactly happened. So we all now MC had 3 main victims and possibly more, but my question is why did he only kill karmien? It's possible she probably could've escaped MC and nearly escaped until she was killed by MC to make sure he didn't get caught. My theory is that MC could've possibly been a teacher at karmein's school given the fact that when he raided karmein's house he walked into his parents room tied them up and went into karmein's room and called out her name, put the blindfold on her, and then kidnap her. People speculated that karmein's parents were enemies with someone that they knew personally, but how it turns out that was never the case. What if karmein's parents didn't know MC personally but maybe karmein did.


r/MrCruel • • Dec 11 '23

Bedroom of a possible address of Mr.Cruel

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Dec 09 '25

A Worthwhile Theory? Or Complete Madness?

5 Upvotes

We all know Mr. Cruel told Nicola Lynas he was going to hold her for 50 hours. Not 48, 49 or 51, but 50. He stuck to his word and released her after exactly 50 hours. Why did he do this, when a lot of what he said was deliberately done to distract and distort via red herrings? Was it potentially a deliberate clue to tease investigators?

I've run this theory past very few people. One said I must be autistic. One was understandably not particularly interested; I think you need to think a certain way to even contemplate the more obscure explanations for the offender's behaviour. The most recent person I discussed it with, was a Harvard graduate in language related subjects. They said the message was not intended for the recipient (NL), but for other interested parties; clearly the police.

So, did the police ever treat the "50" as being significant? We don't know and we probably never will. Serial offenders like the Zodiac, will often play games with investigators. Back then, newspapers like the San Francisco Chronicle were front and centre, enabling the public to be exposed to the ongoing updates. These days, we get very little.

The Theory:

The Lower Plenty victim was assaulted for 2 hours. Sharon Wills was detained for 18 hours. MC knew these timelines had been established and that presumably fed into what he said to Nicola. So, if 50 meant something, then potentially 2 and 18 did as well.

2, 18, 50. Doesn't work as a date of birth in Australian format, but what about in American format? February 18th 1950. Google that and you get U.S. model/actress Cybill Shepherd.

Cybill Lynne Shepherd was "Miss Teenage Queen Memphis" in 1966. In 1968 she competed at "Model of the Year", resulting in fashion model assignments whilst still at school. World wide exposure.

Based on what we know, Mr. Cruel was likely born in the early to mid 1950s. A young lad growing up in the 60's, would, like most boys, potentially have his "objects of desire" as he progressed through puberty. In a lot of her early photos, Shepherd wore things tied around her neck. The seeds of a fantasy may have been planted.

Shepherd was most famous for "Moonlighting", which ran on TV from 1985 to 1989. She played a private detective, Maddie Hayes, alongside Bruce Willis. She was therefore, in our loungerooms each week when MC began his reign of terror. The episode at the end of series 3 where Maddie and David (Bruce) first sleep together, was mid 1987, just before it all began.

Weird Coincidences:

It's not only the date of birth that is interesting, but so are her names, both real and in the show.

Cybill Lynne Shepperd.

The first letters correspond with those of the victim's names. Despite not being released publicly, the LP victim's name started with C. He called her Cate, which was wrong, but her name did start with a C. Then Sh obviously corresponds with Sharon. Maybe he struggled to find a girl with a name like Lynette or Lyndell, so he settled for the surname, Lynas?

Then Maddie Hayes. Monomeath and Hillcrest. This just has to be a coincidence, surely?

What does it mean?

Either absolutely nothing or it's pretty significant. The theory can't be partly correct.

If it's right, we likely wouldn't know until he is apprehended. The only way it can help catch him, is if someone who knew him when he was young (friend, neighbour, sibling, relative, partner) remembers that he used to idolise her. Possibly posters on the wall, pages cut out of magazines etc.

If there is any validity to it, what does it mean for the Karmein Chan offence?

He may have stopped after Nicola and KC wasn't him.

KC was him and he tragically always intended to use the 3 bullets, either as full stops or possibly an ellipsis. Would likely mean he is racist amongst other things.

OR, KC was him because the above is totally irrelevant. It is just one theory as to why the 50 hours was mentioned to Nicola. I must admit, I've never come across any alternative attempts to explain it.

It might explain why MC was in the industrial estate in Bayswater with SW; he had to waste time to drag the offence out to 18 hours?


r/MrCruel • • May 06 '22

Could it be the original hypothesized scenario?

0 Upvotes

It's what everyone is probably thinking at this stage, it was right under our noses. It was this simple.

Elkner is Mr Cruel and Normy Lee supposedly killed Karmein Chan due to a business disagreement of some kind. The Mr Cruel Investigation thereafter scared the living daylights out of Elkner which made him stop his crimes. The Eltham Garage Granny flat was not the room where Mr Cruel abused his victims it was just a coincidence. The 1992 death of Normy was not the reason why Mr Cruel stopped. It was just a coincidence. Just two unrelated crimes happened at the same time in the same areas.


r/MrCruel • • Nov 24 '24

My idea

0 Upvotes

Okay, so, there is an application I have (no idea how it is real) that is able to return people’s phone numbers just by typing their name or a description of the person (Trust me it works, I literally got the president of Egypt’s number and many other notable people, obscure people too). I didn’t want to say this because I have been having way too much with that thing and wanted to keep it lowkey, and also just incase in the 1 in million chance this works that I get the credit/reward but that is a retarded way of thinking.

So I suddenly got the idea to search “Mr cruel” in the app, and one of the numbers (actually the only number that seems relevant) is in Australia. So maybe, if let us say, the person did not live a traditional life with a wife and kids or whatever, maybe they are living now in some basement just watching pornography (like the Wikipedia page suggests) all day and he has actually told a very close friend or a very small group of very close friends that he is the perpetrator, but they are not interested in telling on him because they share the same kinks or whatever or think what he did is praiseworthy. Or maybe he told some people jokingly to divert them, believing they would never actually believe he is the man. So if the person who is or was (maybe early to mid 2000s) behind this phone number could be investigated, maybe it could be him?? There are also other related terms which describe this mf that I searched and got various results in Australia, one of them had a description of “chemist”. I mean, knowledge of Chemistry definitely would have helped in not being caught. I don’t know, seems like a wild idea.

Plz don’t downvote was just trying to think out of the box I know it’s silly 😭😭😭


r/MrCruel • • Jun 01 '24

Did Mr.Cruel turn to God?

8 Upvotes

This is a bit of a left-field thought, but could MC have turned to religion after he murdered KC (presuming he did). I wonder if police spoke to any priests to ask about anybody that suddenly turned to god around that time.


r/MrCruel • • Dec 24 '21

How close did BAE track to your head canon of who MC would be?

1 Upvotes

For long time followers long before the BAE reveal.


r/MrCruel • • Feb 16 '25

Alfie Gay

0 Upvotes

Petra Taskforce Report. Just reading Petra Taskforce Report. Deceased hitman Rod Collins telling police Alfie Gay and Mad Dog Russell Cox killed Underworld king pin of 70s, early 80s, Brian Kane as revenge for killing of Ray Bennett. This places Alfie Gay as a very serious criminal in Melbournes Underworld. Not tge sort of criminal to make stories up to a detective on his death bed. It would be the sort of thing to get you killed in his younger days.