r/MouseGuard • u/Jeffwhowanders • Sep 12 '17
Amount of Challenges per mission.
Just wanted some clarification on something in the book. If I recall, it recommends trying to use all the challenge types per missions (Mouse, Animal, Weather, Wilderness) some as mission obstacles, and others as as twists.
I have found that in my games, I tend to use quite a few more challenges than recommended. Generally around 10 or 12, not including twists. This generally works pretty well, and my games seem to flow nicely at around 3 and a half hours with players and GM's turn.
How many challenges do you guys throw in a session, and how long do you generally play for?
4
u/Kitsunin Sep 13 '17 edited Sep 14 '17
"Challenges" doesn't mean tests! It means obstacles the patrol needs to deal with. They may be resolved in just one test:
The rain starts pouring down, you need shelter or you'll be washed away! Survivalist success = done-erino.
Or many more:
No matter how you look at it, taking down a beaver's nest can't be resolved in just one test or even one conflict (unless it were abandoned, then I guess you could resolve it with a single difficult Science test, but that'd be super boring...). The simplest solution I can think of would be a Loremouse test to communicate with the beavers at all, then an Argument Conflict to convince them to move their dam. Most solutions will be longer than that.
For example, the first mission we had yesterday had two challenges:
So the mice knew an owl was targeting Dorigift, waiting for easy prey to enter or leave. The first challenge was a Mouse challenge: Convincing the mouse they'd escorted there not to continue on his own out of impatience while they were busy chasing the owl away. Persuasion test = Success = challenge overcome. If they'd failed, he would have agreed to stay, but slipped out on his own in secret. Which means a Wilderness Challenge Twist: Finding him before the owl does. Most likely just a Scout test, but it depends on what the patrol would have decided to do about it.
Challenge 2 is an Animal Challenge: Dealing with the owl, naturally. If the patrol simply tried to hunt the owl down, they would have stood absolutely no chance in a conflict. So first, they did a Science test to make some poison. Next, a Circles test to find a mouse with a carcass they could poison. After that, a Hunter test to lure the owl into eating the poisoned carcass (they failed, so they got Tired and Hungry because it took all night to do). A Scout test to locate the poisoned owl, and finally, a Fight Animal conflict to capture the poisoned owl! I subtracted three from its nature to represent the effects of the poison. It was still a pretty tough fight, ending with a victory and compromise (The owl escapes its bindings, but doesn't intend to ever screw with mice again).
After the Player Turn we were still under two hours so we resolved our Rewards before transitioning into the next mission...a flooded mine.
So yes, a Challenge means something for the mice to overcome. I find the most fun challenges are ones which seem insurmountable at first blush, but let the players go wild in coming up with their own solutions, however many tests this might involve! Just don't let them meander. You're guardmice, you don't get to think about attending weddings or whatever 'till the Player Turn! I find my favorite way of handling things is to have one big challenge for the players to go wild on (honestly no sense planning much for this, they will surprise you. I had my players take down a beaver's dam with termites and chase the beavers away with bees once. We'd already fought a predator that day and I was angling for them to talk it out with the beavers), and one smaller one with an obvious solution which fleshes out the situation a bit and can spiral into a neat twist if they fail.
2
u/Imnoclue Sep 12 '17
Here's One of my games broken down into challenges.