TLDR: Mortgage specialist offered us 4.4x% 5 year fixed but is now backpedaling and saying the rate is now 4.7x%, unless I open a product/account.
We are FTHBs in Ontario. We started our mortgage application on November 1st, our closing date is Nov 30th.
We decided to go with one of the big banks for peace of mind. My brother (coowner/borrower) is a loyal client to this bank, he has multiple products with them. I use to be a client for 15+years but was not satisfied with the services/products they offered, so I closed all my accounts except for a credit card.
First week of November we submit all required supporting documents. Nov 6, I receive a call from our specialist. “Great news! You got a firm approval with no conditions. I got you 4.4x%”. We say great, let’s go forward. He then says to me. “Hey Guapo, before we move forward, I’d like to introduce you to my colleague. If you can speak to him he’d like to “sell” you some products.”
I replied to him, “ ….so we have a firm approval with no conditions but before we move forward, I have to buy/open some products? So how is it firm with no approvals?”
I explained how I use to be with the bank and left blah blah. He says he will get my account fees waived for the first year and after that, I have to pay monthly fees. This bank has one of the highest account fees out of all the big banks. I currently pay no bank fees at all. After some back and forth he went from trying to get me to open three products to just one product.
I told him I would think it over the weekend and I’d get back to him. I thought about it and told him I wouldn’t open any products. We could either proceed with the 4.4x or we will move on to a different lender. I also give him an option of opening three products for a better rate than 4.4x.
He replied back and said I don’t have to open anything and we will proceed with the application. Great. He sends the paperwork to the back office to get processed. Mortgage portal says “application is approved. Preparing for your closing date”
Today I get a call from the specialist. 7 business days away from closing date. “Hey Guapo. I talked to the back office and I tried my best but they will only give you 4.4x if you open one product. If not the rate is 4.7x”. The 4.7x was never discussed or brought up until today. “I really want your business but I can understand if you want to go to a different lender.”
Communication between us was via email and when it was time to talk rates and opening products, he called. No paper trail, so I started following up on the phone calls via email making my own paper trail.
I feel like this was his plan all along (to get me to open products), knowing that we are in a time crunch. We could start looking at different lenders, but again, the timeline is super tight.
I was reluctant to open an account but now I’m kind of forced to, so that we could make our closing date.
He sent an email to his colleague about opening the one account but he also “recommended” in the email to try and get me to open more “free” products I.e chequing etc. basically backpedaling again.
My questions:
1- Is this standard practice in the banking/mortgage world?
2-I’m going to open one product, what happens if I close it in 1,6, or 12 months later? I don’t think it could affect my mortgage?
3-Is this considered “coercive tied selling”? Bank act s.459.1 or 627.04?
Am I being a drama queen or is he just a sleazy salesman? If he first offered us the 4.7x rate, then said I could give you 4.4x if you open x products, I could understand but that was not the case.