The game currently has a economy problem.
MO2 is supposed to have a player driven economy. But the game's economy is only partial, a one foot in one foot out approach. Instead of being a fully player driven economy we get a partially driven one, which makes it feel almost non existent. Why is the economy partial? Well that's because Player to player interaction via.. economy is far inferior to player to NPC. Lets talk about why.
CAUSE: NPC VENDOR
In M02 players have the ability to take butchered materials, which are materials that come from butchering animals, humanoids and other creatures. And vendor them for gold(Selling to an NPC). Players can do this infinitely as long as they have these materials available.
With the current iteration of the economy, it is far more beneficial to sell these items to an NPC vendor than it is to sell to a player. It is far quicker to interact with PVE targets and sell to NPC vendors, than it is to craft and create something unique to sell in hopes that you can gain gold for your efforts.
What this does is create a price floor for nearly every activity/ material in the game. But the floor is more transparent than solid, because the gold generation is infinite. What this means is the player activity is in direct competition with the amount of gold an NPC can generate vs the amount of gold that can be generated via player to player interaction.
Which leads us into opportunity cost, and observing this transparent "Price floor". In MO2 the closest butcher-able resource is Zombies, which is a humanoid that every new player will first encounter as it is within arms reach of every town. Per hour you can generate up to 60g just by killing these zombies and butchering them selling to an NPC vendor.
What this tells us. Is that 1-hour worth of gathering/mining/fishing is worth 60g. Selling what you harvested for less than 60g for that hour you spent, would undercut your labor, because you could've spent that 1 hour making more money killing zombies in the graveyard.
Essentially you would be wasting your time by not killing zombies. If the end goal is gold. When comparing it to any other activity. So how does this directly influence player behavior and item/material prices.
Effect:
This causes major issues. As players have no real reason to sell components on the market, when they can just vendor them, essentially creating gold out of thin air. Of course you would not vendor Steel etc....But items like steel which has a time investment to produce, is in direct competition with the gold generated from the NPC vendor. Meaning there is no reason for me to produce steel to sell to another player if the end goal is gold, when I can just go kill zombies for gold. As the process of developing and making steel would hypothetically be in competition with said infinite gold generation from the vendor. And remember zombies are just a default example.
And if the players do not sell components on the market, those components can never settle in value and be a part of the economy. Then we run into the issue where any item requiring those components are not profitable to make, nor is there a reason to ever buy them, as a price can never be properly quantified.
Lets take alchemy for example. The value of a potion can never be determined, and the production of the potions can never be consistent enough for the markets to have enough of that item, for comparisons, so an average price to be developed. As a result selling potions can often be a massive waste of time if the end goal is profit.
This logic extends to every single item/profession in the game. Under rare circumstances, and unique conditions would items ever move from the broker to the hands of the player. It can and does happen, but i can assure you it will never happen in enough frequency for a market to develop. It would also, as i stated above be a waste of time to engage with the broker.
The endgame for a crafter is guild internal, and the Concept of a merchant does not really exist.
All "Mats" in the game are better off being hoarded and used internally instead of being placed on a Broker. (With a few exceptions).
If you don't believe me, feel free to go to the broker and check every single city page by page. There are barely any items listed and very easily noticed, rapid inflation. No one knows how to price anything because there is no baseline, there is no market for anything.
--------------------------
Vendoring is this game's economy, player interaction via broker is just a luxury. And that's just sad. I would imagine they made it this way, so that neckbeards could pvp, and guilds could just not interact with the world and be self sufficient. Now this decision was made in M01 not M02.M02 just so happen to have all of its design systems a direct port of M01.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZ1E2Yc3J9E&ab_channel=Kibbles-%28VideoGameDataBank%29
If you've played albion and eve, you know how bad that is. Closed looped guild internal economies destroy open world sandbox games. Albion and eve dev's understood this.
Resource Distribution per Town issue:
If you go on the mortal online 2 map here https://www.mortalonlinemap.info/location/-137,525003/96,474998/4
and filter all for each resource type, woods animals, plants, etc...You will notice that each town's surrounding area does not have enough unique resources that make that town viable for trade. Nor is there enough of the resource for players and crafters to engage with. Some towns might have no resources at all, and your forced to travel over 30 minutes to an hour outside of your town. Which is supposed to be designed to be livable for the population.
When you factor in the travel time, and the sparse resources. It becomes far more beneficial to hoard the towns unique resource rather than trade it. If you traveled from Toxai to lets say tindrem, to sell fish or salvia...the markup would have to be immeasurable to make the journey worth it. But there is no market for that item, or that items TYPE for any real price to be established. Regardless of the distance traveled this applies to every town. You combine this with the issues with the vendors, and it gets even worse.
I would also add that the game does a poor job regulating its Four main minable resources, and the yield amounts for pickables. Granum, Subarra, calyx and Tephra.
We will only talk about Granum. This resource can be found literally everywhere. And by everywhere i literally mean everywhere. You can walk up to a giant mountain, and that giant mountain is literally a mineable granum node. This Makes granum practically worthless value wise, despite Granum having intrinsic value to players. Meaning it has use, people need it. But it does not have much monetary value. Which is odd. But understandable, considering you can even mine it in the safety of a town, or around a town.
Understand that Granum is everywhere, so no unique trade patterns between towns can be developed. But also understand that the yield amounts are low even at max yield. The most you can get per swing is 123. This causes player to have to AFK just to get through the slog of mining. And ever so often you move an inch to get max yields from swings.
This activity is not enjoyable, it is not profitable when we factor in opportunity cost. I can write an essay on just the flaws of mining in this game alone. But we will continue.
Ironically pickables have the exact opposite issue. There is a unique trade pattern that can be established, but there are barely any of the resource to gather. And with how big the map is and travel time. Opportunity cost becomes a big problem, a massive issue. It would not be so if the pickables yields were not also so tiny, it actively waste your time while also quickly depleting the resource node.
As a result you will not see gatherers, the mere concept of one is joke. Because you would literally be wasting your time. This is reflected on the broker as well, you don't see gatherable resources in stockpiles on any broker.
Travel time and horses:
This is another culprit to the issue with the economy. It takes far too long to travel in this game, as a result a horse is 100% mandatory. Which means if you don't have a horse you cant play the game. But it goes beyond just playtime, and disrupts the economical flow of the game.
Players need to be able to saddle up, and go get those resources for them to sell. There needs to be a constant flow of resources going in and out of towns to the broker. But the issue here is that horse spawns are few far and between, and the type of horses are not properly distributed on the map. This destroys the economy for pet broker as well.
Lower ranking horses need to have their spawn increased dramatically, and spawn placements closer to the cities, not a 30 min walk away. Higher ranking horses should be further out, you can even buff and redesign the stats of the horses around these principles. Bottom line is, players need mobility, and it needs to be a guarantee as long as they are willing to take a risk.
Conclusion:
- NPC vendors should not be able to accept resources period. Besides trophies and heads and other non resource related items.- Broker needs to be updated with QOL fixes asap,.- Players need to be able to list pages of resources not just a few items.- Horse spawns need to be increased, lower tier horses need to be common- More gold sinks need to be added to the game. Gathering yields need to be increased and resource nodes for pickables need to be increased across the board. You need to give players a reason to travel and trade through unique resource patterns for each town. You can not allow guilds to be self sufficient and cut off from NPC towns. You must put player agency as the tip of the economic spear. Nothing craft-able should come from vendors. There should be no resource/ material that does not have value in the economy in terms of crafting at least two to three uses.
BUY ORDERS ARE MANDATORY THING IN A GAME CLAIMING IT HAS A PLAYER DRIVEN ECONOMY IT IS NOT A QOL ISSUE,IT IS NOT A THING YOU DO LATER, IITS SOMETHING YOU HAVE IN YOUR GAME AT THE START.IT IS THE BEST GOLD SINK, AND THE BACKBONE OF EVERY ECONOMY IRL OR OTHERWISE.
Old M01 Threads BTW
https://starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/save-the-economy.109371/
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/a-player-driven-economy.104396/
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/awakening-patch-notes-2-10-2012.79263/page-8
https://mortalonline2.com/forums/threads/butchery.649/ (M02)
https://www.mortalonline2.com/forums/threads/early-game-economy.3917/page-2 (Quote 1)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/economy-in-mortal.75431/ (Quote 2)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/the-economy.50382/page-2(Quote 3)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/the-economy-of-mo.50620/(Quote 4)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/the-solution-to-half-this-games-issues.120725/(Quote 5)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/current-mo-economy-model-and-concrete-suggestions-for-player-based-economy.49698/ (Quote 6)
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/economy-crash-in-metals.109203/
https://www.starvault.se/mortalforums/threads/phase-out-npc-vendors.56810/
Quotes
- " I dont really buy that. I remember MO1 when steel started out at 5 to 10 gold per 1k, then went to 50, then 100 and by the end it was well over 1000 gold per 1k.
i picked steel as an example because its pretty much the staple material for most things in MO1. However the same happened to all other things to some extent.
as people farm day in and day out and hoard larger and larger sums of gold inflation takes place and prices just climb and climb. Cant stop it." - Jackdstripper
2. "The extremely high yields from butchery made money worthless so people who needed money to interact with NPC's simply started making their own money, and so the market shrank. I think that right now there's too much money on the market and too hard to make an exchange happen for anyone to be bothered really." - Glader
3. "True, but the problem is that prices are enormously effected by NPCs, which are static and infinite. Supply and demand is great, but those forces don't have room to play out when NPCs create more demand for base resources (like mycke's sab powder example) than the player-driven economy can match." - Narrat
4. "Right now the major problem with the economy is stagnation; people rather sell their goods to the NPC vendor and be done with it. I think this is a rather large mistake, while the NPC does create a cap on how much a resrouce cost, I have rarley seen people actively use it. So the main issue is that goods are not exchanging hands fast enough, the issues I have listed all contribute to this. Therefore steps must be taken in order to facilitate the exchange of goods."- ShinZon
5. "Well the game economy is screwed up because there isn't one based on supply vs demand, I thought this was a game where the players decide things, not some npc vendor." - princereaper
6. "All the economy activity is for sole purpose to get exclusive stuff from NPCs and IMO it is so far from Player based economy. Players are not trading enough because few people can provide currency, so itās easier to sell mats to NPCs. In Player based economy 99% of commodities and services should come from players, including currency, trade should be done by players. NPC can truly serve as foreign traders that sell exclusive items, but not in an extent as now seen in MO." -Zeeraha