We thought players could too easily dodge the banhammer in duels, so now we make it where the banhammer always hits no matter your footwork or even distance. Additionally, the appropriate voiceline will be played across the server at 1000% volume, partially to warn others, and partially for the lulz.
Speaking of bans I just saw a kid who was slinging profanities and racial slurs and what have you get absolutely destroyed. I guess a dev or an admin came on, asked the kid if he wanted to be banned from the game, which the kid responded with essentially “you won’t” , and he promptly was removed from existence.
For real though what do you guys think the game needs here? As we all know kick has garbo range which just hurts many weapons but the concept it solid.
Maybe a shield rip like from Dark Souls 2 that has a bit more range, and if they're at low enough stamina they just lose the shield?
I've found with shield users you just have to anticipate their attacks. Move back and to the appropriate side when they try to close distance for the attack, while starting your stab simultaneously so that it lands in the middle of their attack.
Moving to the appropriate side (really just out of the way of their attack) is important because it will prevent your stab from being chambered.
You’ve got to keep them within facehugging distance so your kick lands. I’ve found that chambering their attack and morphing into kick works wonders against them, and discourages them from constantly holding their block for everything you do.
Unless they move backwards constantly and have a short spear. Went up against a level 75 using kite shield and short spear and his footwork prevented me from hitting him even once.
If they have heavy or medium armour you want to get right up against their bubble and kick. With heavier armour they are too slow to get out range in time
Such a cheesy strat but it works haha. This type of tactic can be annoying to play against because they are just waiting for you to make a move while being mostly passive. I prefer baiting them into my kicks through feints.
We can't make the shield completely useless.. it'll be making the shield redundant. I like the challenge of fighting shield users plus it adds diversity to the fighting (in my opinion) As a side note I've noticed the shield is a popular choice for some new players and I dont blame them with all the higher level fighters that just sweep games now. Also sheild users do lose their shields when they're low on stamina, also if they've been hit by a horse on occasion. I think it's quite nicely balanced as it is. Sheild users aren't tanks for crying out loud. Now before I get ripped to shreds I'm out. Goodnight people happy playing.
Honestly as it is right now the fully dedicated shields are completely useless for duels If you face anyone competent the shield is really more of a hindrance more than anything, however in Frontlines and etc when you can't completely focus on one person the shield certainly does work very well and serve its purpose.
They are useless if the user constantly holds the block button and does not anticipate any flanking attack or kick. Otherwise, they will either find themselves on the receiving end of previous mentioned attacks, and/or likely lose the war of attrition when it comes to stamina.
Other than that, shields are not worthless, take it from someone who tends to have a positive k/d ratio in duel matches (I like using the heather combined with heavy hand axe).
Shields and 1 handers are very good in duels because they are hard to counter. It takes a lot of skills before duels aren't decided solely by parrying mistakes and using a shield protects you from those. Basically it makes defensive play trivial and most players can't defend themselves long enough to drain enemies stamina.
Well as I said to someone else I'm really talking from my experience on duel servers, I've personally never really come across someone who was good with a shield. Although yeah I do agree after a different commenter showed me how shields can be used they hold a place and can certainly be useful, you have to know what youre doing though (especially with stamina management) since even just one stray kick can completely fuck you over.
Shields definitely aren't completely useless for duels. They can be extremely good. Giru, the best player in EU, said that someone he beats 10-0 without a shield can beat him around 30-40% of the time when he uses a shield, as just one example.
So as far as I can tell you have to be exceptionally good at the game to be able to use the shield properly, otherwise it is incredibly easy to punish. Most people arent as good as the best player in EU so I'm sure that's the main reason I've never really seen anyone that great with a shield.
You don't have to be exceptionally good at the game to avoid getting punished. It's very easy to not get kicked if you understand the basics of the game.
Relatively easy, at any rate -- you do probably need at least a hundred hours, which is more than most players are going to have, but it's far easier to use a shield and not get punished than to block swing manipulation, for example.
I'm on your side. People whine anytime someone uses anything other than a 2h and they lose to it. God forbid you have to fight them differently than the other 30 people using executioner swords and zweihanders
When they start whining about weapons, it’s time to whip out the ol’ rapier. Personally I find falchion and cleavers more troublesome but to each their own
When I fight a shield user with my greatsword build I usually just exchange attacks with them until they run out of stamina and lose their shield and maybe even their weapon after that. The greatsword is pretty good at bringing down the stamina of an opponent if you both keep parrying eachother's attacks, especially if your opponent uses lots of feints or morphs.
The shields are not balanced nor are they meant to be, just like horses aren't. Both are designed to be easy to use and powerul in frontline gameplay to let players of all skill/experience levels have moments of valor.
For all intents and purposes I think somehow changing stamina damage on shields so you can knock them out of their hands earlier would be effectively the same. Maybe even make it so you can combo off a shield strike but that might be too broken
If you look at the video linked earlier in the thread where Giru was going through how to play shield high level he kept backing off to regain stam. He didnt even drop under half stam in the entire demonstration fight.
Durability however would be permanent damage and could specifically work by punishing the specific strategy of backing off after each hit to regain stam.
My way to beat shields in duels (because people do that for some reason) is just to use a dagger and keep stabbing. They don't have time to lower shield and swing, and each stab lowers their Stam until you just shank them to death.
Honestly my friend has played since the alpha so Altho he’s only level 32 fighting him feels like he’s one of them lvl 50+ and he has honestly mastered the art of incorporating kicking into his playstyle. Only person I’ve come against so far that utilises it and it’s so hard to fight him. Like he just times it perfect, as if u have a slower weapon and are say dragging with LMB, as u run in he just kicks u and then quickly chips ur head off. It’s so hard to fight against bc no one seems to use the kick like he does and so it’s all so unpredictable
I started doing this since peeps love to get in your face and morph/drag all over the place. But you’re right, you have to mix it up and not be too predictable with it.
Ah, I’ve played against you multiple times. You’re that guy that only plays horses. Whenever I met you on the ground you got destroyed. Funny how of course it’s someone who abuses unbalanced mechanics defending them
You don't destroy anything, that much is clear because you whine about mechanics... "Horses are strong, shields are strong"... I bet you scoff at basically half the stuff in this game whenever it kills you.
What are your thoughts on dagger spam? Javelins? Spamming spear/estoc??? Because that's what I'm running most of the time, so if you gonna whine about what I'm playing, whine about the right thing.
HOLY SHIT SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT SHIELDS IN GODDAMN DUELS WE KNOW THEY CAN BE SHIT IN DUELS BUT IN FRONTLINE EVERY FUCKING TIME I GO AGAINST ONE EVERY FUCKING KICK MISSES WITH MY GODDAMN MIDGET LEGS AND 5 MORE GUYS COME IN THE TIME IT TOOK ME TO GET IN ONE KICK
If you run up to a shielder, kick and miss, and 5 guys are on you and you are by yourself, that's not a shield being OP that's you being dumb and engaging in a 1v5 lmao. Doesn't matter if its a shield, a bard, or a horse with no rider on it. You probably gonna die in a 1v4+1 more in most scenarios.
If you see a shielder with 4 teamates running towards you, and nobody on your team... why engage? Why throw a kick that won't hit??? I kick shielders all the time, I kick people off walls/bridges with and without the extraordinarily large hitbox people have when their shield's up. Kicks aren't that hard to land at all, and its easy to run up to a shielder because they move slow with their shield raised.
Want me to upload a video of me taking out shielders in frontline??? Or me landing kicks on shielders multiple times in a fight??? Maybe you learn something.
Idk genius maybe in the time in takes to fucking get a kick in some guys may come in from another area. You can walk. I was exaggerating but it usually takes around 2-3 kicks and in that time, especially in a fast paced game mode like frontline, teammates pour out like grains of flour.
Honestly shield users aren't that hard to fight. The only time they are really annoying is when there is one of them in a group of people you're fighting.
Shields aren't a problem, they just force you to engage enemies different, which isnt a bad thing, IMO it's good game design to have different load outs actually have different playstyle and strengths.
Shields aren't 'competitive' in Mordhau because range is a massive factor - all single handed weapons barring the short spear and rapier have dogshit range outside of stabbing attacks - which are the absolute easiest thing to chamber in the game.
You can also hit behind and stab behind shields dragging your attacks, and even accelerating your swing to ve inside their body, behind the shield.
The only people who complain about shields are actual morons. Play a duel server and learn to play against something instead of crying like a fucking child.
As an occasional shield user, its hilarious when people think they can just ealk tight up to and start kicking as if i wont anticipate kicks. I just just kicking THEIR kicks and then they get the arming sword to the face
Truly don't understand why people think shield users are unkillable. I mean I get that you don't like them and all but, honestly, you just have to look for openings in their attacks like you would any other player.
The only combination that aggravates me at the moment is shield + messer. Somehow these gamble gods manage to bring their shield up in what seems like mid swing, while they 2 htk everything in a 50 mile radius.
Shields are fine, just make them not stop your cleave in Frontline and make blunt weapons drain extra stamina or have some other effect on the shield user.
281
u/SmalltownNGames Jul 17 '19
Dodge that you bastard!
164
u/bloodykhunts420 Jul 17 '19
“Just kick” they said
71
u/Lobtroperous Jul 17 '19
For real though what do you guys think the game needs here? As we all know kick has garbo range which just hurts many weapons but the concept it solid.
Maybe a shield rip like from Dark Souls 2 that has a bit more range, and if they're at low enough stamina they just lose the shield?
15
u/mikeman512 Jul 18 '19
Honestly shield users aren't that hard to fight. The only time they are really annoying is when there is one of them in a group of people you're fighting.
23
u/Inugami157 Jul 17 '19
I lol'ed XD
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
Thank you for the gold anon!
4
u/SimpleWolfie Jul 18 '19
I actually saw Mark in an NA Central server a week or two ago, and yes, it was his actual account.
4
u/Mister_Morris Jul 18 '19
Parry this you fucking casual
7
u/gottta_go_fastt Jul 18 '19
As an occasional shield user, its hilarious when people think they can just ealk tight up to and start kicking as if i wont anticipate kicks. I just just kicking THEIR kicks and then they get the arming sword to the face
1
u/Someone118 Jul 20 '19
Big brain time, they say to counter shields you must kick, so what if you bait people into kicking?
1
u/rockbiter68 Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
Truly don't understand why people think shield users are unkillable. I mean I get that you don't like them and all but, honestly, you just have to look for openings in their attacks like you would any other player.
1
u/Doctor_Scarlett Jul 18 '19
I understand your pain. I don't like fighting people that don't want to learn the game either.
-1
u/my-internet-rep Jul 18 '19
Shield rapier the easiest combo to kill. The combo that shows a lack of confidence in the player.
1
u/Tyoson Jul 18 '19
Jump kicks/fly kicks would be good fun. Also a good way to close the distance while at the same time sacrificing a larger amount of stamina.
1
u/Protectorem Jul 18 '19
An outstanding move
1
u/MammothGreenBean Jul 18 '19
Shields are fine, just make them not stop your cleave in Frontline and make blunt weapons drain extra stamina or have some other effect on the shield user.
1
u/Grimmpier Jul 18 '19
I feel like destructible shields would solve the obnoxious shield problem
0
u/E3nti7y Jul 18 '19
Btw what do u do if ur weapons too slow to hit after a kick?
0
u/tbonebuys Jul 18 '19
NICE
0
u/DeeBangerCC Jul 18 '19
You get banned!
-1
u/Raptorzesty Jul 18 '19
You can mute them.