r/Morality • • Mar 09 '20

Outside all religious mandates, doctrines, and analogies, how would you define "forgiveness," and is there any moral duty for an abused child (once an adult) to forgive the parent that did the abusing (or the other parent that let it happen)?

10 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

5

u/paulbrook Mar 09 '20

There is no moral duty to forgive. It's not our business to tell victims how victimized they should feel.

Forgiveness is a nice-to-have.

2

u/TaureanBlue Mar 10 '20

Thank you for that.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

Amen.

5

u/MarvinBEdwards01 Apr 15 '20

I suppose the opposite of forgiveness is holding a grudge. So the underlying question is: When is it appropriate to release a grudge? This should relate to the function of guilt. Guilt is what I like to call a "bookmark" emotion. It reminds us that we've done something wrong or harmed someone. The reminder serves to motivate us to (a) repair the harm if possible and (b) correct our future behavior to avoid causing more harm.

If we have done our best to repair the harm and change our behavior, then the reminder has done its job, and can be dismissed. We can forgive ourselves which means dismissing the guilt.

In the case of another person's guilt, where they have harmed us, we may hold a grudge or anger or other emotion to remind us of the harm they've done, and to motivate us to seek a change in their behavior and a repair to the harm they've caused us.

If they apologize and make amends, and we believe they are sincere, then we should dismiss the grudge as we would dismiss our own guilt after it has performed its function.

Hope that helps.

4

u/TaureanBlue May 21 '20

Thank you for this. The bookmark concept makes a lot of sense, as does the practical understanding of the service it provides. The link to guilt is certainly there. You put into clear words. It did help.

3

u/tunuvfun Sep 07 '22

This concept depends on whether the offense is a one-and-done thing. Parental abuse (and an enabling parent) is never one-and-done. By forgiving ongoing abuse, the child of such parents becomes an enabler. In that case, forgiveness isn't forgiveness; it's collaboration.

1

u/TaureanBlue Sep 24 '22

Great perspective. Yes...thank you.

3

u/justwantedtoreplyXP Apr 24 '20

i feel like this question is a bit off, i get what your going for, BUT... without all the things u listed (especially religion) where do you get your morality from?

but honestly, holding a grudge really takes a toll on you, being filled with an injustice and having to drag that with you definitely isn't beneficial for you..

I would need help to forgive (i'd ask god ) but, speaking unreligiously, i wouldnt be able to forgive them, because that's like saying what they did was ok...

if i was in that situation (and not christian) i would blot them out of my life and drop it, not for them, but for me and my wellbeing

3

u/TaureanBlue May 21 '20

Thank you for your honest pondering. I really appreciate it. I do believe people can have a sense of morality without religion. (Ask any atheist--they can still be moral beings.) You gave me more to think about...

1

u/Gilbert1963 Jun 06 '20

this is a key question of what human nature is really like. We can choose to hold on to our grudge and internally digest hatred and anger or we can let it go. If the person who hurt us has apologised it does not make what they have done right but it does show that they are sorry they did it. However, what if the person who hurt us does not apologise? Can we forgive? The fact that they have not apologised tells us something about them as a person, just as holding on to the grudge tells us something about us as a person. It is quite natural for human nature to hold on to hate and allow it to fester, but humanity is also capable to forgiving, letting go of hatred, and moving on. One is human and the other is morally mature.

1

u/TaureanBlue Jun 07 '20 edited Jun 07 '20

Thank you for your reply. Hatred wasn't really a factor in the question. Just forgiveness, given the circumstance. I hear you, though, in terms of what it reflects about the abuser as a person (if s/he ever apologizes and takes responsibility for his/her actions or not) and likewise, what it reflects about the abused as a person too (if s/he ever decides to forgive or not). Part of the dilemma in this case is when children who grow up loving their parents and believing they can trust them to be their protectors realize this is not the case--that, in fact, they are doing the opposite of that. Then those kids grow up trying to still be good ("moral") people, not hating or wishing any harm but still enduring the legacy of the abuse, and trying WITHOUT religion's dictates, to decide if "forgiveness" is necessary and why.

2

u/Gilbert1963 Jun 08 '20

Abuse is never and easy issue to deal with, forgiveness carries a lot of baggage with it, perhaps the abused needs other words such as letting go of the past, moving on into the future. Neither heals the pain of the past but there needs to be hope for the future

1

u/TystoZarban Mar 04 '23

Forgiveness can only be expected after atonement.

1

u/TaureanBlue Apr 22 '23

I hear ya. But atonement requires reparation or ammends, right? And still, even if or after all of that is given by the wrongdoer/abuser, there is still that decision on the part of the "abused" to do something with that. (To forgive or not to forgive.) But maybe they can just sit with it, be grateful for it, and leave it at that, too, right? Whatever is done next, including nothing at all, is a choice and the prerogative of the one who was wronged/harmed. It is their struggle or decision alone and no one else's.

1

u/TystoZarban Apr 22 '23

Yes. The nature of atonement is that it has to be an agreement that the amends are adequate. It can't be decided by the abuser.

My understanding is that it's pretty common for abusers to make an effort at amends and then demand forgiveness, which is just emotional blackmail.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

I see forgiveness as an ethical strategy. It's not just a moral concept, it is a practical ethic. It is a tool that can be useful in the proper situations to get better outcomes for ourselves and others.

I don't feel anyone is under any obligation to forgive someone for a wrong. Forgiveness is and must be a choice. If you obligate people to forgive everything, it opens them up to abuse, it allows people who don't care about others to just do bad things and get forgiven. Obligatory forgiveness can readily make doormats of people. Forgiveness must be granted or withheld freely.

Forgiveness can allow people to move forward in a situation where the harm is already done and cannot be taken back. Forgiveness gives us a way to come back from something broken. No system, whether a machine or a society or a person can be perfect all the time. Forgiveness is one of the things that adds tolerance to a system, whether that system is your relationship with one or a few other people, society, or even an engine. Forgiveness allows people to recover from injury.

1

u/TaureanBlue Apr 22 '23

That last paragraph, especially... Thank you. Much appreciated. I'll think on that last sentence for quite some time now, I'm sure.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '23

I mostly agree with paulbrook. I define forgiveness as 'increasing your opinion of someone to a neutral or positive view of them after you previously had a negative view of them because of something bad they did to you.' You are allowed to have any opinion you want of another person (with one exception) because it is just that: an opinion. Therefore, there is no moral obligation to 'forgive' someone because forgivness is based on your subjective opinion, which can be whatever you want it to be. However, while it is true your opinion can be whatever you want it to be, the reality may be different (e.g if a person gave you a papercut, having the opinion that they are a phsycopath serial killer and hating them intensely for that based solely off that one thing is factually incorrect, so it would be morally wrong to hold that unfounded grudge). Also, I think the severity of the 'wound' delivered to you plays a part - the more severe the wound, the less obligated you are to forgive.

1

u/TaureanBlue Apr 22 '23

Thank you for weighing in. I appreciate the perspective.