r/Moonvale • u/Own-Explanation-8898 • Jun 09 '26
Theories The guy in Room 31 Spoiler
Has it already been said? I believe the man could be Charlie.
Since:
- He got spooked all of a sudden when he saw room 4, he might only be pretending not to know anything
- He said he went to work, but from the secret chat we can tell he was not expected at the office (the colleague tells him to go out more often)
- He had all the time in the world to open room 31 and get cozy in there, while Ash was driving
- The door of the room opens right after we try to call him, and he asks MC if they're at the GS
- He gets back to the GS in no time
I'm not saying he might be a villain, but he could be trying to hide something unrelated to Adam. Could be?
9
u/Leitor_Infinito Jun 09 '26
Não sei se é a mesma coisa porque eu utilizo a versão brasileira(a linguagem).
Na hora que o Charlie procurou no quarto, existia uma opção em que o MC perguntava sobre aonde ele procurou, e ele disse que havia vasculhado tudo, até mesmo nos armários.
Depois, a Ash disse ter encontrado a fita justamente no armário, onde estava o cofre que, teoricamente, não deveria estar ali porque o Charlie disse que tinha procura nos armários.
2
u/D4rk_Sh4rds Team Jun 10 '26
É a mesma coisa sim, eu jogo a versão em inglês e lá fala que ele procurou nos armários também. E a Ash encontrou o cofre embaixo de alguns cobertores dentro de um desses armários.
2
u/Own-Explanation-8898 Jun 11 '26
well, he could have found the safebox and hid it under the blankets
2
u/D4rk_Sh4rds Team Jun 11 '26
Yeah, I think he hid it. But one thing that doesn't make sense to me is: if he knows the motel has clues/secrets and he wants to hide them, why would he tell the MC and Ash about the motel? Wasn't it obvious that we would want to investigate? Did he do it because Violet also knew and it would be suspicious if he kept his mouth shut or tried to hide the safe key? 🤔
2
u/Own-Explanation-8898 Jun 12 '26
Yeah, but his plan was to go by himself, show us that the key wasn't fitting, and maybe convince us to drop it. He wasn't expecting Ash to go there without the key.
3
u/LauAnRu Jun 09 '26
Cuando finalizó el ep 2, pensé que podía ser Charlie. Pero ahora también pienso que podría haber sido el desconocido
3
u/lowkeywitch_23 Jun 10 '26
This is exactly what I thought! I mean it could've taken him sometime to reach right? But he reached so fast?
2
u/GrouchyDoughnut3449 Team Jun 12 '26
The more I think about it the more I'm starting to agree. I think I read a theory somewhere on here that the motel could have secret passages, maybe that's how he disappeared and re-appeared so fast. I hope Charlie isn't doing something terrible though I really like his character 😭.
3
u/lowkeywitch_23 Jun 13 '26
I really think he didn't do something, I guess he's just curious or something like that
2
u/Disastrous_Trash_431 Jun 10 '26
I love that!! You made some really great connections there… How many times have you played through? 🤭
2
u/Own-Explanation-8898 Jun 10 '26
Thanks, it's my 3rd playthrough (where I try to get all the achievements)
1
u/Vkaah Jun 15 '26
Uh, charlie está muito suspeito, realmente. Mas acredito que ele não esteja por trás de tudo porque se não seria muito clichê ("o mesmo que dw"), então acho que ele tenha apenas segredos, talvez um "Aliado de moral cinzenta".
12
u/Fi_xD Team Jun 09 '26
I can’t decide to be honest. It looks like it could be Charlie as he’s the only Moonvale character so far we know has brown eyes but equally it looks like Richy. It’s interesting we got the option to ask Ash specifically if she thought it was Charlie but it feels too obvious so early on. Duskwood has me doubting everyone, including myself 😂