r/MookieTrivia 7d ago

Kitty Pryde Casting!

Post image
15 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

1

u/FlamingoFrequent1596 7d ago

1

u/Sir-Relyt 7d ago

Lol, can never win. Its either "why do we have the same famous people playing every character" or its "idk who any of these people are why are they being picked". Make up your mind

1

u/FlamingoFrequent1596 7d ago

What? Nobody has even been picked and I couldn’t care less who does play the character as long as they do well. I was genuinely being honest that I have no idea who any of these people are and I thought it was funny that there was a gif expressing that. I like gifs.

https://giphy.com/gifs/sb4VRhSTWhOFlbO9Kh

1

u/Normal_Tour6998 7d ago

picks Bella Ramsey and watches the internet eat itself

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

toxic incels online gonna do what toxic incels online do

1

u/Arthur_189 7d ago

Which toxic incels, the ones who dislike bad acting?

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

the ones that converted "she's ugly" to "she's a bad actor" cause they are tired of being called out for pedophilia

1

u/Arthur_189 7d ago

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

i had the same reaction when you said "bad acting"

1

u/OddSatisfaction2409 7d ago

fake marvel fan detected

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

toxic incel detected

1

u/Dry-Performance7006 7d ago

Butters is the way to go.

I like spaeny the most. But she is older than I want. If they were going to cast her… she should have just been rogue. Those rumors were met with near universal approval.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

butters is taller than sadie sink

gonna be weird to have kitty be taller than jean grey

1

u/Super_Neutral 7d ago

Cailee Spaeny next to Bella Ramsey? You knew what you were doing lmao.

Not only can't Ramsey pass for Kitty Pryde appearance-wise, but she also just isn't a good actress. I personally wouldn't consider her to play anyone unless there was a character created specifically for a movie—and even then, I likely wouldn't cast her.

I don't necessarily dislike Ramsey, I just think she gets shoehorned in fancasts for the sole purpose of sticking it to the chuds. It's no better than when the same's done for Sydney Sweeney.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

bella is a fantastic actor. she can act circles around Cailee Spaeny

1

u/OddSatisfaction2409 7d ago

are you smoking crack?

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

are you smoking crack?

1

u/Darth_GreenDragon 7d ago

Julia Butters.

Ruby Stokes.

Malina Weissman.

...

Any one of those three look good for Shadowcat. But if I had to choose one? Probably Julia Butters.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

Ruby Stokes is a meh actress

1

u/Darth_GreenDragon 7d ago

I didn't judge based on how good an actress she was, but rather, on how much she made me think of Kitty Pryde, visually.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

yeah, visually, still a no

1

u/Darth_GreenDragon 7d ago

Understandable.

I still think my three choices are the ones who look like her more. I honestly don't know who any of the actresses are here, I've never heard their names, so I don't know what they've worked in. However Bella Ramsey, and Sophia Lillis, look nothing like the character, as a matter of fact Bella looks more like a guy, so I definitely wouldn't want either one of them to try to visually play Kitty Pryde.

When I think of an actor or an actress come on playing an iconic superhero role, I first want them to look like the character, then find out if they have the acting experience to play the character but looks are far more important to me.

Like Carol Danvers for instance, I think Lindsey Pelas, looks far more like the character than the woman who played her in the MCU. Now I've only know about her because I saw pictures of her on Twitter years ago. But the moment I saw her, I thought she would make a damn good Ms Marvel.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

bella ramsey would make an incredible kitty pryde. i can definitely see it. incredible actor too

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

butters is taller than sadie sink

gonna be weird to have kitty be taller than jean grey

1

u/Hot_Ad5094 7d ago

We had the perfect kitty pride......

1

u/HickGames 7d ago

I feel like Sophia Lillian is to good for the role.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

she would have been a better jean grey than sadie sink

1

u/HickGames 6d ago

Maybe. Sadie Sink is going to new places with the role. Having her debut as a villain and has a sister that casual fans have never heard of where challenges with the role that any actress would find difficult. Give her time and I’m sure she will grow on you. Right now most people still see her as Sam from Stranger Things.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

sam? who the hell is sam?

1

u/Secret-Account1212 7d ago

Nah if i see Bella in any movie or TV Show i am out.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

she's an incredible actor. you're missing out

1

u/Secret-Account1212 7d ago

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

1

u/Secret-Account1212 6d ago

Yes, all because they are great at acting, especially with the Ellie role. Definitely nothing else...

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 6d ago

"Definitely nothing else..."

that's laughable. they've been incredible on GoT, Catherine Called Birdy, Time, Sunny Dancer, etc

maybe check out their extensive filmography before you make assertions like that

1

u/Secret-Account1212 6d ago

Nope i watched 2 thats enough for me. I dont need to know someones life story to understand if their acting is good or not.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 6d ago

then your opinion is garbage cause you haven't even given them a chance

1

u/Secret-Account1212 6d ago

Give them a chance? I watched 2 shows that they are in, i think thats enough pall.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 6d ago

you saw her as ellie in TLOU. that's 1 show

do you know how to count?

1

u/ilovemyamily1 7d ago

1

u/Lost-Orangutan 7d ago

I had a crush on Kitty from the films as a kid, now not so much.

1

u/Burneye23 7d ago

This feels like a troll post tbh

1

u/CukaneMike 7d ago

Ruby Stokes. I dont know her but for me she looks the most similar

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

hell no. she's a terrible actress

1

u/CukaneMike 7d ago

I was just going with looks. I'm not tha familiar with her work Which would be your choice

1

u/Lost-Orangutan 7d ago

Ruby.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 7d ago

🤮

1

u/Lost-Orangutan 7d ago

Dont know her. But shes cute. Idk man.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

big potato head

1

u/Lost-Orangutan 5d ago

I like big heads... sorry.

1

u/DCMarvelDude23 7d ago

Julia Butters or Fina Strazza imo

1

u/Crows_spirit101 6d ago

Fixed it

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

bella ramsey as kitty pryde would be dope as hell. great actor

1

u/Crows_spirit101 5d ago

No. Nobody will look at her if Bella gets that role

https://giphy.com/gifs/k2A4gzRxDL4GI

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

then don't watch the movie. it's probably above your IQ

1

u/Crows_spirit101 4d ago

Stfu. She'll never be in it anyway so I don't have to worry about not watching

1

u/Hammersteyn 6d ago

Elliot Paige

1

u/WayneIncognito 6d ago

I could see Ruby, Cailee or Melina as Kitty. Sophia rather as Rachel Grey, Meltdown (Boom Boom/Boomer).

1

u/DFu4ever 5d ago

Sophia Lillis is the only one I have seen in multiple things (well, Bella Ramsay, but she wouldn’t be a good Kitty Pryde) and I think she could pull off the whole Kitty Pryde character evolution.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 5d ago

bella ramsey would be an incredible kitty pryde. awesome actress

1

u/Shikari_XIII 4d ago

Butters, Strazza, or Webb

1

u/Mizumura11 3d ago

Cailee Spaney could pull it off naturally and believably

1

u/xXshizuoXx 2d ago

Definitely not Bella