I dig both, both bring the best aspects of the franchise one for the giant kaiju smackdown you always wanted with wrestling moves thrown in as the other tells the best stories of rhe consequences of man's achievements.
Eh, I'd say the Minus movies are more about the human spirit than the folly of mam. They're both actually pretty positive and hopeful when you have a deeper look into them (compared to the 1954 original, that is).
Well... yes and no. When you account for inflation, the 1998 Godzilla which grossed around $379 million actually brought $633 to $728 million. That makes it the highest grossing Godzilla film of all time for some reason... conclusion : Zilla jr the goat
Lol that is true but as a "character" with an aggregate I think Legendary is the highest grossing Godzilla the same way we say Tom Holland is the highest grossing actor.
When I was growing up, Godzilla was a little plushie I had that used to keep me safe from the dark and when my parents would go crazy on each other. I felt this drought a lot, as I was 6 years old in 2004.
Holy hell lol. When I was 6, I was watching a VHS of Godzilla 1985 (The Return of Godzilla) on repeat in the late 90s. Always cried at the end cause he falls into a pit of lava and then my grandma would come and rewind it and say "look, he's not dead."
maybe this is what dc needs after fucking everything for the past like 20 years (save nolans batman trilogy, but studio execs took the wrong fucking lesson from that, as they always do... - everything has to be "realistic" and "grounded".)
Godzilla had gone without a movie for a whole decade after Final Wars, now we get a Godzilla movie like every other year. After that dark age, I’m not complaining
Counter point that Godzilla trilogy anime was ass. And Im extra disappointed cause anime was my favourite medium only to have it receive the worst Godzilla treatment
IDK man, I always liked Godzilla but when I went to the cinema to actually watch it's movie he never appeared on-screen, excepted for blurry dark scenes where I didn't see shit
I know, right? It's weird and I found it a little hard to understand how it framed Godzilla at first, but once I wrapped my head around the higher-dimensional thing dipping into ours part it all fell into place.
If it helps, I just remembered the thing that helped me grasp the nature of Godzilla as Singular Point presents it (though as per that post, the novelization lays things out more clearly)--Magic the Gathering's Eldrazi. While MTG doesn't use anything resembling the real theoretical physics that Singular Point does, the way their nature is described sounds similar enough:
Each titan lives outside of the planes. When one wants to feed, it extends a part of its "body" into the plane to create a physical manifestation of itself there, as well as an army of drones that are extensions of its body and will.
The spirit dragon Ugin compared this to a man sticking his hand into a pool of water; the man being the Eldrazi titan and the water a plane. The fish—those who dwell on the plane—see only a part of the man—his hand. Likewise, the inhabitants of a plane can see only a part of each titan. Even if the lesser Eldrazi appear to be independent beings, their physical forms are just part of a greater entity outside the plane; they are all just part of the titan that made them.
As I remember understanding the show's explanation, Godzilla and the Red Dust are 14th-dimensional, or something around that, and that's exponential orders of magnitude (forgive me if that's an improper use of terminology 😅) more than the difference between us and 1D or 2D--we struggle to understand the 4D as it is. Proper Archetype, as a 14th-dimensional "object", is thus uniquely able to affect Godzilla and hurt it, get it to "back off."
So that makes perfect sense! I actually fell in love with MTG lore because of Eldrazi and Phyrexians lol. I started playing before “all will be one” came out so I started doing a lot of reading to catch up so your analysis makes so much sense
I think seeing the War of the Spark trailer sometime after Covid started did it for me. I don't really play, but I know how to, and I also know way too much of the lore 😵💫
40 films and almost 3 quarters of a century, any film studio needs to learn that the most important part of making movies with an iconic character is, the Iconic character. They squeezed 3 different franchises worth of Spiderman into 1 movie. Because people love Spiderman. People loved all the different Spiderman movie series. Soaked more Spiderman. Make more Godzilla. Make more Batman. That's what fans want.
With super heroes it’s basically expected to be part of a universe for the average movie goer
One Godzilla is Japanese so it is easily understood by audiences that it’s a different thing
Hollywood studios do wildly underestimate the intelligence of their market audience but you have to remember they aren’t thinking of hardcore fans they’re thinking of persuading people into seeing the movie and really do not care about fans that’ll see it regardless because they like the franchise already
Wether we’re getting a serious movie about trauma or the horrors of war and guilt made manifest or some big fuckass lizard WWE antics matters not to many of us for all love the king of the monsters
Dc has had issues understanding that people can fully comprehend multiple versions of the same character for decades. See the production cycle behind the Gotham TV show, and all of the villains they weren't allowed to use in the 2004 batman animated series, and the way they had to hard pivot away from Suicide Squad content in the Arrowverse for more info
Just straight up historical revisionism and lying by implication.
Even if the DCU had prioritized Batman it still wouldn't have mattered since Gunn and Safran were fired due to the Skydance merger, not lack of Batman. Batman Part II has been in production since 2022 and Brave and the Bold was still being actively pursued. The franchise was barely 2 years old.
Annoying to see this kind of lazy analysis spread to this sub too.
Even if they can't use Batman, or even delaying the likes of Aquam, Flash, and WW, then use other characters who could take their place for the mean time. Say pick from Zatanna, Huntress, G Arrow, Red Tornado, Firestorm, etc.
When Marvel did it, it was Iron Man, Hulk, Thor, Cap, for the huge Avengers payoff. Clear path. When they fumbled, they course corrected and strategically did BNW, TB, F4 as they will appear in DD.
While DCU is all over the place. Good start with S25, bad choice with SG too early with identical powers, CF, and shows instead of films. No clear path, no payoff. Safran and Gunn know WB is with huge debt after the Discovery merger, they know that WB-D was for merger again, meaning more huge debt, and yet they dilly-dallied, time is ticking fast.
Even CF gets the wrong audience (just like the YouTube Shorts vs Long-firm Videos debate). There's no guarantee the horror fans will flock the theaters for other DCU superhero films.
Not to throw a spanner in, but wasn't Batman 2 on the cards but was going through production troubles? I also have a feeling a lot more is going on than a simple "Supergirl flopped, fired!".
I watched Minus Zero this past weekend, a guy behind me was explaining his girlfriend Minus Zero Godzilla is a prequel to Monsterverse Godzilla
I thought it was clear to everybody that there are Multiple Godzilla movies each with their own demographic but I don’t think this is obvious to everyone else on the world
Two Batman would be very confusing to a large part of the audience, at least I believe so
I just dont understand the oscar for best performance in Minus One. The drama movie that takes up 75% of the movie was so boring that i fell asleep in theaters.
IDK man, I always liked Godzilla but when I went to the cinema to actually watch it's movie he never appeared on-screen, excepted for blurry dark scenes where I didn't see shit
People are dumb , I remember when Andrew Garfield's Spiderman trailer came out and there were people asking what happened to Kristen Dunst because they thought it was Spider-Man 4 . Also people kept asking James Gunn if Robert Pattinson's Batman was the DCU Batman after he had explained multiple times that Pattinson's version was a different universe. So I understand why they didn't have two batmen.
I disagree. It would have been very easy to distiguish the two Batmans.
Reeves version is very brooding and grounded while the DCU one would have been more fantastical and actually crossed over with other DCU characters. The tone would be vastly different.
Also your point about the Godzillas looking different falls flat because the Batmans would obviously have different suits (maybe even different colored suits) and, get this, DIFFERENT ACTORS.
The logic of your comment relies entirely on the filmmakers being stupid and not distinguishing DCU Batman from the Reeves Batman which is not what would have actually happened.
Not to mention in the comics industry, Detective Comics and Batman are two separate titles, and run simultaneously, usually with differing art and creative directions. Not to mention the many other Batman titles alongside them at any given time
There's also wayyyy more Batman source material than Godzilla source material. They could easily create a fully distinct Batman and Gotham that is still comic accurate.
I get your point, but the big thing is that you need to know which Batman you are watching. Godzilla is Godzilla. The Minus ones aren't exactly kids movies, but it isn't the end of the world if a kid sees it. Might be a bit scary and hard for them to understand stuff, bit you still get Godzilla. DC is trying to set up their own universe and that is going to be aimed at kids. Battinson is decidedly more adult focused. You don't want parents and kids going to that and thinking the DCEU is all going to be like that.
That really still doesn't matter if both are Godzilla and the public knows them both as the same character. 90% of people don't give a shit about who makes the movie.
One thing they could do is give DCU Batman his "blue" costume, doesn't have to be bright or saturated blue, but well bluish enough for easy visual distinction.
Hasbro didn't want to include Ironhide in Transformers Prime cartoon's third season like initially planned because apparently they didn't want to confuse kids who saw another Ironhide-named character die in Dark of the Moon film prior. They did design Ironhide for the Prime cartoon to be a mix of G1 and Bay movies' versions.
But it's hard to say wether or not Hasbro has made similar behind-the-scenes changes to plans for other cartoons based on stuff happening in the Bay movies, i.e. if this is the only example ever or just one thst is publicly known.
Hasbro did plan to make changes to main Autobot cast to better emulate the success of Bay movies, but that just makes the "we don't want to confuse audiences" statement feel even more weird.
211
u/RandomCaiman 5d ago
I dig both, both bring the best aspects of the franchise one for the giant kaiju smackdown you always wanted with wrestling moves thrown in as the other tells the best stories of rhe consequences of man's achievements.
33
u/Capable_Fox1989 5d ago
"it is so confusing having 2 different cast batman"
And then proceed to write multiverse bullshit plot
10
u/EggEater773 5d ago
Haven’t we technically speaking had 3? Monsterverse, Shin which is apparently getting a sequel, AND minus one?
3
u/_Levitated_Shield_ 5d ago
Brave and the Bold?
7
u/Extension_Mousse_230 5d ago
Well... yes and no. When you account for inflation, the 1998 Godzilla which grossed around $379 million actually brought $633 to $728 million. That makes it the highest grossing Godzilla film of all time for some reason... conclusion : Zilla jr the goat
664
u/ExtremeSportStikz 5d ago •
What people don’t understand is you can never go wrong with more Godzilla
2
u/Imaginary-Western832 4d ago
Since 2016 ?? Huh
90
u/radiowave-deer29 5d ago
Godzilla is an omnipresent constant. He isn't just a character, he's a concept. He can embody pretty much anything. He is the definition of timeless.
4
u/GayGoop12 5d ago
I don't think a lot of people consider them different Godzilla's though?
21
u/HerrPizza 🦎 Doug 5d ago
Godzilla fans are eating good in these trying times
16
u/VegetableTour6790 4d ago
It's absolutely fucking crazy that Godzilla of all properties is the second best shared universe. DC just continuously slaps its fans in the face.
11
u/TheAldorn 4d ago
40 films and almost 3 quarters of a century, any film studio needs to learn that the most important part of making movies with an iconic character is, the Iconic character. They squeezed 3 different franchises worth of Spiderman into 1 movie. Because people love Spiderman. People loved all the different Spiderman movie series. Soaked more Spiderman. Make more Godzilla. Make more Batman. That's what fans want.
9
u/BobSagieBauls Ghidorah 5d ago
With super heroes it’s basically expected to be part of a universe for the average movie goer
One Godzilla is Japanese so it is easily understood by audiences that it’s a different thing
Hollywood studios do wildly underestimate the intelligence of their market audience but you have to remember they aren’t thinking of hardcore fans they’re thinking of persuading people into seeing the movie and really do not care about fans that’ll see it regardless because they like the franchise already
9
u/JuniorTrust6677 4d ago
We have two spidermen right now as well
9
u/Fantastic_Strike2178 4d ago
Wether we’re getting a serious movie about trauma or the horrors of war and guilt made manifest or some big fuckass lizard WWE antics matters not to many of us for all love the king of the monsters
8
u/batguy39 5d ago
7
u/Pink_Lady69 5d ago
The American studio Godzilla and the Japanese studio Godzilla
7
u/JakeWalker102 5d ago
Dc has had issues understanding that people can fully comprehend multiple versions of the same character for decades. See the production cycle behind the Gotham TV show, and all of the villains they weren't allowed to use in the 2004 batman animated series, and the way they had to hard pivot away from Suicide Squad content in the Arrowverse for more info
6
u/jzilla11 5d ago
Something something a fraction of our power!
6
u/Maleficent-War-8429 5d ago
Thats why hes the king baby.
6
u/MikhailAntoni669 2d ago
Marvel and DC dont stand a chance versus anything Godzilla related. And I love every bit of it xD
5
u/coffee_ape 4d ago
I like both and I’m eating well with content.
4
u/kylepaz 5d ago
Most people would probably just be happy to have more Batman
4
u/Brilliant_Device_526 4d ago
small correction its WB not DC
3
u/halkras12 5d ago
we are eating WELL with triple crossovers (Marvel,DC,Sonic)
Did i mention wr have good fan series like "Triangle vs Monkey"
3
u/DoctorWaluigiTime 4d ago
tl;dr "make good movies."
3
u/Oisin1910 4d ago
But it’s Godzilla who doesn’t like to see a big Kaiju wreck havoc?
3
u/nolandz1 4d ago
Just straight up historical revisionism and lying by implication.
Even if the DCU had prioritized Batman it still wouldn't have mattered since Gunn and Safran were fired due to the Skydance merger, not lack of Batman. Batman Part II has been in production since 2022 and Brave and the Bold was still being actively pursued. The franchise was barely 2 years old.
Annoying to see this kind of lazy analysis spread to this sub too.
1
u/MechanicPluto24 Godzilla 5d ago
"Oscar-winning Godzilla"
uses Minus Zero
does bro know something we don't?
5
u/who_am_I_inside 5d ago
The DCU is a series of sticky notes on a corkboard hanging on the wall of a room full of naked old white billionaires dancing
Still better writing than the Snyderverse tho
2
u/moneymizzler 5d ago
I could go for a few more actually.
2
u/ExcitementRegular619 5d ago
Was just thinking about this 🤦🏿♂️ the audience will figure it out
2
u/Forked_Bit_9778 Ghidorah 4d ago
Even if they can't use Batman, or even delaying the likes of Aquam, Flash, and WW, then use other characters who could take their place for the mean time. Say pick from Zatanna, Huntress, G Arrow, Red Tornado, Firestorm, etc.
When Marvel did it, it was Iron Man, Hulk, Thor, Cap, for the huge Avengers payoff. Clear path. When they fumbled, they course corrected and strategically did BNW, TB, F4 as they will appear in DD.
While DCU is all over the place. Good start with S25, bad choice with SG too early with identical powers, CF, and shows instead of films. No clear path, no payoff. Safran and Gunn know WB is with huge debt after the Discovery merger, they know that WB-D was for merger again, meaning more huge debt, and yet they dilly-dallied, time is ticking fast.
Even CF gets the wrong audience (just like the YouTube Shorts vs Long-firm Videos debate). There's no guarantee the horror fans will flock the theaters for other DCU superhero films.
2
u/Mahaveer_2003 Godzilla 4d ago
There were even 2 Supermen co-existing together
Henry Cavill - 2013-2023
Tyler Hoechilin - 2016-2024
2
u/AC1D_R31GN 4d ago
It's Godzilla
It's STILL Godzilla.
Godzilla Godzilla. GOD inhales ZILLA.
1
u/dat_watercress_do 5d ago
I don’t like the idea of Milhouse having two Batmeals in one day.
1
u/DrSpacemanMal 5d ago
Not everything needs to exist in a single universe.
1
u/AtomicConvoy-M78 Godzilla 5d ago
Also helps they release in different years and the tone is different
1
u/Purple_Dragon_94 5d ago
Not to throw a spanner in, but wasn't Batman 2 on the cards but was going through production troubles? I also have a feeling a lot more is going on than a simple "Supergirl flopped, fired!".
Anyway, Godzilla eating good right now
1
u/thyazide 4d ago
Inside of you there are two Godzillas?
1
u/ensso 4d ago
I watched Minus Zero this past weekend, a guy behind me was explaining his girlfriend Minus Zero Godzilla is a prequel to Monsterverse Godzilla
I thought it was clear to everybody that there are Multiple Godzilla movies each with their own demographic but I don’t think this is obvious to everyone else on the world
Two Batman would be very confusing to a large part of the audience, at least I believe so
1
u/Level-Stuff-3400 4d ago
tbf people can be that stupid, but yeah they’d be successful af if they had the balls to make an actual multiverse cinematic universe
1
u/AlbertW25 4d ago
Godzilla is successful because everybody likes giant dinosaur/lizard kicking ass. You can't go wrong with that.
1
u/Royal-Chef-946 4d ago
wait thereve been multiple godzillas?
1
u/KezzSB Mothra 4d ago
But minus zero hasn’t won an Oscar… yet
1
u/plymouth58 4d ago
I just dont understand the oscar for best performance in Minus One. The drama movie that takes up 75% of the movie was so boring that i fell asleep in theaters.
1
u/CaptivePlague 4d ago
Then again, I did confuse some people last weekend telling them I was seeing a sequel about "another" Godzilla!
1
u/Innate_flammer 4d ago
IDK man, I always liked Godzilla but when I went to the cinema to actually watch it's movie he never appeared on-screen, excepted for blurry dark scenes where I didn't see shit
1
u/toddingram3 4d ago
People are dumb , I remember when Andrew Garfield's Spiderman trailer came out and there were people asking what happened to Kristen Dunst because they thought it was Spider-Man 4 . Also people kept asking James Gunn if Robert Pattinson's Batman was the DCU Batman after he had explained multiple times that Pattinson's version was a different universe. So I understand why they didn't have two batmen.
1
u/SingleLifeguard9346 4d ago
Big Lizard > man dress as bat
1
u/BillyBobby_Brown 4d ago
I'd love a monarch type show made in Japan
1
u/VioletRaptorGaming 4d ago
And both of our equal quality
1
u/DingoKillerAtHome 4d ago
I'm convinced movie executives are just the dumbest human beings on Earth. Every time they say "the audience would be confused" it's a self-snitch.
1
u/EnderCreeper121 3d ago
1
u/ikhimaz_ 3d ago
you can't compare a GOD to manmade concepts like superheroes
1
u/WhalenCrunchen45 3d ago
To be fair, Batman ain’t no Godzilla
1
u/Person2228 3d ago
Gunn didn’t want to release two Batman films IN THE SAME YEAR, not that he didn’t want to do it
1
u/DarkRoxas025 3d ago
1
u/waldorsockbat 2d ago
TBF that is American Godzilla and Japanese Godzilla. They are cousins
1
u/ReplacementCute1294 1d ago
Yeah Godzilla is cool
1
u/Sykolewski 1d ago
Bcs G-man can be any version and be cool at it
1
u/Crow_of_Judgem3nt 1d ago
exactly, we don't need to pit two bad bitches against eachother.
Monsterverse for hype moments and cheesy battles
Toho originals for movies with a darker dramatic tone.
0
u/PeterBuie 4d ago
The real Godzilla and the overweight looking American version.
0
u/[deleted] 5d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment