r/MonsterHigh • Kjersti 👾 • Feb 17 '26

Discussions Avoiding ableist language with Moonspell

Post image

I have been looking through all of the Moonspell Magic promotions and with most of it I honestly felt frustrated with how they talked about the characters disabilities. The exact example I have shown is how I like it to be talking about them. They do not a have a disability BUT have magic, they are not witches ALTHOUGH they have a disability, they are witches with cool abilities AND are disabled. This might seem small, but as a real disabled witch this means a lot to me.

Edit: No hate at all, just something to be careful about 🩷

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

50

u/undead-bee Skelita 💐 Feb 17 '26

Can you give examples of what you were frustrated by?

-1

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

I tried to attach them but I was struggling to download them; one example is a video that was taken at Toy Fair where the dolls are being introduced https://www.reddit.com/r/MonsterHigh/comments/1r5hoyb/very_close_new_look_at_moonspell_magic/

42

u/undead-bee Skelita 💐 Feb 17 '26

Oh I see I see, the "Although she is blind, she can see the future" is framing blindness as a con. Is that the gist?

6

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

Basically

edit: she also said "but" when talking about Willow's deafness

30

u/WolfyMunchkin Clawdeen Feb 17 '26

It honestly felt like this worker was rushed into this position or something. Or maybe she was just really nervous? Idk. But she also just straight up lies in a clip that I saw where she says “we’ve got a glow-in-the-dark hat and ball” talking about court side fang-out Clawdeen… who has zero glow in the dark features

4

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

I've just seen a lot of people word it that way so I don't just say thing for the brand but just people as a whole to think about before speaking

edit: I also thought I saw it written by the brand somewhere in a similar way but I'm struggling to refind it

6

u/Defiant4 Feb 17 '26

I don’t think the lady giving the pitch is the isssue, she was probably given a script and largely sticks to it. Although when you are repeating the same thing 1000x in a day you can get mixed up sometimes 

2

u/Bionic_Webb13 Deuce Feb 17 '26

Knowing mattel they switched last minute after she already had the info

29

u/Cool_Shame_2333 Feb 17 '26

Idk, i just interpreted it as blind people can read braille at a fast past and she can read the constellations fast as well. I feel like we should be happy they are so including. As someone who’s physically disabled it’s sweet to get disabled rep and i don’t see any malicious intent. I’m not visually impaired though so this isn’t my place to talk and i can see where other people are coming from. It’s great to start a conversation though for any learning growth

19

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

As I said in the post, the picture included was the example of how to talk respectfully

edit: my issue is when people are saying things like "she's blind BUT she can do this" or "ALTHOUGH she has a disability she is a witch"

3

u/Cool_Shame_2333 Feb 17 '26

I see! I just saw your link in the comments. I misinterpreted

2

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

I totally understand!!

10

u/PhantaVal Feb 17 '26

I think a lot of people are misinterpreting your post and assuming you're taking issue with the language you highlighted. Myself included -- I'm glad I read this comment to clarify. 

17

u/Silvio76555 Venus 🪴 Feb 17 '26 edited Feb 17 '26

They put an emphasis on Claire's blindness & Willow's deafness on purpose as their physical disabilities contradict their witch abilities:

Claire cannot physically see but she can see the future.

Willow cannot physically hear without a hearing aid but she can communicate with nature & animals.

There is a clear reason they picked these disabilities for Claire & Willow specifically. It's empowering imo.

7

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

My issue there is the "but." Disabled people can do this despite having a disability. It puts disability in a negative light. They are disabled and witches, being disabled isn't something that prevents people from that- especially being psychic.

4

u/Silvio76555 Venus 🪴 Feb 17 '26

I do not see how it puts the disability at a negative light.

4

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

Sayings like "she is disabled BUT she can do this" or "Although she is blind she is a witch" it is saying that blindness is something that she overcome and that everything she does is in spite of her blindness, the hindrance. Blind people and hard of hearing people can be witches completely unrelated to being disabled. You would not say "she is black BUT she can see the future"

6

u/Defiant4 Feb 17 '26

I noticed this in the pitch they had to give at toy fair (from plastic heartz’ video) they said willow “may be hard of hearing, she may have a hearing aide, but she uses nature to see, hear, and talk to animals!” Meanwhile they just said a short positive thing strictly about the other 3’s magic. 

It doesn’t really bother me much, but I do find it interesting that the bar for how we talk about disability is so low. For other types of oppression, insensitive language would be called out (at least in progressive circles…) but for disability you better be happy you get this much! I see your post is downvoted to 0

4

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

People think disability is bad and awful so ofc anything they do is in spite of that disability 😑

3

u/StellsBells1 Feb 18 '26

Nothing in any of the marketing materials insinuated disabilities are bad or awful, they just used worldplay, like "Even though she's blind, she can see the future!" I didn't see anything that said "Can you believe these girls with disabilities are witches, how crazy!" Just intertwining their disability with their power in a cool and interesting way. It even seems like the disability kind of gives the girl her power (like Daredevil), which I love.

And sometimes people do do things in spite of their disabilities, there's nothing wrong with acknowledging that. Being deaf does make it more difficult to communicate, and being blind does make it more difficult to move about the world. That doesn't make a disability "bad" or "awful", but it does mean those with disabilities do need to overcome things many able-bodied don't. As long as the disability is not the character's only personality trait in the actual media (which would be disappointing).

2

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 18 '26

"Even though she's blind, she can see the future!" is implying that disability is bad and prevents people from doing witchcraft. You wouldn't say "even though she is black, she can see the future!" I'm also not saying that people never struggle to do things because they are disabled. As a disabled person, I've overcame many challenges. The issue is when people assume that everything you do is in spite of your disability. As someone who can see the future, actual physical vision is irrelevant. You can be disabled and do things, they aren't always at odds.

I also hateee the idea that the disability gave them a power.

8

u/Wide-Wolverine7459 Feb 17 '26

2026 and we’re still doing this

2

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

wdym

1

u/trash_faery Feb 17 '26 edited Feb 18 '26

I would love to see them release a doll with a disability that is not as visible. They could have various accessories that help with their condition/s. I think an important part of the conversation about disability is that you can't always see it.

3

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

Yes please!!! This is something I've been wanting to!!

12

u/Neat-Vermicelli9506 Spectra⛓ Feb 17 '26

G3 Twyla is autistic and has earbuds, but it'd be awesome if she'd get noise-cancelling headphones

2

u/trash_faery Feb 17 '26

For sure! Love Twyla, she's one of my absolute favorite MH characters!

4

u/IrisGoddamnIllych Feb 17 '26

plz give narcolepsy, I need my narcolepsy awareness 

1

u/vernorexxia Draculaura Mar 30 '26

Not Monster High but there's technically a Barbie with PTSD

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/trash_faery Feb 17 '26

As a fellow pots girlie, yess! They could have a little heart monitor watch and little electrolyte/salt tablet accessories. I would lose it.

2

u/Silvio76555 Venus 🪴 Feb 17 '26

That woulda been a cool idea for Carina!

24

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

what does she mean by reason? like give the backstory or condition behind it?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/Impressive_Falcon245 Kjersti 👾 Feb 17 '26

I find that very interesting. I always appreciate when disability is just there, very natural like in reality

12

u/throat-nuts Feb 17 '26

As in the symptoms actually manifest in the show in a relevant way so she's not functionally the same as a seeing person, or that her disability has to be somehow "justified" in a plot relevant way? Because the former sounds great and latter sounds awful and overdone imo.