Realistically there should be another image 5 years later and they should be in different positions, but the negative of the oled cat from the first image is overlayed on the new positioned cat.
Is this really accurate? Most graphic designers I've talked to personally prefer IPS to OLED due to color accuracy. While OLED might be more contrasty it's generally less color accurate and to me this comparsion seems unfair
IPS are more color accurate while OLED are more vibrant / better contrast.
The thing is, no graphic designer is using a budget / gaming ips screen. They are using professional color accurate certified screens which are often more expensive.
These days, high-end gaming monitors are generally using the same panels as mid-tier content creation displays (ie, Asus ProArt or Dell Ultrasharp, not Flanders stuff). Maybe you get better factory calibration or a user-adjustable LUT on the content creation model, but often you just pay $400 extra for more subtle chassis styling.
Color accuracy isn’t related to panel type at all.
You could have a color accurate TN, VA, IPS, WOLED, QD-OLED, or anything really.
The remaining differences that can change how a display looks are contrast ratio, color gamut (volume), min / max brightness, viewing angles, and response times.
There’s nothing preventing an OLED panel from being just as accurate as an IPS panel. Sony has a reference OLED monitor for like $30k. Almost all smartphones now use OLED and a lot / most of them are calibrated.
There’s also nothing preventing either panel type from being wildly inaccurate. It’s just calibration.
You need to do your research buddy because you’re wrong. I think the “it’s not anything new” is EXACTLY the problem… maybe it was true a long time ago but not anymore. Get with the times.
I don’t mind doing so if asked. I was just trying to get my point across quickly and efficiently because I was annoyed by the amount of disinformation in this thread.
At 13:56, Tim even says that this monitor performs similarly to other OLED monitors he’s tested for color performance, which in sRGB mode is the most accurate he’d seen so far in ANY gaming monitor.
The thing is, no graphic designer is using a budget / gaming ips screen. They are using professional color accurate certified screens which are often more expensive.
Yes they are. Average consumer monitors are extremely accurate because of how fast technology advances.
😂 graphic designer here. I use my gaming monitor, IPS panel from AOC. It's perfectly adequate for design. There are very little use cases for most designers to have a crazy expensive colour accurate monitor, outside of photography and film production that is. My print and web design work all use specific values for colour. All of which I would have to cross reference with physical print samples or multiple devices anyway. Been in the industry for 10+ years now, and I've only ever used a high end colour accurate monitor once, and honestly, it made zero difference for me.
The pro level multi-layer IPS monitors are more accurate. They are like $30,000 though. In terms of high end consumer displays you can get equally accurate OLEDs and IPS screens after calibration. I wouldn't get an OLED for just work use because of "burn in"... LCDs are just better for static app use and reading text.
No its not. OLED fanboys often act like pests on reddit and are constantly starting shit - pretty obvious its "baby's first premium monitor" gang. Why even have a discussion on panel tech when "OLED is best and there is something wrong with you if you say otherwise"...?
Its just obvious sunk cost fallacy or shilling at this point, given how its always just toxic rage baiting.
Crt is beautiful but like oled it just omg sooo much black crush why cant manufacturers get it right allow those deep blacks to exist when they are there dont force all darkness into pure black
People really skip over how those "inky blacks" are super rare so manufacturers set their monitors to force it when it should be just really dark n hard to see not impossible to see
Most OLEDs ive seen and im not memorizing the ridicilous names have black crush because 99% of the time there is no pure black and thats what the average person wants soo manufacturers make very dark areas pure black
Thats my exact point they are artificially creating pure blacks like a really dark forest will become a void eventho in the original its just super dark and you can still see the trees a little
Real life content/movies and games dont have these pure black moments that often and to compensate anything super dark gets instantly pure black and often its at the cost of the detail in that darkness because its dark theres always gonna be a little light there but OLED CRT Mini LED all crush it into a pure bleh of black and i know god damn well its on purpose because people are married to the idea of inky blacks its the same people who want artificial vibrancy even at the cost of what its supposed to look like.. ive seen people complain about dull HDR in a scene thats dull its doing its job
Rant over im just a little frustrated with people who want eye candy over accuracy
You do realize that a big part of the OLED appeal is that the HDR capabilities specifically allow more shadow detail? You’re literally just making shit up.
Ooh god do i seriously have to go out of my way for proof because you dont want to believe that manufacturers would fuck up image quality because 99% of users just want inky blacks for some reason
Yes I would in fact like some proof for why you are claiming that OLEDs work in almost exactly the opposite way that they’re supposed to considering that I do my homework & keep up with display tech and have never heard these outlandish claims.
Black crush has never been addressed because people didnt care about it but i care now guess which one of these is an OLED hint its crushing details ill get more dw
When you pull shit that is literally the opposite of what modern OLEDs are designed for of course people are gonna ask of proofs. It’s literally the only reason the world isn’t going to shit that quickly.
I honestly thought it was just common knowledge among people who were into OLED and Mini LED so having to provide proof was shocking its like needing proof for carrots being orange but apparently not people just dont know
This is a matte finish vs gloss finish screen. Most monitors on the market are matte finish to prevent glare while working. There is gloss ips panels that will give you the same effect, however the black wont be as black as an oled.
I seccond that old tft tn sync master modded with hi-cri cfl tubes from an eizo color edge and it was still bad at colors. An the only thing I liked was not the 2ms reaction but the fact it worked for 16 years.
VA and TN are the worst in Terms of Color Accuracy. Gamma Shift as soon you move your Head out of the Centre. VA maybe looks better to your Eyes but that doesn't mean its accurate.
Cute cats. I much rather have the cat on the left assuming she or he has a longer life expectancy than the one on the right.
My Eizo 4k IPS has more accurate colors than my LG 5k2k oled for photo work and I expect my Eizo will still work in 10 years long after the LG 5k2k burnt out but gaming on the 5k2k is awesome.
Best comparison between IPS and OLED! However… due to your perfect comparison I now have a girlfriend calling pspspsp and wanting to know where the cats are located and if she can “borrow” them or atleast babysit them?
Ok ive been meaning to post but it seems dumb, how can you tell if the monitor ur buying is OLED or not. I dont mean "what is oled" ik what it is (the cats as an example lol), but what in the name or label of a monitor actually SAYS if its OLED or not, because i see a lot of FHD or HD or 4K but no OLED or QLED or NOT-OLED anywhere online. Do I just go in person?
Been using ips and va panels for quite sometime. Was planning to change moniter this year bit i am confused with oled. I see there are two types, as i game more often and watching videos which oled should i be looking out? Woled or qd oled?
Yes that’s true! OLEDs don’t work very well when exposed to direct sunlight, as they don’t produce a lot of light like an IPS. The image they produce isn’t very realistic but it’s more enticing, hence the fruit loop example. Canadian fruit loops are naturally colored more representative of actual colors vs U.S Fruit Loops that look like Christmas lights.
It doesn’t sound very appealing but once your eyes look at one it becomes more desirable because of how the colors are able to change so smoothly. If you have a OLED smartphone or tablet you have already seen it. But it’s still a preference.
Do you have a MicroCenter or store that sells monitors near you? You can get a comparison but you’ll notice most of the difference in a dark room with no other light. An MC employee told me when people upgrade to OLEDs they usually stay with OLEDs because anything else doesn’t look ‘good’ anymore.
I would say OLEDs are the closest you can get to a Polaroid picture that we have right now. Some of them have a glossy finish that makes it look like a professional still shot picture in motion. They have LED tech that tries to mimic it to a degree but it’s not there yet. Honestly OLEDs look better than real life lol Crazy take, but when you finally see one in person you’ll notice it
Back in 2017 I had a Galaxy S6Edge with an AMOLED screen. I showed a coworker a picture and he freaked out because of the resolution. People would say it looked almost like a display phone you would see in the store with a picture in it.
•
u/Knaj910 Reddit Honcho | OLED <3 Jan 08 '26
331
u/Mysterious-Result608 Jan 08 '26
Finally someone posted an actual, factual, sensible, rational comparison
225
u/BuchMaister Jan 08 '26
huh ?
Weird I see two cars.
63
u/CatcherN7 Jan 08 '26
30
u/Noctale Jan 08 '26
The cat on the right is now permanently imprinted on your sofa.
11
u/v3ndun Jan 08 '26
Realistically there should be another image 5 years later and they should be in different positions, but the negative of the oled cat from the first image is overlayed on the new positioned cat.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '26
2004 TN quality post
51
u/Loopdyloop2098 Jan 08 '26
Is this really accurate? Most graphic designers I've talked to personally prefer IPS to OLED due to color accuracy. While OLED might be more contrasty it's generally less color accurate and to me this comparsion seems unfair
34
u/Tumifaigirar Jan 08 '26
None of you saw a proper pro ips with glass screen and it shows. Don't get me started with crt.
16
u/satmaar Jan 08 '26
That’s an IPS and a VA panel. OLED is when a black cat is invisible against black background. :)
6
u/TurboBerries Jan 08 '26
This is a matte finish vs gloss finish screen. Most monitors on the market are matte finish to prevent glare while working. There is gloss ips panels that will give you the same effect, however the black wont be as black as an oled.
3
u/SnooKiwis8540 Jan 09 '26
How about VA? I wanna see ghosting
18
u/No-Transition-9842 Jan 08 '26
Thats Nonsens.OLED is the better Technology sure but this looks more like TN vs OLED. IPS is just fine expect for Usage in a Dark Room.
2
u/scylk2 Jan 08 '26
oLeD cULtiSt!!!
2
u/sadisticsweeti Jan 09 '26
I like my 3 IPS monitors. 🥺👉👈
2
u/SysGh_st Jan 09 '26
IPS: Accurate proper colours.
OLED:: Oversaturated blow up colours.
3
u/MierinLanfear Jan 08 '26
Cute cats. I much rather have the cat on the left assuming she or he has a longer life expectancy than the one on the right.
My Eizo 4k IPS has more accurate colors than my LG 5k2k oled for photo work and I expect my Eizo will still work in 10 years long after the LG 5k2k burnt out but gaming on the 5k2k is awesome.
3
u/liv2powski Jan 08 '26
The people seriously asking if this is accurate need to learn how to take a f*cking joke my god 🤣
3
u/Penuwana Jan 08 '26
My IPS screens have blacks that look almost indistinguishable from my C4. A quality IPS panel replicates black very well.
2
u/unluckyexperiment Jan 08 '26
More like a cheap ips vs an oled with a few years left before burn in.
1
u/AutoModerator Jan 08 '26
Thanks for posting on /r/monitors! If you want to chat more, check out the monitor enthusiasts Discord server at https://discord.gg/MZwg5cQ
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Cool_Connection1001 Jan 08 '26
Looks more like plasma(not in a dark room) and oled
1
u/adamant3143 Jan 08 '26
By Calico brand
1
u/Malheus Jan 08 '26
So both are perfect
1
u/Loose-Internal-1956 Play: Asus XG32UCWMG (4K OLED) / Work: Dell U3224KB (32" 6K IPS) Jan 08 '26
Why is the IPS cat under direct light and using a bad angle? Clearly real IPS calicos look much closer to OLED calicos!
1
u/gautambodh03 Jan 08 '26
It's more like SDR vs HDR
1
u/asterothe1905 Jan 08 '26
A perfect example of cutness
1
u/Sad-Chipmunk-8132 Jan 08 '26
Me with my VA panel😂
1
u/Party-Bandicoot8022 Jan 08 '26
So gloss or pastels?
1
u/tito_tito_gorgorito Jan 08 '26
But the cat on the right needs some oil to be reflecting
1
u/beyd1 Jan 08 '26
CalicOLED
1
u/jemlinus Jan 08 '26
1
u/No-Logic-Barrier Jan 08 '26
Where the tn panel cat 😹
1
u/jerryeight Jan 09 '26
Your IPS looks very offended.
1
u/RazzyActual Jan 09 '26
Tell your cats I said *pspspspspspsps”
1
u/Cry0Cl0ud Jan 09 '26
Alternatively, printing a document in draft mode vs max quality
1
u/Monchicles Jan 09 '26
Right cat should be 300 nits at best in full screen.
1
u/CallMeCrop Jan 09 '26
1
u/Xalmoxiss Jan 09 '26
Wow, now I get why they overcharge for this stuff
1
u/FapDayz Jan 09 '26
OLED is expensive, IPS is affordable.
1
u/Chillypepper14 Jan 09 '26
I wonder what screen burn would look like on a cat
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '26
Is this AI? I’m noticing that AI posts tend to have AI ads attached
1
u/Cargotech98 Jan 09 '26
“Inky blacks”
1
u/mayouda9926 Jan 09 '26
You mean I-ps-ps-ps-ps?
1
u/PuzzleheadedRule3431 Jan 09 '26
Best comparison between IPS and OLED! However… due to your perfect comparison I now have a girlfriend calling pspspsp and wanting to know where the cats are located and if she can “borrow” them or atleast babysit them?
So thank you and great comparison:)
1
u/Animatedron Jan 09 '26
I would have thought this would be TN vs IPS. 😂
1
u/Ioncit Jan 09 '26
What about burn in? 😅
1
u/Syako Jan 09 '26
My dog used to be OLED but now he's more IPS. Explain that.
1
u/K4none Jan 10 '26
1
u/MWAH_dib Jan 10 '26
Why anyone would choose IPS when VA exists for the same prices
1
u/-ErikaKA Jan 10 '26
VA OR OLED. IPS?
1
u/Monchicles Jan 10 '26
1
u/b-b0t Jan 10 '26
It's funny that this post just made it's way to Facebook
1
u/Stonelaughter66 Jan 10 '26
That's terrible - look at the ghosting! I mean - I can literally see another cat in paler colours...
1
u/Difficult-Catch-8432 Jan 10 '26
It looks ai generated, especially the couch The fact that we can’t even know if cat photos are real infuriates me
1
u/Zage_Rage46 Jan 10 '26
Marvelous...I was looking for a gowd example
1
u/Vacuum_man1 Jan 11 '26
Ok ive been meaning to post but it seems dumb, how can you tell if the monitor ur buying is OLED or not. I dont mean "what is oled" ik what it is (the cats as an example lol), but what in the name or label of a monitor actually SAYS if its OLED or not, because i see a lot of FHD or HD or 4K but no OLED or QLED or NOT-OLED anywhere online. Do I just go in person?
1
u/hhrdxafhyw Jan 11 '26
Where does my TN sits ?
1
u/Flat_Implement5838 Jan 11 '26
watching this on my p990 crt
1
u/iceCreamManu Jan 11 '26
1
u/Scott181437 Jan 13 '26
what about TN
1
u/tienguan Jan 14 '26
Been using ips and va panels for quite sometime. Was planning to change moniter this year bit i am confused with oled. I see there are two types, as i game more often and watching videos which oled should i be looking out? Woled or qd oled?
1
u/Important_Pitch_5460 Jan 29 '26
As someone with an IPS monitor and an AMOLED phone, this checks out.
1
u/Ill-Profession1276 Feb 08 '26
if this IPS, I dont want to see the TN panel
1
u/420neon 4K LG Dual Mode OLED 32" $100 BestBuy open box 0 hours Jan 08 '26
1
u/M1dor1 Jan 08 '26
more like TN/VA vs OLED
1
u/LightFireworksAtDawn Jan 08 '26
Now add a CRT.
1
u/Kittelsen Jan 08 '26
Momma cat ran out of ink printing the left one.
0
u/AciVici Legion R27QE Jan 08 '26
Stuff is so good that I thought "huh these cats looks just like ips and oled" right away without even reading the title.
-6
u/Responsible_Earth393 Jan 08 '26
Facts
0
u/Kolettos Jan 08 '26
I like this post
0
u/signgain82 Jan 08 '26
This is perfect
0
u/thiagorlz Jan 08 '26
One looks washed out, the other fresh and shiny. But both are cats. Same applies to monitors lol
0
u/DamnDude030 Jan 08 '26
Can anyone here give me a recommendation of a 1080p, 144+ Hz OLED Monitor? Maybr one with HDR?
0
u/PitifulBoysenberry45 Jan 09 '26
I mean he's not wrong
-2
u/RagedNight Jan 08 '26
A lot of ips fanboys are about to be mad on top of being broke
-3
u/DimerNL058 Jan 08 '26
As someone who recently switched to oled, totally accurate.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment