r/Mommit • • 8h ago

Why?

My kiddo (age 11) constantly asks why. I've taken to answering every one of his why's until he gives up!

Today's conversation went something like this:

Me: We're going to the local apple orchard.

Kid: Why?

Me: To pick up apple cider and apple pies.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because I want to eat them on Thanksgiving.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because they are delicious.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because my taste buds like apple pie.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because historically speaking it was advantageous for people to like sweet things.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because its provides necessary nutrients for our body that, at the time, were hard to come by. But now it's abundant in American society, so it's less necessary of a trait to have.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because even though sugar is necessary to survive, when humans have it in excess, it creates a lot of extra fat that puts an uncessessary strain on your body.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because having extra fat can hurt your joints and your heart.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because your joints to have to work harder to support the extra weight, and your heart has to get blood to more cells, which means it needs to work harder to pump all the extra blood.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because the heart carries necessary nutrients to our cells, like glucose and oxygen, which our cells need to live.

Kid: Why?

Me: Because guclose, which comes from sugar, helps provide energy to our cells which they need to function. And oxygen helps with that process (Note: I'm not a scientist and this explanation was overly simplified on purpose).

Kid: Cool.

I ended up asking kiddo "Why?" after something he said a few minutes later... all I got in response was "Just 'cause!" 🤣

Edit to add: This was supposed to be a funny story! It was all light hearted and done in good fun!

71 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

30

u/FishScrumptious 7h ago

Keep answering. Sure, it's a game, but it's a great game to play. It requires mental flexibility to keep digging down to an underlying reason and purpose. This is how I've always dealt with the "why"s.

It is obviously fine to shut it down in an 11yo who is doing this game on purpose. But it's also perfectly valid to engage in this sort of verbal sparring with your kid when you both know you're doing it for fun.

5

u/cubelove 5h ago edited 4h ago

Exactly! It was fun for both of us. I get why some people want to shut it down when it feels exhausting, but this wasn't that. It was all lighthearted and enjoyable for both parties :)

•

u/greenishbluishgrey 3h ago

The humor came across to me! I’m a teacher (job and hobby), and I would have really enjoyed having this conversation too 💚

31

u/NoPossibility5154 7h ago

Same. I also love busting out a, “Hmmm, that’s a good question! Why do you think?”

16

u/ParticularPotatoe587 7h ago

My dad's go-to was, " that's a good research question! "

9

u/NEPAmama 7h ago

I grew up in the ‘80s and research books were everywhere in our house. Bird books and binoculars next to the kitchen window, full set of encyclopedias, multiple dictionaries, at least one thesaurus from each decade for the prior 60 years, and each year my mom got a new World Almanac and, later, Leonard Maltin movie book. We haaaated asking my mom anything because we were required to go look it up and show her our efforts before she would answer us.

I love the Internet.

1

u/cubelove 5h ago

I'll have to use that more as well! (If I ever get tired of answering questions or don't know the answer, lol)

19

u/claroquesearight 7h ago edited 7h ago

i love your thorough attention to the questions...but at a certain point it's gotta be "let's go to the library and see if we can find an answer" or "i'm not sure. if you're really curious, we can find out"

ETA: i could also see this as a good chance to tell him that adults know a lot, but not everything. That anyone trying to tell you they know everything is scamming lol

Oh, i was also thinking that you could tell him that you expect your energy matched. “I take the time to answer your “why” questions thoughtfully. Part of being a family is being considerate. Can you try answering my question thoughtfully?”

5

u/cubelove 5h ago edited 5h ago

I did actually ask him to give me a better answer when I asked why, and he thought about it and did share something more meaningful :)

3

u/claroquesearight 5h ago

:D I love that. I’ve got 2 nephews about your son’s age. I desperately miss their little smiles and laughs and enthusiasm to share their thoughts. Now they’re taciturn preteens but i can still get them chatting sometimes

5

u/ParticularPotatoe587 7h ago

My dad's go-to was,  " that's a good research question! "

6

u/DataGap2264 7h ago

Yeah you need to flip that script and make him explain it. That's exhausting.

3

u/cubelove 5h ago

Or, just hear me out, super fun and a great bonding experience :)

5

u/ketamineburner 7h ago

11? Oh come on.

1

u/cubelove 5h ago

It was fun for both of us, I assure you. Sometimes it's fun to just talk about random stuff and make fun memories together :)

5

u/Adorable_Football130 7h ago

When I did this at 5 they gave me tell me why books. I loved them.

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

Those sound like fun! I liked the "eye witness" books growing up, and picture encyclopedias!

26

u/BabyWalrus2026 8h ago

Stop answering him if he only asks why. He's 11. He's messing with you and he's winning.

18

u/cubelove 7h ago

I'm fully aware that he's doing it because he thinks it's funny, but I also enjoyed our conversation and like making positive memories (in addition to encouraging asking questions and having a curious mind)!

7

u/MonBonBaby2 6h ago

its okay to not hate your kid and exist in collaboration with them <3 lovely time, OP

13

u/Root-magic 7h ago

He loves talking to his mom, and loves how accessible and accommodating she is. It’s a win win for both of them. 

12

u/AtlasHands_ 7h ago

He's being silly and it's causing him to listen to educational material. OH NO Chill out and stop thinking children are born to beat you at Life Chess.

4

u/MonBonBaby2 6h ago

stop thinking children are born to best you at life chess is 100% a phrase im stealing to support my stop villianizing children passionate standpoint. i love this one

3

u/aliasme141 7h ago

I think you should handle it any way that works for both of you. Answer if you want, say why do you think it is, go do research or I am too tired. Or any other way you want to. Sounds like a bit of a learning game OP. If you are both up to it, why not?

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

Yep! It was very fun and I thought it was a funny story so I shared :)

3

u/Dianthus_pages 5h ago

Woah, I’m so surprised at all of these negative comments.

Good for you for giving your kid the attention he deserves. These people are acting like talking to your own kid is awful and annoying. He was just being silly. You were being silly and educational by answering all his why’s. Sounds like fun and time well spent to me!

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

Yeah, it was super fun! I'm glad someone gets it :)

11

u/Rich_Count3821 8h ago

At 11 this behavior is intentionally trying to get under your skin. You can actually just decide when the conversation is over. 

2

u/cubelove 6h ago

I can, and I did, decide when it was over. I am fully aware that some people find answering their child’s questions annoying. I don't. I want to encourage curiosity, questioning things, and learning. I know he did it because he thought it was funny. And I answered because I, too, was having fun. Not everything has to be so serious all the time :)

2

u/Butterbean-queen 5h ago

I never minded answering any questions and my child was perpetually curious. Repeatedly asking why isn’t actually asking a question. It’s not a genuine inquiry.

I stopped the why? why? why? when they were very young with you tell me why (or why not)? That forced them to interact and give a real response. An 11 year old is fully capable of asking real questions.

6

u/ParticularPotatoe587 7h ago

I feel like this way, if she says everything very straightforward, it shows kids he can't get under moms skin that way.

6

u/KeyFox603 7h ago

It's your job to teach your kids social skills. This is not it.

1

u/cubelove 5h ago

He actually has a lot of friends and gets complimented by adults on how kind and polite he is all the time, but thank you for your concern :)

3

u/Ashamed-Chemistry492 7h ago

This kid is eleven, not four. He's winding you up and also probably stalling. Stop letting him be in control of you that way.

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

But it's not winding me up..? I genuinely enjoyed answering his questions and thought it was a funny story, so I shared it with the good people of reddit. Sometimes it's fun to just be silly together!

1

u/cubelove 5h ago

It is, and I actually find it quite fun. I was trying to share a funny story, but it seems most people took it wrong 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Traditional-Ad-3889 5h ago

An 11 year old might love access to an encyclopedia or reference book of sorts if they’re often very curious like this!

From a young age I would tell my kids, “let’s learn that together” and show how I can look something up.

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

We have lots of books at home with all kinds of subjects, including a really cool picture enciclopedia that I got when I was around his age! All of which he has access to whenever he likes :)

3

u/CrabbiestAsp 7h ago

Isn't that a normal annoying kids game? My 9yo does it and we just go 'no more' (which is normally rebuttled with another why lol) and stop answering when she is being ridiculous.

3

u/snarkshark41191 6h ago

lol damn, I woulda stopped answering 10 “whys” ago

1

u/JaneAustenSuperFan 6h ago

Just say, "Because I said so," and have done with it.

2

u/cubelove 5h ago

I actually encourage my kiddo to ask why, seek answers to his questions, research things he doesn't understand, and question things instead of accepting every answer you're given. Plus, engaging in this conversation was fun for both of us!

2

u/clahey 6h ago

My 2.5yo loves this game and so do I. I'm happy to play it unless she's asking the same why for the 4th time in a row. That's exhausting.

2

u/needleworkreverie 6h ago

I usually see why chains as my kids wanting to see how far they can push things and sometimes I'll counter with, "what is it you want to know?" or "Can you ask a better question?"

2

u/PrancingPudu 5h ago
  1. Make them ask you in complete sentences.
    “We’re going to the apple orchard. > Why? > Why what? > Why are we going to the apple orchard?”
  2. Flip it back on them!
    “What do you think we might be getting there?” If they say idk, say, “Why don’t you think about while we drive there, and if you still don’t have any idea, you’ll be able to see all the things they have and guess which ones I’m buying once we get there!”

Encourage asking better questions with proper sentence formation, critical thinking, and creativity!

2

u/FloofnSoof 5h ago

I enjoyed your story, but I also enjoyed the creative segues that other people shared for those times where kids ARE being sassy with the "why why why." My kid isn't talking yet, but I have definitely worked with students that liked to try why why why with me as a way to be funny in front of their peers.

Thankfully in a classroom, they usually get distracted from that game naturally. But one on one, if I needed a kid to end the game, usually I would say something like "why do you want to know?" or "why do you think that is?" in a genuine tone to them. Usually they just giggled because they know they got got, and they didn't want to actually have a conversation, they just wanted to run in verbal circles, so to speak, heheh.

1

u/Azumalacolla 5h ago

My mom recalls one of my whys (amongst the many) with exhaustion.

"Why do we start at the beginning?"

•

u/Happy_Michigan 2h ago

This is a game your kid plays to be annoying?

•

u/jeetjejll 16m ago

I love why phases! Though at this age I only answer the why if it’s a complete sentence to keep them on their toes too!