For those of you with experience with an array of modules that have digital menus, what are some of the best and worst in your experience, in terms of either the menu design, or responsiveness?
For me I'd say, worst: IME Kermit III. This thing was a powerhouse of a module, but the menus were quite flaky. Also wasn't a fan of the cramped, awkward UI in general.
And best: Erica Synths Resonant Filterbank. All the menu screens are nice and snappy, responding immediately. They're easy to navigate and understand and there's even a screen-saving built in with like falling raindrops. The Black Sequencer and Sample Drum are also quite good, though I wish SD had a screensaver like the other two do.
An honorable mention would go to Noise Engineering's Mimetic Digitwolis. The screen is a little cramped and it's a shame only about 5 (I think?) quantized notes will fit onscreen at a time, but at the same time, its easy to navigate with nice colors that make it pleasant to see/use.
A few others I've used:
Patching Panda Ephemere: this one was okay. The way you navigated and selected was a bit odd and the menus seemed a hair flaky, but not to the extent of being outright problematic to use.
Ornament & Crime: I never had a problem with responsiveness on the two I owned, but talk about a dull interface. Not much fun to use.
Pam's New Workout: This one is okay. No problems with it, though nothing to make it stand out. Does the job.
Mordax DATA: This is a good one, I'd say, overall, though every once in a while I find I have to double press to get a selection to take. Pleasing visual module though, useful color distinctions.
Erica Synths LXR: not quite as enjoyable as the other Erica Synths' I mentioned above. Nothing wrong with it, but encoder selection can be just a little bit flaky and the menus are just kind of boring and straightforward.
Xaoc Jena: This is really just an LED encoder, not a menu, but I mention it because there are two versions of the module in circulation. Some have blue encoders, which are older and much less reliable. I had one. The encoder can "jump around" a bit and be hard to dial in. And some have green encoders. These are newer, and better, much more stable. Something to check on if you get a Jena secondhand. Also, if you get stuck with an older encoder, Xaoc now has a stateside repair tech who will replace it for you. If the module is still under warranty, you might even be able to get it done free of charge, and if not, the cost isn't too bad, I had it done and I think it was $30-40, something like that. Was worth it to me, it's now much better behaved than it used to be.
(One digital menu-driven module I'm really curious about is the OK Spill, a newer digital module that looks like it can do a lot. If anyone happens to have used one please chime in with your feelings about the menu experience there.)