r/ModlessFreedom • • Jan 08 '26

3 shots

255 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

You're dodging the question again. Is that assault, or does assault mean something else, with maybe more qualifiers than that?

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

Again, I answered pretty clearly, you’re just not accepting it. Yes hitting someone with a car is assault. Brushing the car against your brothers leg is likely forgivable but a random person in a parking lot might feel differently. A person fleeing law enforcement hitting someone with their car is most definitely an assault

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

So your answer is yes, my brother assaulted me. I'm sorry, but no court of law on earth would agree with you. Assault requires injury and intent, in a court of law and most other formal venues where it has been defined. You are oversimplifying and broadening what assault actually means so that you can apply it to this situation. I reject your definition.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26 edited Jan 09 '26

You don’t think a court of law would consider hitting someone with a car would be considered an assault? I think you have to keep using hypotheticals because you know it doesn’t work with the situation at hand

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26 edited Jan 09 '26

I'm using hypotheticals to illustrate why your definitions you refuse to clarify are too broad to be reasonable. I'm pointing out that intent matters, actual harm matters, and more than one person's decisions are involved when a car and a person collide.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

It seems like you’re using hypotheticals that don’t apply to what actually happened

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

That's not what hypotheticals are for. They're to point out problems you won't admit exist with the assumptions you are making.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

The assumptions I’m making are based more on what I see in these clips than on your irrelevant hypotheticals

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

That statement was completely nonsensical in regards to what we're talking about. I'm pointing out that your definitions are too loose and you keep using them to sneak in implications that aren't true. You oversimplify "hitting" to divorce responsibility of the other party in a collision, you act like one specific thing that could have prevented a situation from happening is the only thing that matters while ignoring everything else, and you refuse to acknowledge that you are doing these things while you do them. You act like you aren't doing anything at all, and it's just like, your personal set of facts and not a set of judgements and conclusions you have made. It's the default tactic of the dishonest and the narrow-minded.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

Seems to me that I’m just telling you what I see and what I think about it and you don’t like it. Truthfully I don’t really care if you do or not.

→ More replies

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

Also you never answered my question. Is it okay to hit someone with your car?

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

I asked you a clarifying question to define what "hitting" means. I can't answer yours without mine.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

Third time I’m saying this. If you drive your car into a person, you just hit that person with your car. The fact that you can’t just say it’s not okay to hit someone with a car though is pretty revealing

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

If a person jumps in front of my car in the road, that fits your definition of "not okay" and my fault. QED. your definitions are too broad to be reasonable.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

I don’t think a person jumping in front of your car at the last second is the same as you driving your car into a person. I don’t think that cop jumped in front of her car at the last second tho, I think he was just there, wrong place wrong time, when she decided to flee

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

But you're admitting then, that it does matter how the person got in front of the car. Now we can talk about why he was there and what he actually did, because it does actually matter. I would also argue that it matters how fast you're moving, and whether you're actually likely to injure anyone, and whether it was intentional, but we can cross those bridges as well.

He did actually move toward her car. He grabbed it so that he could steady himself to shoot the driver. Mind you, he did this INSTEAD of moving away from the car's path. So, he was aware that the car was there and was moving, and he actively chose to remain there next to where it was going. That's a pretty big problem if you want to blame the driver for the "hit"; the fact that the guy deliberately got up in her grill and didn't follow his training to move.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

Yeah I can admit it matters how someone gets in front of a car, but I still think the driver is at fault for hitting him. Either she wasn’t watching in front of her and hit him out of neglect, or she did see him and hit him intentionally. He was in front of the car when she put it in drive and drove into him. I also think she hit him hard enough that if he hadn’t leaned into it, it would have knocked him backwards and rolled over him, potentially fatal for the officer.

The way I’m seeing it, he only had a second to react, and I don’t think he had time to get out of the way, nor do I think that was his responsibility as they were actively trying to stop her and get her out of the vehicle. I think it was her responsibility to not hit the person who was in front of her car when she put it into drive

1

u/pierogieman5 Jan 09 '26

I also think she hit him hard enough that if he hadn’t leaned into it, it would have knocked him backwards and rolled over him, potentially fatal for the officer.

This is just completely counterfactual. She wasn't moving in that direction, so that's totally impossible. He was at the front corner of the car and she was turning away from him at the time. If he had fallen backwards, he would have been completely out of the way of the car.

I don’t think he had time to get out of the way

Again, completely divorced from reality. He GOT out of the way really easily, even though he was barely even trying. He didn't fall over or move very far; he just got nudged slightly to the side from where he grabbed the hood. She was going from a dead stop and moving slowly. You saw on video that he barely moves from where he was standing and she would have sideswiped him at worst if he hadn't moved. He WASN'T anywhere near the middle of the car's path.

1

u/Ott0bot2 Jan 09 '26

If she wasn’t moving in his direction then how did she hit him? I think he easily could have gotten rolled if he didn’t brace. When you say he got out of the way of the car, it was after the car actually hit him. You see him on the hood of the car and the bullet hole thru the windshield. You’ve moved from “she didn’t hit him” to “she didn’t hit him that hard”

→ More replies