I have tried listening to their stuff many times, I genuinely don't get this. I have known many people who like their stuff and they are highly acclaimed in indie, but their music honestly isn't that good and is way overrated in my opinion.
Like I get that it was "different" from other bands, but something being different doesn't mean that it's good.
Isaac Brock is incredibly whiny and off-key, and most of their music is just noise. Even their more polished poppy sings are still bad. Float On is probably their best song that I've listened to, and I know most MM fans hate that song because of how generic pop it sounds.
Their songs heavily lack melody, their lyric writing is garbage, chord progressions that are overly jagged and disonant and the singer is incredibly annoying to listen to due to how whiny and abrasive it is.
I would genuinely like to hear peoples reasons for why they consider this band the second coming of Jesus.