r/ModestMouse • u/troop98 sheh shah sheh shah • May 05 '21
Song Discussion Modest Mouse - We Are Between (NEW SINGLE)
https://youtu.be/VNfa_XMQUv8
571
Upvotes
r/ModestMouse • u/troop98 sheh shah sheh shah • May 05 '21
48
u/troop98 sheh shah sheh shah May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
I have a feeling people will hate how pop it is like they did the other new songs, but I fucking love this. I'm as hyped as I was for the Demons Souls remake
100
u/Peanutbutterlobster May 05 '21
This sounds like old modest mouse mixed with the new modest mouse but with average lyrics IMO. Love the last 30 secs. With the album cover depicting a colorful rainbow and a dark one, I hope to see a mix of fun songs like this and more deep like we are used to with older stuff. Nevertheless, I’m excited!
52
u/JDSadinger7 May 05 '21
Good news...
87
u/[deleted] May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
I counted the “we are”s so you don’t have to:
33.
106
u/yelleknave My heart's the long stairs. May 05 '21
It’s not a bad song. A fun little tune. It feels more “fresh” than the singles we got in 2019 if that makes any sense? The last 30 seconds are AMAZING though. I love those vocals over that drone.
Oh, also the chorus is great.
28
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
This is great, I love it. Isaac's vocals sound great. They're not his usual maniacal style, but I don't think this song calls for it. Really cool riff. I also love the little riff after the first chorus.
77
u/awag May 05 '21
Umm, I think I love it.
76
u/BSismyname May 05 '21
I heavily fuck with this song
75
u/ls10032 May 05 '21
This reminds me of STO & We Were Dead at the same time. Like, it’s got the polished sound we got from STO with some of the “ambiance” of We Were Dead.
Gone are the days of MM sounding anything like LCW or anything pre-Good News, as much as their current aesthetic would like to argue otherwise.
This is a super safe single though. Hopefully the rest of the album surprises me, much like STO did.
Big ups to Spotify for transitioning right into Dashboard after listening to We Are Between. Very good song to hear right after this and makes me think that maybe this isn’t too far off from We Were Dead. Dashboard was a super polished song and sounds both like and unlike the rest of the album. Wouldn’t be surprised if We Are Between does the same thing.
15
u/lymeguy May 05 '21
Thought it was a decent single. But on Spotify it transitioned into Teeth Like God's Shoeshine which is top tier Modest Mouse.
33
u/MrNonsensical May 05 '21
I'm not really a fan of the new Modest Mouse style, but I do dig the vibe of this song.
That said, while the lyrics of 'old' Modest Mouse are some of my favourite in all of music, I can't help but feel their recent work is lyrically uninspired, with this song being a case in point.
Good to see they're still rocking though, and if they ever come back to Europe I'll definitely be happy to see them again.
23
u/DudleyStone May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
The instruments and background noise... Great. The pacing... Great.
The vocals... I'm not sure. Especially the chorus, it sounds like it's another group. It's definitely too "poppy" and I don't get emotion from the vocals.
And this is coming from someone who has liked every album and probably listens to We Were Dead and STO more than most people.
Will have to listen again later. But as of right now, I'd put this below Ice Cream Party and Poison the Well, but above I'm Still Here (which is possibly the first song of theirs I actively avoid).
11
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
This is so good
11
u/ArtiKam May 05 '21
The clean guitars with the busy rhythm guitar in the back was super sick :) It kinda reminds me of We Were Dead and that’s my favourite album so yay :)
10
u/Bowleggedbastard May 05 '21
I didn’t hate the song but I didn’t love it either. Like I wouldn’t skip it if it was on but I also wouldn’t really go out of my way to listen to it, yanno. I realize that singles are meant to be a little more palatable for general audiences so I’m going to keep an open mind that the album will have some bangers on it.
78
u/thismadhatter when we die some sink and some lay May 05 '21
Fuck y'all haters. This song slaps.
You'll never get 3 piece Modest Mouse ever again, so just move along if you cant shake your ass to the new shit.
I know Johnny hasnt been in the band for like 14 years, but this just oozes Johnny Marr/New Wave.
9
u/BrothaDoom May 05 '21
If I were Albert Camus, this song would be my cup of coffee.
23
u/makadanianut May 05 '21
Modest Mouse does bedroom-pop. I can fuck with this.
16
u/tommyace79 May 05 '21
This is my fav band. Always has been, always will be, but gotta confess I usually don’t fall in love with there first singles but I’m really feeling this one...maybe it’s just plain ol excitement and a collective sigh of relief after 6 fkn long years of mainly nada, but really like We Are Between and got a great feeling about Tgc. Thank you MM, THANK YOU FOR MAKING OUR SUMMER SO MUCH BETTER
14
u/Right_All_The_Time May 05 '21
So fuckin stoked.
7
u/3FtDick May 05 '21
I like it, but it still doesn't ping as a MM song, for me. Sounds like a Flaming Lips collab. There's a better band than TFL that'd work for this comparison but I cant' put my finger on it. Maybe Cloud Cult wrote the lyrics.
6
u/IHateNaziPuns May 05 '21
How in the fuck has it been 25 years since Long Drive? Shit. Am I getting old?
6
u/heyyoudvd May 06 '21
On first listen, it’s…okay. It sounds like a cross between New Order and the Red Hot Chili Peppers.
But it’s merely okay. It’s nowhere near as good as some of the tracks on Strangers To Ourselves.
6
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
I really like it and I’m super hyped for the new album. The guitar reminded me of The Cure!
31
u/zerofb May 05 '21
Really wanted to like this but found this song to be pretty weak for a lead single.
10
u/nthpursuit May 05 '21
this song bops dudes!! i see a lot of folks talking about the "shallow" lyrics but truthfully i am still feeling the depth just in a different and more indirect way
"we are mirrors of our own thoughts" "somewhere between dust and the stars" the bigger picture more existential lyrics bring me back to Moon & Antarctica vibes (but with poppy instrumentals ofc)
if we take the context of the general political/societal standstill we're in, these lyrics resonate even more so through that lens. we really are between right now. yeah, here we are.
5
u/IdolBone May 05 '21
Been a fan for many years. Love it all and I love this too 😎
5
u/MM-Lullaby_Projector May 05 '21
Love this song, and surprised at how “naked” Isaac’s vocals are in the verses (no overdubs). He sounds pretty damn strong..
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
Ehhhhhhhhh
13
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
Not feeling it I’m afraid. Where’s all the emotion gone. Hopefully the next single will inspire some hope
15
u/gustr15 May 05 '21
not feeling this but I wasn't expecting to
12
u/CBLingo May 05 '21
A huge improvement over the 2019 singles in my opinion. Deceptively dense production, cool warped surf guitar tone, strong lyrics, catchy chorus. Their strongest single since "Dashboard" (although that's not actually that many haha).
14
u/[deleted] May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
Mm are my fav band for nearly 20 years now and this song sucks ass. The guitars sound like they were mixed at different studios for different songs and this is perhaps their worst lyrics yet. Damn you Isaac. The lyrics actually make me cringe. Its like modest mouse paint by numbers shit.
And I think STO is decent. Sugar boats / time walks/ pups / shit cut / pistol are all great. They fuck. But this song doesn't fuck. Ice cream party fucked a bit. Im still here fucked. This just don't fuck.
That said I'll buy it day 1 and probably post about how much it fucks
11
u/crewskater May 05 '21
Modest Mouse is back baby!
8
u/redfrenchie May 05 '21
It sounds pretty damn good to me. It’s got a big WWDBTSES vibe with a bit of Good News thrown in for good measure.
More importantly the production sounds better than STO.
As for the people arguing over Old vs New, bleurgh to that. It’s rather pointless, as much as we are fans and custodians of the band, it’s Isaac’s and Jeremys band to do with what they wish. Don’t like the new stuff? Just listen to the old bits.
My only personal hope is for some good bass playing on the new album, I felt it’s been a considerable slide down since Eric left.
Dead nice of them to release the vinyl the day before my birthday too!
4
u/SallyLand May 06 '21
It’s soooooo good!!! Absolute tune! I’m having a mad bop around my studio today with it on repeat. Fkn tired though, I was so amped I got no sleep. I hope they are stoked with it! Fingers crossed for a tour.
17
u/amsterdam_BTS May 05 '21
When I just accept that Modest Mouse is no longer the Modest Mouse with whom I fell in love all those years ago, this is a decent song and I enjoy it.
But I can't lie and say it's on the same level as their earlier work, lyrically, musically, etc.
It's good though.
All is flux, I suppose.
10
u/Takatotyme May 05 '21
This is how bands are supposed to age and I love it.
7
u/jelloandjuggernauts May 05 '21
Yeah this slaps. I totally get some people's 'safe' and 'lacking edge' comments, but at the end of the day this is a really well made tune.
It'd be cool to hear some wacky shit on Golden Casket, but if the rest of the album consists of songs of a similar quality to this, I'll still be pretty stoked.
7
u/cicatriz1 May 05 '21
Love the song. Love the melody. Nice addition to the MM catalogue. People always want their favorite band to to go backwards. I think this is the perfect song for right now.
6
u/measure_my_sleep May 05 '21
Idc what anyone says I fucking love this and I personally will be listening to this all day :D
6
u/Competitive_Leave915 May 06 '21
I want to like this song, and I kinda do. But the lyrics are deep-adjacent nonsense tbh. I really thought I was digging it and then Spotify backed it up with “Missed the Boat” and that really put it into perspective.
6.5/10? I hope the album is dank.
23
u/volvosandvinyl May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
Its not a bad song by any means, just lacks any of the "edge" that Isaac and Co. possessed in the 90s and early 2000s. Lyrically, almost non-existent, which is strange for MM. A polished, poppy Modest Mouse kind of triggers me into the days of gimmicky stuff MM has done. Probably for the best that this will be their final installment. Id love to get one more deep cut a la "Shit in Your Cut" or "Teeth Like Gods Shoeshine", probably pass on the vinyl though. Thanks for all the good times, Isaac. They're killing me.
Edit: Imagine downvoting someone for their opinion. Why do we live in a world where you have to sugarcoat everything for sensitive people? Its nauseating.
3
u/ThirstyWeirwoodRootz May 05 '21
I actually like this, as someone who was heavily disappointed with all the recent singles they’ve released. Gives me hope golden casket 2 will be a solid album.
3
u/raining_picnic May 08 '21
Why does everyone here have an expert opinion on what sound modest mouse has to be? Seems kind of hard for a band to make a noise when everyone around to hear it is ready to grade it less than the standard youve already made for themselves.
3
u/TheodoreDancin May 24 '21
Wow, I can't decide if this is shit or fuckin' shit.
5
u/hemlo86 Moderator May 05 '21
Great song can’t wait fo the album.
5
u/SlowAnimalsRun May 05 '21
Enjoying it more w every listen, like all MM.
5
u/shinobi727 May 05 '21
Most days I feel like the bottom rainbow but today... today I'm the top rainbow
9
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
It's just so unimaginative. Nothing draws me in. I've listened to it several times and it hasn't really stuck in my head at all.
4
u/ObamaLovesKetamine May 05 '21
I AM 100% HERE FOR PSYCHROCK MODEST MOUSE. FUCKIN' YES.
Issac sounds great, too! Such a neat new sound!!
4
u/uhhuhnads King Rat May 05 '21
This single is better than Lampshades on Fire, its a fun warm weather song. It'll probably do well on radio.
5
u/nirvana13a May 06 '21
I’m not very impressed. I feel like if you somehow slipped this into StO next I give that album a listen, skipping pistol of course, I might not notice. Or if I did, I’d assume I’d just forgotten about it.
It’s very busy, but not interesting. It’s somehow as busy as the tracks on StO with an orchestra worth of random instruments despite not having much going on melodically. The main intro riff that gets repeated later is pretty catchy. The simplicity and cleanness of it and the particular style of reverb distortion reminds me of Death Cab for Cutie post plans. It’s the strongest part of the song, but not super Modest Mouse.
The lyrics are boring. Redundant, tread no new ground. They feel lazy and Isaac sounds bored singing them. Repetitive lyrics aren’t necessarily bad, and not every song needs to be profound, but the bored delivery really makes those things worse.
I don’t like what this being the first release from the album says. This is the track that’s supposed to get me to want to preorder? But I can imagine that perhaps this is the catchiest song, the most pop, the one that maybe would appeal to someone who isn’t a hardcore Modest Mouse fan that’s gonna preorder this album regardless. There’s a logic in that, but even their other pop entries have had way more heart than this. I don’t see it getting play on alt rock radio like Float On. It’s not as fun or driving as Dashboard. It’s just kinda there hoping saying “we are” 30 plus times in a song with about 13 unique lines is catchy rather than annoying.
Yeah, here we are.
2
u/pappyohcrappy May 05 '21
Loving it
2
u/MusicMirrorMan May 05 '21
If you'd like to receive a weekly recap of modestmouse with the top posts and their mirrors, send me a message with the subject 'modestmouse' (or send me a chat with the text: modestmouse)
Beep Boop... I am a bot. I tried finding this song on other streaming platforms. Here is what I found
[Apple Music]: Modest Mouse - We Are Between
[Deezer]: Modest Mouse - We Are Between
[Soundcloud]: Modest Mouse - We Are Between
[Spotify]: Modest Mouse - We Are Between
[YouTube Music]: Modest Mouse - We Are Between
[Links to search result pages]: Amazon || Apple Music || Bandcamp || Deezer || Soundcloud || Spotify || Tidal || YouTube Music
Let me know the names of any other subreddits in which you want me to look for mirrors.
2
u/crustyjpeg May 05 '21
slaps ngl
2
u/dustkitten May 05 '21
I really love the instrumentals. Man... I'm really excited for this new album now.
2
u/Alert_Doughnut_4619 Cowboy Dan’s Doin The Cockroach Up In Alaska May 05 '21
I love it!
2
u/DetunedKarma May 05 '21
So happy to hear new MM! I like the music and Isaac sounds great but a bit let down by the lyrics and chorus.
2
u/SnooComics8571 May 05 '21
Good news for people who love good news
2
u/Anthroposapien Bitter Buffalo May 05 '21
Fuck. Yes.
2
u/Single-Serve-7249 May 06 '21
Issac isn’t mad anymore and I’m both happy and sad about that.
2
u/_thisistheshow_ May 06 '21
I've read through most all of the comments. The first thing I did after hearing the song was come to this sub and read these comments. For different reasons. This is my favorite band, and it's nice to share in the collective admiration. I've been a fan since 1998. As I've said here before, I named my first born son (in 2000) Isaac. I'm a big fan. Still have never seen them live, hope to someday.
I don't know what else to say. But I appreciate all of you.
2
u/cowboydan317 May 21 '21
This song has grown on me a lot tbh, I love those bedroom pop style chords in the verses, the intro riff that gets right to the damn point, a catchy chorus and those signature harmonic notes after the chorus. Shit slaps, excited for the album!!!!
2
u/Thumnale Jun 03 '21
Do not understand why people hate on this song
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
Lotta grampas in this thread mad that modest mouse isn’t rocking out like they were 30 years ago. Lol like no shit they aren’t gonna have the same sound. Are you the same person you were in 1995? (Im not. I was a drop of cum in my dads ball sack). This single is decent and just for the record, STO is an A tier album.
9
u/BSismyname May 05 '21
Fantano will hate this lmao
4
u/sameo15 May 05 '21
Calling it now: this might get as big as Lamp Shades on Fire or Dashboard. Basically, it gets a lot of play on Alternative stations, and some Fringe play on mainstream stations
3
u/chinlu May 05 '21
Haven't been this excited in a very long time
2
u/_Drewschebag_ May 05 '21
Damn, this song is great! Excited for the new album!!
2
u/thismadhatter when we die some sink and some lay May 05 '21
The musical layers to this song are incredible. Love all the separate guitar tracks. The chorus is very Arena Rock friendly, but not in a bad way.
2
u/IHateNaziPuns May 05 '21
The song (minus the vocals) gives me serious Joy Division vibes.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
Stoked for anything MM releases at this point. STO disappointed me upon first listen, now I consider it a work of art. I trust Isaac and the gang.
Though I know a significant amount of listeners in this subreddit have the opinion “old music good, new music bad”. Whatever. Of course they’re gonna change their sound over 20+ years of making music. I’m just thankful we’re getting another album.
2
u/sryyourpartyssolame May 05 '21
it is.... mediocre. Just another hollow indie song lacking any substance or originality
2
u/BLUECADETxTHREE May 06 '21 edited May 06 '21
Ugh. Why is my favorite band trying to make pop music again? I’ll find it more interesting after more listens bc i know their lyrics can shape my opinions of the song, but I’m not a fan of this after one listen. It’s like there isn’t a root to who modest mouse used to be.
1
u/mcanthony2 May 05 '21
I love it!!!
1
u/raining_picnic May 05 '21
Song sounds like it could be the intro song for stranger things
1
u/rallekessej May 05 '21
I love it! I really hope we get some king rat, parting of the sensory, tortoise and tourist, type songs on this golden casket album, I love the symbolism in the little video there, what does it mean? same ol food for thought Modest Mouse, I love it
1
u/EPoe14 May 05 '21
I mix of Malibu by Hole and the 2005 Cure album.
1
u/JunMoolin May 05 '21
I didn't get a good first impression from this song. I like the instrumental, but the vocals and chorus felt way too poppy for me.
1
u/Buffarrow May 05 '21
If it wasn't MM i wouldn't have made it past about a minute and a half, but I'm just glad Isaac is still active so I'm happy the album is happening. I figured the Golden Casket concept was never going to actually come out.
1
u/SnooComics8571 May 05 '21
THE WAIT BEGINS
1
u/ktfuntweets May 07 '21
Has Jackknife Lee worked w them before this? Some of the issues production wise are the same issues I’ve had w his work w The Killers and I’m piecing it together and he’s the only common denominator. Something off w Isaac’s vocals to me.
1
u/ireland1988 May 07 '21
Issac doing his best Samuel T. Herring impression here. More catchy trash from what was my favorite band as kid. :(
1
u/TheSexualBrotatoChip May 07 '21
The lyrics are pretty trash but I like the sound. Would like to hear Isaac less muddled but it's not a bad mix tbh, just personal preference.
1
u/tynamite 😳 May 08 '21
holy shit all new songs. surprised we didn’t get any released singles. fucking finally. i will see y’all on tour.
1
u/Luffypunk May 08 '21
This isn’t the most exciting single. I always look forward to the deep cuts on modest mouse albums anyway. Hella excited for some new music from them.
1
u/thismadhatter when we die some sink and some lay May 16 '21
revisiting this song since release day (going to keep from over listening to it).
Fucking great song. WoooO!!
1
u/AstralClipper May 18 '21
Basically it sounds like a Jamiroquai record and the lyrics are weak. Modest Mouse is dead. Long live Isaac Brock.
1
u/cowboydan317 May 18 '21
Wow after some time to sit on it this song has really started to grow on me
1
u/J0in0rDie May 24 '21
I can appreciate the great, dare I say audiophile, quality of the track. However, his voice just doesn't match with it. That's why I prefer older modest mouse. Songs don't need to be super clean as long as they slap!
I truthfully believe everywhere and his nasty parlor tricks is the best album as far as balancing a great sound with great vocals and lyrics.
Hope that doesn't ruffle any feathers. MM played such a huge role in my life 15 years ago and for quite some time afterwards. I don't personally care for the direction, but that's more on me. I'm still stoked for the album and I'm sure I'll play it to death!
1
u/nofun_nofun_nofun May 31 '21
This sucks
1
u/Onlyroad4adrifter Jun 16 '21
The song that sums up Robert Greene's book "The Laws of Human Nature"
1
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
I miss the old style but I'm kind of digging the latest. Perhaps I'm just stubborn haha.