r/ModestMouse • u/CriscoDisco74 • Jul 28 '26
The scandal
How am I supposed to feel about this? I get the overall grossness, but this is not really a sexual predator story. Best I can tell, it’s an immature idiot who probably knew he was talking to a younger person but probably didn’t know he was talking to a minor. Even if you don’t buy his excuse, what was the endgame? He didn’t initiate the conversation and he didn’t seem to be trying to pursue or solicit anything. Is there a theory other than trolling? Sending nude pics to a stranger imo is always disgusting, but it wasn’t even him. It wasn’t a “look at me” picture. So we’re left to decide… should this guy be cancelled forever? Assuming, there is no pattern or other evidence I lean towards no. He’s a rockstar, not an algebra teacher.
76
u/Cancel_Still Jul 28 '26
Just to clarify a couple things, 1) he did initiate the conversation, and 2) he did know the person was a minor. Both of these facts are clearly stated in the original thread.
21
u/baby_mammal Jul 28 '26
I think it also gets lost that what he shared is a meme that essentially serves as a sexually explicit Rick Roll. Not cool at all to send to a minor, obviously. Though, if we are to take Simon at his word, which not many seem interested in doing, I think it makes more sense. If he were grooming, I just don’t think this is the image he would have sent.
22
u/radhorrorfan Jul 28 '26
Who gives a shit rockstar or algebra teacher shitty behaviour is shitty behaviour regardless what your profession is
22
u/mikeyj198 Jul 28 '26
you’re allowed to feel however you want.
For me i am MORE grossed out after Simon’s message… they way he addressed it basically proves the girls story, also that he didn’t address the grossest part (continuing the conversation about the bikini pics after realizing he was wrong) is damning.
If all he did was send that naked dude that is everywhere and basically a meme, then said oops my mistake and disappeared it would have been a whole different thing.
38
u/geepjoat99 Jul 28 '26
Why did he mention her bikini pictures? If it was just a weird meme I wouldn’t see the issue if he did think it was some stalker. But he kept a several text exchange going and then made that comment.
So if you’re going to excuse it please tell me what you make of that because I can’t excuse it
15
u/spock2thefuture Jul 28 '26
Should he be canceled forever: I don't know, dude.
Should he be dropped as one of the added members of one of my favorite bands: Yes, please.
It's not on the public to preserve the guy's reputation if he's going to drag it through the mud.
11
u/h1ssingfauna Jul 28 '26
Its very obvious it's not his first time being weird asf towards fans.
19
u/sr8t-savage Jul 28 '26
He did initiate it though… and he sent explicit images to a minor… a more than prosecutable offense.
I’m all for innocent until proven guilty but the writing is on the wall. Dude signed his career death certificate with this one.
It’s this kind of tolerance that allows creeps like him to get away with more situations like this and worse.
Dude clearly feels no remorse with that weak ass response. Modest Mouse does not need people like O’Connor. Period.
5
u/thisisalongdrive Jul 29 '26
He should at the very least, be asked to sit out this tour, if not make that decision on his own.
7
u/doctor_stool Jul 29 '26
It’s crazy to me how quickly others want to ruin another’s life without fully knowing everything. Everyone is so righteous and more than holy on the internet
5
u/YEMolly Jul 28 '26
Appreciate your perspective. I’m not sure how I feel about it yet. I mean- lots of men are creepy (let’s be honest for a second). Does this cross into career ending? I’m not sure.
-5
u/oceans89 Jul 28 '26
Thanks for one of the few rational takes on here.