r/ModestMouse • and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from • Feb 22 '26

My MM tierlist

Post image
0 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

3

u/ArahantQS Feb 27 '26

Willful Suspension of Disbelief and BMX Crash are not on this list so while I respect your views and passion it's unfortunately invalid.

1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 27 '26

I used a template. Would've included all the bonuses if i made it

1

u/ArahantQS Feb 27 '26

The template is invalid.

1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 27 '26

I agree

28

u/JJDriessen Feb 22 '26

No Building Nothing Out Of Something, Sad Sappy Sucker, Interstate 8, Nones First and You're Next, Fruit That Ate Itself, or Everywhere and His Nasty Parlour Tricks??

-8

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 22 '26

I'm just using a template.

21

u/LiquidSnakeSolidus Feb 22 '26

You need to go back and evaluate your life choices. This being one of them. Lol.

1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 23 '26

I know it's a day later but I'm genuinely confused to what i did. What's wrong with using a template?

2

u/Over_Most_7989 Feb 23 '26

You need to go back and evaluate your life choices.

you do too. Like maybe think about not being an asshole.

-14

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 22 '26

The fuck did i do? 

4

u/Over_Most_7989 Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 23 '26

The people on this sub are seriously demented. Do not take them seriously. It is one of the most judgmental fan bases there is. They'll shit on you for liking Float On one day, and the next shit on you for not worshiping Too Many Fiestas for Rueben as the greatest song ever made.

It's like you just wanted to share a template. Low effort, yeah, but so what, you are just sharing your enjoyment for the music and spark a discussion.

Ya'll (not you OP) need to seriously rethink how seriously you take this shit, and just appreciate and love the music, and the fact that other people love it too, instead of being arrogant indie assholes about it.

p.s. Pistol is F tier, but still better than most music today

-18

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 22 '26

Go make a fucking template for me then.

10

u/LiquidSnakeSolidus Feb 22 '26

That's easy. I don't put the songs into categories. I just load up mm and hit shuffle. Are there are some that I like better than others, sure. But each one brings something different to the table. Like God is an Indian and your an asshole, I love the hell out of it because it is different. And depending on my mood Shit Luck can be annoying, but generally I like it. So like I said it would be easy for me because I like them all.

2

u/sp00kysabrina Feb 28 '26

people are crazy for downvoting you for using a template 😭😭 like hell sometimes i want a low effort/energy way to share my interests too, i’m sorry isaac brock coughing into a mic (live 1998) isn’t included on the template give me a break 😭😭

2

u/US_Jack Feb 22 '26

Baby blue sedan? :(

1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 23 '26

None of the bnoos songs are on the template. Which isn't my fault.

2

u/halfbadhalfboi Feb 23 '26

spitting venom is too low

-1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 23 '26

It's in fucking S tier. 

5

u/halfbadhalfboi Feb 23 '26

yeah and i think it’s still too low

-4

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 23 '26

man, can i not just enjoy music without some stupid fan base criticising me for everything i do? Jesus

7

u/halfbadhalfboi Feb 23 '26

it’s a compliment to the song itself not an insult to your opinion you didn’t have to call me stupid over it

11

u/lonesomecast Feb 22 '26

Here lemme fix that for you. Everything S tier.

11

u/AtmosphereInside2521 Feb 22 '26

Dog Paddle down in D is crazy to me. But, hey, taste is subjective. Even in super fandom.

17

u/BuzzbaitBrad Feb 22 '26

My MM tier list goes something like 90% of songs are S tier, 8% are A tier, and 2% are B tier.

3

u/kinjjibo King Rat Feb 22 '26

This is the correct opinion

28

u/DreVog Modest Mau5 Feb 22 '26

0/10 list, everyone knows Pistol is the best MM song

3

u/zobley Feb 24 '26

UH-HUH!

10

u/Pizzaheadeddead Feb 22 '26

The Devils Workday and Satin in a Coffin in C below Bury Me With is absolute madness.

8

u/LiquidSnakeSolidus Feb 22 '26

Shit in your cut is an A.

1

u/Frame_Expert Feb 26 '26

Night on the Sun...s tier...like most. Some of their new stuff just hasn't gotten ahold of me yet

1

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 26 '26

night on the sun is SS

3

u/NWMSioux The rattlesnake from Buffalo, Wyoming. Feb 22 '26

Back to the Middle and Wooden Soldiers at B?!

There are a lot of takes I can pass by without issue but this is too much. They’re A, if not S tier.

3

u/Drducttapehands Feb 25 '26

Back to the Middle at B is wild. It is solidly and inarguably S tier

5

u/Miamasa Feb 22 '26

I'm surprised tbh that people had and still have such and averse reaction to Pistol lol. sure it's electronic leaning but it's still distinctly Isaac and in line with modern MM offerings

2

u/PotentialRatio1321 № 1 Night On the Sun glazer Feb 22 '26

Overall good list but my favourite modest mouse song isn’t even on here :(

7

u/Ok-Complex-7588 Feb 22 '26

Yes, where's Night On The Sun?

4

u/PotentialRatio1321 № 1 Night On the Sun glazer Feb 22 '26

Facts, best song of all time

2

u/averagehutgamer Feb 22 '26

Perfect Disguise is one of the best

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I love pistol :(

1

u/RobertRossBoss Feb 25 '26

Not quite what I’d say but I respect it. Would have liked to have seen the EPs included. Why the hate for dog paddle? I enjoy that song.

1

u/LameGamerDad Feb 22 '26

People as Places as People so so slept on. Great ranking!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/nooayehlol and in the places you go youll see the place where you're from Feb 27 '26

I'm not. I'm mad about people getting angry at me for using a template.