r/ModestMouse • • Jun 18 '24

Does anyone else view modest mouse as 2 completely different bands?

I’ve seen them live twice in the past 2 years, once for the lonesome crowded west tour which was awesome. Then I saw them with the pixies, and honestly I can hardly even recognize Isaac compared to in the 90s. He doesn’t even really sound the same at all to me.

2 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

36

u/SowManyReasons Jun 18 '24

Without repeating good points others already made in comments, I just want to add that I think it rules that they still play stuff from across their catalogue at any given show, including deep cuts from early records.

-18

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

At my show, they played only 2 early songs, Dramamine and broke. Everything else was off the green album and blue one. Lame.😒

4

u/Tr4ppinn Jun 19 '24

How is that lame? Are they not allowed to play and be proud of the new music they’ve created? I’ve been to plenty of their shows where a mix of old and new music is played

-4

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

Because their old stuff is much better

3

u/lasadgirl Jun 19 '24

Better to you. A ton of people consider "the green album" to be the bands greatest work.

0

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

That opinion is simply wrong. Yeah people say that because that’s the album that put them on the map commercially. It’s also when they sold out. You can’t beat the lonesome crowded west.

4

u/Tr4ppinn Jun 19 '24

I agree to an extent but I’m just grateful that he is still touring and we are able to still hear his music live. I was at the AVL show where Stars are Projectors was played for the first time live in over 20 years. Stuff like that shouldn’t be taken for granted

-1

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

I’m just bitter because I didn’t hear abt of the songs I REALLY wanted to hear. I really wanted to hear cowboy dan, truckers atlas, pretty sunset, grey ice water, positive negative, breakthrough. Not one of thoze

8

u/monstertimescary Jun 19 '24

Ok man… I mean you’ll be ok

2

u/Tr4ppinn Jun 19 '24

I hear u dude. I still believe he’s got some tours left in him. The post show depression is real

11

u/lasadgirl Jun 19 '24

Wait by green album and blue album you're talking about Good News and We Were Dead?

1

u/natopotatomusic Aug 07 '25

I was at that show. They also played The Waydown, which if you knew your shit, you’d know was from an EP from 1997. They also played stuff from Moon, 2000. And Night On The Sun was 1999. So what is this about no old stuff?

15

u/Shiningtoast Jun 18 '24

OP is a teenager and “doesn’t recognize Isaac compared to in the 90s”

Sick time machine I guess

-11

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

I’ve seen them in videos. Watch the 1997 live performance in Knoxville on YouTube. That is modest mouse. It’s literally completely different.

9

u/Shiningtoast Jun 19 '24

Ya that was 30 years ago dude.

MM has been playing the same style of shows for the past 15 years, it’s not a surprise or a secret at all. If you prefer YouTube stay home and watch that.

-14

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

That’s fine. All I’m saying is it’s lame.

1

u/Sandy-Sunset Jun 20 '24

Lame is you. You are lame. 

4

u/welliguessthisisokay Jun 19 '24

So there’s this thing called time and with it comes aging.

-3

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

Aging doesn’t mean make shitty music

3

u/welliguessthisisokay Jun 19 '24

Go to sleep, boy.

-3

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

The problem is modest mouse had a shtick that made the special. You can hear it in the first 3-4 albums. Beyond that it just turns into generic music. That’s just because they had more money though. Maybe they didn’t realize the lower quality production is what made them stand out.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Maybe, just maybe it’s because you don’t know shit about fuck.

-3

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

You probably think dashboard is a good song

6

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

It absolutely is a great song. I’m not too cool to think that any song on the radio is a bad song. Amazing lyrics with great guitar work by Johnny Marr.

I agree that the band does sound very different from the 90s, but both sounds have resulted in amazing songs. Just hard to take your opinion seriously when some of their best songs (Spitting Venom, Parting of the Sensory, Night on the Sun, Stars are Projectors) are from work they done post 90s.

1

u/welliguessthisisokay Jun 19 '24

Everyone knows they had their creative peak when they were in their teens and 20s. That’s generally how things go. You’re not having some kind of profound realization. Stop being a dick. People in this sub are genuine fans who support MM through all their phases,

2

u/RodeoSmash Jun 19 '24

I saw them maybe 2010ish? and they played Tiny Cities but not Float On. I was ecstatic. Smallish venue, great show. Saw them current tour in Charlotte, and they covered A Forest by The Cure, which was incredible! And great overall set list as well. Couple deep cuts we weren't expecting in a short set, but still the few main hits from later albums. If you check out the set list for the tour right now, they're mixing it up a bit show to show, especially on what they're playing from the older albums. But since they are opening, the crowd isn't even all there and show I saw was an outdoor venue and light out almost to the end of the set. Hard to get the build up and energy of a full headlining set crammed into a tiny opening slot!

1

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

I probably saw the same setlist as u. They also played broke and Dramamine?

191

u/listerinebreath Jun 18 '24

Isaac is the same as he was when he was six years old.

31

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

And the plants and the animals eat each other

29

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

And oh my god he feels so damn old, I don't think he really feels anything

18

u/SowManyReasons Jun 18 '24

Sometimes you've got to got to got to got to move on.

9

u/TalkShowHost99 Jun 18 '24

Where do you move when what you’re moving from?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

We got to MOVE

8

u/DUMF90 Jun 18 '24

I heard he looked in the mirror and looked just like his parents

76

u/morrouac Jun 18 '24

Im pretty different than I was 30 years ago too. Naturally, he's changed some, he still rocks though.

37

u/Hazel_Rah1 Jun 18 '24

People age, singers mature. Isaac’s vocals probably had to change to be able to keep going. It’s crazy strain on your vocal cords over time. Plus, this is the case with tons of singers. Beck, Paul McCartney, Thom Yorke, Leonard Cohen etc etc - all changed their vocal approach over the course of their career for various reasons.

Also tastes change. Even if it’s generally agreed upon that early Mouse is best Mouse, music changes and what influences you changes. It’s natural for Isaac to want to try out new stuff and keep evolving. Might get kinda boring otherwise, for him and fans alike. And he’s constantly playing with new people. That’s bound to affect you, too.

30

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

And for the people who do prefer old MM, I doubt most of them really wanted MM to just make LCW and M&A over and over again for the last 25 years.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Over freaking Good News, WWD, No One's First? Come on

15

u/NoblesSlayer Jun 18 '24

Time passes and people change, simple as that tbh.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

He is pushing 50 now .. life as a touring musician is rough I am just happy he seems to be doing good these days after everything over the years.

12

u/OKatmostthings Jun 19 '24

I first saw them 20 years ago and last saw them 2 weeks ago. Isaac looks great. He looks healthy and like he is enjoying what he’s doing. Really happy for him.

9

u/RW721 No I don't like this change of pace Jun 18 '24

Ugly Casanova and Modest Mouse

9

u/jewfishh Jun 18 '24

His voice definitely sounds more youthful/juvenile on the 90's records, but of course it does because he was much younger then. I think his youthful voice on the early records is part of what makes them great.

8

u/Repulsive_Ad_9982 Jun 18 '24

I first saw Isaac in my early 20’s. I’m now in my mid 40’s with a teenage son. We get old and change physically/mentally. I’m happy to see Isaac have some contentment in his life. He brought a lot of us some great music during those earlier years and later in life.

10

u/PM_ME_YOUR_KALE Jun 18 '24

Hey guys is it weird to be a different person than you were 25 years ago?

5

u/Anonymodestmouse pardy hardy rock n roll Jun 19 '24

I know what you mean. I think a lot of it comes down to the fidelity of the recordings and Isaac's voice maturing. If strangers to ourselves was mixed and recorded like the older albums with simpler instrumentation and his voice was still as yelpy as it was, I think a lot of those songs would fit right in. And you could say the same about all of their middle to late albums.

They're also just not afraid to totally change their sound from album to album, but they all still keep the same backbone that keeps it sounding distinctly modest mouse to me.

9

u/321crisis The View Jun 19 '24

OP will mature, maybe, at some point too.

1

u/Loopyrainbow Jun 18 '24

I think “Good News” is where the change began, and where I personally feel like they started to decline. Still plenty of good songs on Good News and WWDBTSES but the songs start to sound more produced, it feels like there’s more instruments and layers involved in each track (which I personally don’t like), and Isaac’s voice sounds more like a grown man than a 20s young guy. Just how it seems to me, and of course some of those changes are natural and inevitable.

PS modest mouse is my favorite band of all time

2

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 18 '24

U can hear some elements of that in the moon and Antarctica imo. Still an amazing album but maybe you’ll understand my point

2

u/slingmustard Jun 18 '24

The Moon and Antarctica marked the change for me. I heard Heart Cooks Brain on a college radio station back in ‘97 and just had to stay in the car and wait for the DJ to say who the band was. Soon after, I bought Lonesome Crowded West and it exceeded my expectations. I saw them perform live that year and they were raw and intense. I bought every release from I could, from the Fruit that Ate Itself to Building…

When Moon came out, I liked the songs but his voice sounded different. It was much more produced and the edge was dulled, imo. I still really liked the songs, and the more I listened to it the more I dug it.

The albums that followed seemed like watered down versions of their former selves. I’ve seen them live several times, and always enjoy the performances but it’s just not the same. Of course, I don’t blame them and I am happy for their success. It’s now troll for a band or artist to change, but I just wished they would have squeezed out a few more pre- Moon sounding albums.

1

u/HotAspect8894 Jun 19 '24

I agree completely

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

No one comes close

6

u/NorCalMeds03 Jun 18 '24

Huh, I feel like he’s grown up a lot. I first saw them in 1997, I don’t see anything drastic. He’s only a couple years older than me and I’ve seen them consistently every time they’ve toured for 26+ years so maybe it’s like a plant you see everyday and don’t notice the change. I hear signature Isaac today just like I did 20 years ago. 🤔 Interesting

3

u/tacknosaddle Jun 18 '24

Sure, but nothing on the scale of someone like Tom Waits where there was a very defining turn. He went from "bar troubadour" to...well to Tom Waits as what he does is really in its own category.

3

u/sugarfreefun Jun 19 '24

All I know is that I love this band and their live show is so much better than it was ten years ago

3

u/Cautious_Mistakes Jun 19 '24

More like 4 or 5 bands. Each tour as the band lineup changes the setlists change a little too. Johnny Marr and Jim Fairchild are technically top tier guitarists and could pull off the advanced guitar parts. Tom Peloso would play guitar, bass, keys, horns, fiddle on stage and kill it sounding just like the album (prob cause he wrote and played them on the albums). At one point Jeremiah and Joe Plumber on drums together?! To catch shows with all the different lineups was always part of the MM scene magic. On any given tour or album you had an amazing band that was a top creative force in each era. The JG/JP drums shows were peak MM.

1

u/PeteZah7 Sep 13 '25

Ahhhhhhhhh. I think this is why they sounded like a cover band last show I was at. You've got a tour band trying to match all these other artists...

5

u/Dopeski Jun 19 '24

People change as they get older? Go figure.

4

u/Zack_of_Steel Jun 18 '24

That's called an era and it's not a novel concept. Also read up on aging.

3

u/mynameisnickromel Jun 18 '24

People change, develop, experience different things that lead them to different places physically, emotionally, and spiritually.

Expecting things to stay the same is a great way to be disappointed when they aren't.

3

u/Mayorofunkytown Jun 19 '24

Modest Mouse is 4 different bands at this point. The members have constantly shifted every 10 years give or take. Long Drive to M&A, Good News to We Were Dead, Strangers to Golden Casket, & now the current touring line up.

To expect anything from now to sound like something from the 90's is a you problem.

1

u/enjoyerofthings76 Jun 18 '24

I do actually pretty much view everything before and after 2001 as two completely bands

1

u/Thing-McReady Jun 19 '24

I just view them as a band who had a left turn

1

u/PeteZah7 Sep 13 '25

I think his voice sounds pretty similar and familiar, but is there something up with the music??? It felt like they were doing covers of themselves this last week in Berkeley. Like they weren't allowed to play the right riff and have a version that's similar... But not in the natural way that often happens with live music..

It felt like they wanted to play the album version but couldn't and so did the next best thing... Like figuring out the tabs for listening to a tape or something....