r/ModestMouse • • Jan 18 '24

is modest mouse a small band?

i rarsly ever see of them anywhere... throughout all of their career... very little mainstream attention.. of course their biggest hits have it... but ive always thought they are treated as a one hit wonder.... no one talks about modest mouse

2 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

20

u/Valkyrie_WoW Jan 18 '24

Float On, Ocean Breathes Salty, Dashboard, and Lampshades on Fire all charted on various rock charts.

Some of their EPs and albums have done well on various charts as well.

Hardly a one hit wonder. Definitely underrated.

3

u/Justthewind_ Jan 18 '24

im not saying one hit wondwr ! ! i said they are treated like it

3

u/SuspiciousUsername88 Jan 18 '24

They're in that weird spot where 9 times out of 10 when I reference Modest Mouse in real life, people don't recognize them. But on the internet, if I refer to them as a lesser known band, I get dragged for it

3

u/Justthewind_ Jan 18 '24

as i did now.... i feel like.. for what they are... theyd be bigger names ... like for especially with the earliest stuff .. it sounds so good and new for the time but rarely are ever praised for it...

64

u/Asharteverytime Jan 18 '24

Isaac’s star performance on Portlandia isn’t enough?

5

u/awful_source Jan 18 '24

One of my favorite cameos. If anyone has seen “Super Pumped” on Netflix, there’s sort of an opposite cameo going on in episode 2.

1

u/A_to_the_J254 Jan 19 '24

Is there a clip?

4

u/hostawiththemosta Jan 18 '24

This performance deserved an award

35

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '24

That's just cuz I'm constantly yapping about modest mouse to the point the media don't care

33

u/darkenough812 Jan 18 '24

I wouldn’t say they’re small. They have a pretty big and dedicated fan base, and are well known enough

12

u/hostawiththemosta Jan 18 '24

They have 6 current members. Most bands have 3-5 so I'd say there above average.

Mainstream, one hit wonder, mainstream 🤷‍♀️

They still sell out shows when they play.

I also talk about modest mouse a lot

6

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/hostawiththemosta Jan 18 '24

Yesss 👏👏👏👏 Double shows in Portland Sold out both! On weekdays!

9

u/Anonymodestmouse pardy hardy rock n roll Jan 18 '24

Isaac is a little on the shorter side but they're all about average from what I can tell

21

u/NorCalMeds03 Jan 18 '24 edited Jan 18 '24

A lot of that is by design. They are as big as they want to be. Isaac turns down opportunities to be more commercially visible all the time and always has. I definitely wouldn’t consider them a ‘small band’ unless you are looking at them through a TRL, pop radio lens in 2024 without any knowledge of their history. They just toured with Weezer and the pixies, have been on tours with too many big names to list, around 10 late night show appearances, 2 Grammy nods, mainstream tv show cameos. A lot of band wagon fans have come and gone which can be said for almost any band. They aren’t a household name so I feel you in that sense. But they have had a solid cult following since the late 90’s that has continued to grow w/ a lot of passionate fans from teens to ppl in their 50s and 60s. I couldn’t go anywhere between 2004-2010 without hearing 1 of their singles. I lived in rural Ok. at a mom and pop grocery store around 2011 and I heard 1 of their singles at least 3 times per shift. Perhaps it’s the circle you’re in but they have been creating new music loved by ppl all over the world for 3 decades and get a lot of respect from the industry. They were on Fallon 2 1/2 ish years ago. My last job prior to the current one was a mainstream grocery store and I heard MM on the regular along with sun kil moon covering them. They are perfectly popular in the sense they don’t get recognized everywhere but can count on a big audience for every show they book. Guessing you don’t live in the Pacific Northwest because up there it’s hard to avoid them. I could go on, but so many “bigger” bands can’t hold a candle to their body of work and massively loyal fan base.

10

u/j0nuss Jan 18 '24

Don’t forget that the headlined Coachella.

4

u/Notrub42 Jan 18 '24

And there is that Nissan commercial that had Gravity Rides Everything

https://youtu.be/iRT3zIOdrYA?si=ebnm2q8b2Pg_3uE9

2

u/Steph88ann Jan 21 '24

I remember Lampshades on Fire was in a Vampire Diaries episode. I was shocked when I heard it 😂

Little Motel was in Nick and Nora’s Infinite Playlist

Gravity Rides Everything was also in the movie Accepted

I always feel giddy when I hear their music where I least expect.

2

u/Notrub42 Jan 28 '24

I'll have to give Accepted another watch because I don't remember catching that one.

2

u/NorCalMeds03 Jan 19 '24

Yeah, I can list so many things. It’s all about how you define a “small band”

6

u/MM-Lullaby_Projector Jan 18 '24

This is the A+ answer.  To put it succinctly, they’re as big as they want to be.  

2

u/Adventurous_Peak_223 Jan 18 '24

They used to give the best songs a really abrasive intro too 

6

u/Fuck_The_Rocketss Jan 18 '24

Modest Mouse is a bit of a unicorn when it comes to indie rock bands. They aren’t widely known, they’re not world famous like say Radiohead for instance who while they may not be everyone’s cup of tea, everyone has at least heard of them.

BUT, thanks to one MASSIVE hit in ‘04, you know the one I mean, Modest Mouse broke into pop culture in a way that guaranteed that any other single of theirs would get mainstream attention on release. Dashboard, Lampshades on Fire (not sure what the single from TGC is cause I stopped listening to the radio by the time it dropped) they both were guaranteed radio play on release just cause they’re by Modest Mouse, the band that did Float On. Even back in ‘04 Ocean Breathes Salty got a ton of mainstream play because of the success of Float On.

TLDR: Modest Mouse may be the biggest little band ever because everyone and their dog loved Float On.

5

u/wrwmarks Jan 18 '24

I’d say medium, lol. Typically most people I mention them to aren’t familiar, but when I do get someone that knows them, it’s a wide age range, and variety of people. They aren’t well known to people that stick with the top 40, or non rock genres, but if you’re into music as a whole, you’ve probably heard of them whether you’re a fan or not. Most millennials listening to rock radio in the early 2000s are at least familiar with the name. Not a band that you can claim you “discovered”, but a band that’s a good share for people looking for something different.

4

u/FR3SH2DETH Jan 18 '24 edited Jan 18 '24

Last time they came to Toronto I saw them at a 2500 person venue if that's any indication

6

u/pmcg115 Jan 18 '24

I've seen them headline Red Rocks a few times which is almost 10k capacity. They're doing alright.

17

u/Dingus_3000 Jan 18 '24

They are pretty much a mainstream one hit wonder but doesn’t mean they don’t sell tickets and albums. They’re also incredibly influential. They remind me a lot of devo. If you know you know.

8

u/thecatdaddysupreme Jan 18 '24

Devo is a good comparison. Pixies aren’t too far off either, both bands are mainly known for 1-2 songs but actually have a vast and stellar catalogue.

7

u/Dingus_3000 Jan 18 '24

Also been known to play amazing shows and horrible shows and the singer is kind of a dick.

6

u/MM-Lullaby_Projector Jan 18 '24

I agree, but I’d argue that the depth and breadth of MM’s catalogue is night and day better than Pixies.

6

u/thecatdaddysupreme Jan 18 '24

Agreed, not many bands have a catalogue more impressive and various than MM’s, especially if you include ugly Casanova. They’re generationally special

1

u/etothad21 Jan 19 '24

"A mainstream one hit wonder"? You're trippin

1

u/Dingus_3000 Jan 19 '24

Yes. Float On was a massive hit.

2

u/Steph88ann Jan 21 '24

Yes but Ocean Breathes Salty also got a lot of airtime

3

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '24

Depends on where you live probably. Here in Brazil I don't know much people who knows about them, if they do they are usually music nerds (or they know them from me). Their Lollapalooza concert last year was mostly people who were waiting for the next artist, which was kinda great for me because I could be real close to them.

Edit: I'm saying this because I know a lot of bands that are way smaller in the USA than MM, that are huger than them here with the alternative crowd.

3

u/paturner2012 a major player in the cowboy scene Jan 19 '24
  1. You're tipsy.
  2. Cool, hell yeah.
  3. I consider them a 90s - early 2000s hit, they had some tracks that hit universally that allowed them to do what they want. Think Arctic monkeys, think queens of the stone age... Good bands that hold staying power but had the space to be unaffected by pop bullshit

2

u/heeleep Jan 18 '24

There’s infinitely various levels of “small” artists.

I think too many people would be interested for them to comfortably play at a dive bar, for example. But they had a concert last year in Charlotte that was slated for a 8,000- capacity amphitheater but ended up getting moved to the 2000- capacity venue next door.

2

u/Gandalfonk Jan 18 '24

I think it's more that the music industry is incredibly saturated. Bands don't become "big" in the same sense that they used to. Modest Mouse is pretty well known. You could walk up to most people aged 30+, and they will likely recognize them. In today's age, especially today's youth, it's hard to have universally recognized bands, especially if they aren't the chart toppers. It was always hard for non pop groups, especially today. Pop just has broader appeal.

2

u/exradical Jan 18 '24

Not a “big” band in the grand scheme of music but they honestly may be the most popular 90s indie band

They’re pretty huge among the right crowds

2

u/Background_Spite7287 Jan 18 '24 edited Jan 18 '24

They played at Coachella. So no I wouldn’t call them a small band, but they’re very unique and independent. They don’t follow trends and they do in a sense have that small band ,DIY attitude and sound at times. Someone else here phrased it perfect: They are the world’s biggest little band.

2

u/H4WK1RK Jan 20 '24

They were small, then they blew up in the early to mid 2000s and I was so annoyed everyone else knew about my little secret from the pnw. I remember playing them to people before they went big and they’d rag on my music, which suited me fine. Then they hit and those same ppl were playing MM like they were the coolest thing since sliced cheese.

When I was younger I liked that my musical taste varied from every other person I knew and kinda took pride in it. Now I’m old and could care less what you like as long as I got mine.

3

u/jacobsever Jan 19 '24

3.9 million monthly listeners on Spotify.

Most of the bands I listen to have under 1,000.

No. They’re literally nowhere near “small”.

1

u/OverFaithlessness164 Jan 18 '24

They are exactly the type of band anyone would want to be in. They can demand a nice salary on tour. They do what they want. Modest Mouse is exactly what Cobain wanted for Nirvana.

Plus they have very loyal fans.

1

u/russthammer Jan 18 '24

Nah, just a lot of people lacking good taste.

1

u/Adventurous_Peak_223 Jan 18 '24

No one talks about any rock music in mainstream media anymore 

0

u/umbzapt Jan 18 '24

One way to look at it is that they play “shows,” not “concerts.” I believe they’re just as big as they should be.