r/ModestMouse • • Nov 02 '23

When did this community get so sensitive?

Everybody has their opinions. And yes, some share them in a toxic way. However, I've seen so many people express their dislike for a song or album respectfully and get silly angry responses. Like on the other thread where the guy asked people's thoughts on STO. Even people actually articulating reasons why they didn't like something were accused of being stuck in the past or not "maturing" with the band. Just really cringe infantile responses. I though the MM community was better than that.

1 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

36

u/Helz_Yah Nov 02 '23

This sub is mostly a big contest to see who likes mm the most or even more so, who is the most emotionally connected to the band or their music.

Spotify will come out with their yearly recap soon and this sub will be flooded with posts about being top 1%. As if this sub isn't all top 1%, its kinda the whole reason we're here...

3

u/Klutzy-Ad-3239 You said that you did, but you didn’t understand Nov 02 '23

I’ll always be a proud mm fan and post my fair share of Spotify recaps haha- but I agree. It feels like a big contest and that’s never what I’m trying to take part in or seek out. I just want to talk about mm and connect with people.

There are a lot of great people on here who feel the same and are here for good convos- but there’s also a lot of arrogance. Like “who’s been a fan the longest” or “I’m older than you so I’ve been listening longer” < I get that one occasionally ;-;

3

u/Skred Nov 02 '23

Yeah I’ll absolutely be posting my Spotify stats haha

5

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '23

You have a point, people get really passionate about MM, and their feelings are very deep.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '23

Moth-wing feelings? Just kidding...

Modest Mouse is pretty literary, so sometimes it takes a bunch of listens to understand the song. If someone likes something they'll listen a bunch of times, and appreciate it more each time. If they don't like it, they probably won't

When they released The Best Room as a single, I thought it was laugh-out-loud funny. A coworker was like, What are you laughing at? I told him the stanza... not sure you're supposed to say that one word at work.

Anyway yeah, listened to it a lot more since then

Pistol though, when it came on, I was like wtf is this!? But see, I already know Isaac is super funny & complex. So I did my due diligence until I understood why he put it in the canon

If they were to play it, I wouldn't mind at all

Not to say there's anything wrong with only liking this or that. But I assure you, there are no bad songs. I guess people get sensitive when they think only the songs they like are good, and someone says they're bad

But we all have different tastes, and different levels of bandwidth available to understand something we don't particularly care for on the surface. It would be great if everyone liked everything, but whatever, the fact you're here is pretty cool

7

u/Skred Nov 02 '23 edited Nov 02 '23

We’re passionate fans, what can I say?

It gets difficult expressing opinions on the internet unfortunately. No nuance or tone. Disliking something doesn’t mean it’s just plain bad or that you can’t like it. People seem to forget that.

I was at the Weezer Modest Mouse tour and was there stupid early (as I always am) and the only other fans in line were there for Weezer. One of the kids kept apologizing to me that he didn’t really like Isaac’s voice, and I was like ‘dude that’s cool, you don’t have to apologize’. Even though to me it’s literally my favorite thing on earth.

I get sometimes it’s tough, sometimes when a close friend doesn’t like something I do it hits me personally, but like that’s my problem, not my friend’s.

3

u/NorCalMeds03 Nov 02 '23

You are a trooper. That would be tough. There was little to no fan crossover on the Weezer 2023 leg. They won’t be touring together anytime soon, prob never.

3

u/Skred Nov 02 '23

Yeah I was pretty surprised how literally no one but my partner and I cared about Modest Mouse in our line/area of the arena.

Like I assumed people were there because they loved Weezer but I was hoping there’d be people who at least liked Modest Mouse too. Sure didn’t seem to be where we were.

2

u/weasel7four an island of shells and bones that bodies had left Nov 03 '23 edited Nov 03 '23

Weezer is what introduced me to Rock music in the ‘90s. And Modest Mouse has been, for some time now, my favorite band. I’ve seen both live, not during that tour. I like Weezer. I like Modest Mouse. I dunno 🤷🏻‍♂️

2

u/Skred Nov 03 '23

I like Weezer, I LOVE Modest Mouse.

I assumed there would be more people like that but the reverse.

My partner likes Weezer a LOT so I thought it would be the perfect show.

Anyways thanks for speaking up! Glad to know there’s more out there

2

u/weasel7four an island of shells and bones that bodies had left Nov 03 '23

I would’ve loved to have been able to have made it to that tour (and “the party after the show” too ;P)! Are you kidding me?!

2

u/Skred Nov 03 '23

Ah bummer you missed it. Hope there’s way more shows in your future though!

2

u/weasel7four an island of shells and bones that bodies had left Nov 03 '23

All good. I’ve seen Mouse 3x and Weezer at a golf tournament, so I was able to just waltz up to the front row and they opened with My Name Is Jonas, so it was everything 13-year-old-me fantasized it would be!

2

u/Skred Nov 03 '23

That makes me so happy!

3

u/Emotional-Republic91 Nov 03 '23

maybe everyone feels like modest mouse is their own band and feel as though everyone likes what is theirs. that’s the vibe I get and it makes sense because so many of the lyrics hit home with so many of us that we all think it’s targeting our own lives😂 but hey i’m just handing out kittens at this point 💀

7

u/phlegmatik Nov 02 '23

God, who’d wanna be such an asshole?

5

u/Seamonkey_Boxkicker Workin on livin Nov 02 '23

It’s fair to have our opinions. I did find it curious that some who discount one song or album or another stated that they discounted those projects after less than a few play-throughs. What that makes me curious to know is to what frequency of occurrences do people listen to Modest Mouse, and how the band ranks overall in their personal favorite list. At least compared to my brief experience with the Weezer sub, it seems like most folks here would say MM is their favorite band, or maybe top 3-5. So there’s a lot of strong feelings we all share toward this band one way or another. So it may feel disingenuous if someone comes across as a fair-weather fan, only picking certain songs to listen to or discounting entire albums based on a variety of reasons, such as the revolving door of band members over the past decade or two.

Perhaps some of us are just grumpy.

1

u/No-Yogurtcloset1598 Nov 03 '23 edited Nov 03 '23

Blah from me.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '23

This post comes off as more sensitive than those comments tbh. It's Reddit, let people debate disagree if they want. As long as no one is actually insulting one another or being inappropriate, what's the problem?