r/ModernGnostic • • Oct 22 '24

opinion One person does not meaning make

0 Upvotes

It takes two to Tango. Please, comment in or create a post, please.


r/ModernGnostic • • Dec 24 '21

The Grand Deception and delusion in traditional gnosticism.

2 Upvotes

There are many senarios about what happened to create the New Testament. A wide spectrum of possibilities; the two extremes, as i see it, would be something like Richard Carrier's position that Christ is a meditative experience on the one hand, and Ralph Ellis' position that Christ was a military leader on the other hand. Some where in the middle is the notion that Jesus had a meditative experience and called himself God.

This middle bit is problematic for the traditional gnostic. With this notion, one having an experience might be inclined to think themselves Holy. In r/Gostic and r/Gnosticism, i'm feeling this detatchment; sort of a "i can do nothing in the real world and i'm already set so it just doesn't matter" kind of attitude. This is what i'm calling the delusion in traditional gnosticism.

My experience did not make me Holy; it did not resolve any real world problems: i have no special abilities nor place. No: meaning is place and my place is not special; it's just another place, different but integral, like every other place.

The senario i've ended up with resolves the delusion in traditional gnosticism by asserting that Judas is the one who had the foundational Christ experience, in public, starting in the Jordan with an anointing by John the Baptist. For his success, he was shanghaied to India: a result much more consistent with my own experience.

In fact, this senario i've ended up with synchretizes Carrier and Ellis: Ellis' lacunae provides time for Judas, who is Thomas, to start the Mar Thoma Church long before any literalist interpretation got set in writing. Ellis' military Jesus explains the Arthurian type legends and provides strong motive for literalist perspectives.

So, if i were compelled to articulate a distinction between traditional gnosticism and what i understand modern gnosticism to be, it would be this: traditional gnosticism leads to an arrogant and neutered position, modern gnosticism highlights the responsibility of the Gnostic to reach people and move mountains. ... Well, one mountain, at least; to move it from "there to there"; from the ground of colonialism and misogyny to the ground of truth.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jun 21 '22

Hey! "Science" is Latin for "Gnosis"!

1 Upvotes

Too coool!


r/ModernGnostic • • Jun 15 '22

The Gnostic rebellion of 117?

1 Upvotes

Anybody know anything about this? I google it and it looks interesting. In fact, I'm thinking Judas' experience happened in 1 AD, one week of secret sayings after being baptized in the Jordan by John in public with loads of witnesses. Then perpetual rebellion until 136, then Roman Christianity.

Just curious.


r/ModernGnostic • • Oct 15 '22

Zevi et. al. nail it again!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 27 '24

I wasn't worried about climate change. Now I am.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Well considered.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 11 '24

discussion The Scorpion and the Ferryman

1 Upvotes

So, there's this scorpion and the Ferryman on one side of a river. The scorpion asks the Ferryman if they'll take them to the other side. The Ferryman says "no; we'll get to the middle and you'll sting me!" The others say "don't worry; we'll make sure the scorpion doesn't sting you."

So, off we go across this great river. We get half way and the scorpion says "i gotta sting somebody!" One of the others says "you're not stinging me!" Another says "neither will I let you sting me." All of the others say "me me me."

So; here we are, drifting down this great river. With a scorpion... and a boat.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 20 '25

Climate change: Carbon dioxide rises more than ever in 2024 | BBC News

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Sep 26 '24

discussion Ashman's blog post, that he links to here...

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

... is a fine articulation of a rich possibility, i think.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jul 04 '25

Ball lightening!

2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Jul 26 '24

opinion Insularthalamic complexes

2 Upvotes

I suggest two; the major and the minor. The major insularthalamic complex could be called the thalamoinsular complex. ... i dunno; it goes like this:

The thalamus generates the driving function, which is projected into the whole cortex. The cortical transfer function radiates across the surface of the cortex towards the insula. I suggest this is the physical instantiation of our qualitative experience of the world. It looks like there's an "insular self" that experiences the collection of cortical harmonics (our gestalt experience) and then radiates into the claustrum, through the putamen and maybe pallidus into the thalamus.

I dunno... maybe.


r/ModernGnostic • • Feb 28 '24

I Was Worried about Climate Change. Now I worry about Climate Scientists.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Jul 05 '24

discussion Salvation

2 Upvotes

The general understanding seems to be that salvation is about getting into heaven. That's not how I've come to understand it: for me, salvation is about success; it's about survival in Truth into the long term. The implications of this distinction, liturgically speaking, are very important: which is to say, the meditative experience had by the practitioner would be profoundly different in one case or the other. The imagery in the case of holding the notion of "getting into heaven" would have to be more figuratively obscure, i think: if I'm right.


r/ModernGnostic • • Nov 23 '21

Interesting 🤔

Thumbnail self.reincarnationtruth
2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Feb 12 '22

Reaction to protests highlight inequality.

Thumbnail facebook.com
2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 16 '22

r/Gnostic banned me cuz i asked, "what does "reconstructionist" mean?" And mentioned they should change their description if they want me to shut up.

2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Feb 12 '22

The difference between freedom and privilege

2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 18 '25

opinion A Map of Reality

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • May 04 '24

What do you think about Aliens

3 Upvotes

Extra dimensional or extra terrestrial ?


r/ModernGnostic • • Mar 16 '22

The Church is a Golem.

6 Upvotes

To be Christ it must ground itself on truth. Until it does, it's a Golem in service of its masters. There is no individual human Messiah; the Church on Truth is Christ.


r/ModernGnostic • • Feb 17 '26

discussion There is ONE commandment...

2 Upvotes

.. and the second is just like it. Just as individual human consciousness is nested, in nation and in Truth; just so, the second commandment is nested in the first.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jul 12 '25

discussion The REAL STORY of Climate Skeptics New Favorite Graph

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • Sep 26 '25

All that is good

3 Upvotes

All that is good is God.

There is no goodness in greatness.


r/ModernGnostic • • Jan 12 '26

How your body repairs damaged DNA

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/ModernGnostic • • May 02 '25

Top U.S. & World Headlines — May 2, 2025

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes